17 ms·
The Untimely Demise of Workstations
- simonh 6y agoLinux killed the Workstation vendors stone dead. Sun seemed to be very aware of the problem and fought really hard, but they couldn't cut off Linux completely. I went to a seminar by an Open Source hacker at a Unix user group conference in the late 90s, where he talked about the Sun funded work he'd done on getting the Linux kernel to run well on Sun workstations. He was absolutely clear that he thought Linux would kill Sun because it completely undermined their software license business, but that this was their problem. They just had no good options. I suspect the reason IBM was able to reconcile with Linux and even go all-in on it was that it complemented their lucrative very high end server and mainframe businesses. Their workstation businesses benefited from a halo effect from the super high-end mega-systems that protected it from becoming total road kill, but Sun and the other vendors never really managed to establish themselves at the super high-end, so when Intel ditched Itanium and PCs caught up with RISC they were left without a market.
- sien 6y agoThat and Intel hardware became better than what the workstation vendors had. Around 1999 SGI Octanes were about 50K, at the time NT machines (think Intergraph) appeared that were, for many, many purposes, just as capable. They were 10K. In addition the MIPS chip was considerably worse than a dual proc x86 machine of the same vintage. I was working at a company where there was a C++ API. Compilation time on the SGI was 2 hours. It was 10 minutes on the Intergraph. When cards like the Nvidia Quadro and FireGL cards came they were better than SGI machines and cost a few thousand dollars. This guy worked for NEXT, who were eaten early because they produced massively overpriced workstations that there was a small market for. They didn't even survive the workstation market, let alone the coming wave of better hardware from very large development budgets for mass market parts.
- jacquesm 6y ago> That and Intel hardware became better than what the workstation vendors had. Exactly. As much as I liked the environment the premium you paid for what was sub-par performance really killed the market. And when SGI ended up selling intel Windows boxes the writing was on the wall for them as well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SGI_Visual_Workstation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SGI_Visual_Workstation I disagree that next got 'eaten early' though, effectively every Mac you've used since those days was a Next workstation marketed under a different brand. Next morphed into Apple much more than that Apple acquired Next.
- simonh 6y agoWithout the Apple deal NeXT were toast, just like all the other workstation companies. They just didn't have the resources needed to elevate NS to the level of polish of OSX, or the market power to engage that may developers on their own.
- jacquesm 6y agoConversely, without the NeXT deal Apple would have likely been toast. That worked out for the best for everybody involved.
- eatmyshorts 6y agoI am not so sure. At the time I thought BeOS was a better purchase. I wonder what could have been if Apple had gone with Gasse instead of Jobs.
- jacquesm 6y agoAt a guess it wouldn't be the most valuable company in the world today.
- itomato 6y agoSteve knew how powerful and essential networking was to the compute paradigm we accept. Be’s TCP stack was never very good. It never had big money applications like Frame or Illustrator, and lacked the robust dev platform (and paying customers) that Next had.
- rhrusps9vnfnds 6y agoLooking back, it's not like there was anything uniquely fast about x86. They just had more money, so they won.
- mobilio 6y agoIt's little bit funny because once upon a time MIPS CPUs powered workstations. Today they're mainly used for low-end cheap routers, because high-end market is occupied from ARMs.
- tinus_hn 6y agoNeXT was bought by Apple who took its software, which still lives on as the basis for Objective-C in the NS... (Nextstep) classes.
- bluedino 6y agoIt's actually Next-Sun....the original classes were NX, for NeXT
- meerita 6y agoI always wanted a SGI, but the price was so privative for me as a student. I learnt that those workstations got outdated really quick and cheap pc market was gaining more and more power competing with SGI until it was eaten totally.
- fit2rule 6y agoI collate a retro collection which includes a small portion of SGI machines. I'm still kind of astonished at what those humble little 100-megahertz MIPS things can do. It feels like it took serious chutzpah to build a 3D product suite on this platform .. but yet, SGI did okay for a while. I always wish they'd made a titanium laptop. If someone at SGI had any real artistic integrity, they would have done this the moment the world caught wind of Steve Jobs' fire at Apple 2.0 .. but yet again, another highly talented pool of people, subjugated to the military industrial complex, just sucked all the sex out of the box.
- cameldrv 6y agoThis is really the answer. From about 1990 to 1996, RISC workstations were several times faster than PCs, especially in floating point performance. However, when Intel came out with the Pentium Pro in 1995, it had better integer performance than almost all of the RISC chips and was about even on floating point. With Windows NT and Linux being viable operating systems for the sorts of applications people used workstations for, it was only a matter of time before workstations died out. The main thing holding back Intel machines by 1996 or so was software support for workstation type applications such as EDA and CAD tools, but this was sorted out within a few years. The last holdout was SGI, which was used in the visual effects industry, but NVIDIA caught up to them in about 1999 and SGI gave up on its performance leadership, and the applications followed.
- curt15 6y agoIsn't this a perfect example of how "interoperability" can't possibly be a fair use exception if APIs were to be deemed copyrighted? The easier you make it for existing users to switch to your product, the greater the market effect you'll have on the original owner of the API.
- adrianmsmith 6y agoI'm sure Linux killed off proprietary server OSs. But "workstations" are specifically desktop computers, and Linux on the Desktop is not what took over. There are many reasons for the demise of workstations, mentioned in other posts, but I don't think that Linux was one of them.
- bayindirh 6y ago> ...and Linux on the Desktop is not what took over. Depends on where you look. In academia and scientific computing, the landscape is completely different. Most of the software is written Linux-first. Because it's both easier to move on to clusters and open source philosophy (GPL & MIT licenses) is more prominent than ever. A lot of the cutting edge tools are open source and there's a strange model in some: Software is free, code is open, but for research you need a license. You need to give your license number in your publication otherwise it might get rejected and/or retracted and you'd be fined by the company developing the software. Forking is not feasible since both the software is well known and developing that kind of scientific software is very hard (to put it mildly). Yes, MATLAB works everywhere but, MATLAB is not the peak scientific software. It's generally the base camp where you start. If you want MPI even for local runs, you're in *NIX land, squarely. There are also other interesting software, like Singularity which can run containers as non-privileged users and some software (like OpenFOAM) is also available as a prebuilt container.
- tinus_hn 6y agoHow can the software be free if you need a license for some purposes? Or does it just cost $0?
- danielheath 6y ago"Free for noncommercial use" is a common license for IP outside of software.
- bayindirh 6y agoVirtualbox comes with PUEL (Personal Use and Evaluation) license, which makes it free for non-commercial use. Java is (was? still is?) free for non-commercial use only. Even if OpenJDK is present. There were some other software which I was using but, forgot their names (since I don't use them anymore).
- TMWNN 6y ago>I suspect the reason IBM was able to reconcile with Linux and even go all-in on it was that it complemented their lucrative very high end server and mainframe businesses. Linux also gave IBM for the first time an OS that ran on all its hardware, from low-end x86 to POWER workstations to xSeries/iSeries minis to mainframes to supercomputer clusters, a goal it achieved with System/360 in the 1960s then soon had to abandon when the minicomputer and PC markets emerged.
- imglorp 6y ago> Linux killed the Workstation vendors stone dead I don't buy this entirely. I'd agree it ate into the market share, yes of course it did. And the blurring of commodity server and desktop hardware ate further. What Linux didn't replace was accountability: there were plenty of shops which needed hardware vendor supplied and supported OS. It wasn't a technical decision, but a checkbox their customers demanded as some sort of due diligence checkbox. Then Redhat arrived on cheap hardware and ate into that share further, because they checked some of the boxes. Sparc and Solaris was still technically superior for some things and still had all the throats to choke. What changed for Sun was Oracle buying them: jacking prices; buying all the competitors to control them like Sleepycat, TimesTen, and MySQL; suing customers; suing security researchers; suing benchmarkers; and charging triple (not an exaggeration) to reinstate lapsed support contracts etc etc. "We're a Sun Shop" was not longer the appeal it once was on the server, and of course nobody would need a desktop Sun with those downsides.
- toyg 6y ago> What changed for Sun was Oracle buying them SUN were basically forced to sell or face bankruptcy in a year or so. Their market was already gone by then. They were completely uncompetitive against Redhat and commodity x86, and they knew it - hence the big opensource push, which was too little too late, and the overall feel of confusion they were projecting. There was just no reason left to buy SUN for anyone but the most hardcore Solaris geek. In hindsight, they should have tried to pivot to services, instead of focusing on releasing free software in the hope it would drive hardware sales.
- alrs 6y agoNo need to pivot, they invented cloud computing. https://www.computerweekly.com/news/2240061933/Sun-enables-online-grid-computing-utility https://www.computerweekly.com/news/2240061933/Sun-enables-o...
- swatson741 6y agoIBM and Red Hat weren't really in competition so, it makes sense that Linux mostly benefited them. I don't recall ever seeing anyone use an IBM workstation. The only places I've seen them used is for kiosks and POS.
- simonh 6y agoI used one a bit in the mid 90s when I worked for the Forestry Commission here in the UK. It was running a specialist scientific application I can't remember anything about. I only worked on it to get it connected to our network, access NFS shares and connect to printers. It was incredibly expensive compared to the Suns. It had an administration interface that was just a set of bash script menus for running various commands to do basic admin activities. I ripped it off and converted it to C Shell to simplify some stuff on the Suns for some of the less technical staff. That was one of my first moderately complex shell scripts, so thanks IBM.
- alrs 6y agoA workstation is not a desktop PC. I can guarantee you've never seen a workstation used as a kiosk or a POS.
- jabl 6y agoNo, I don't think Linux killed the Unix workstations. The workstation market mostly shifted to x86 + Windows NT. What Linux + x86 did kill was the entry- and mid-range Unix server market. Redhat grew very rich largely by offering a cheaper platform (x86 + RHEL) to run Oracle RDBMS. And when the web started taking off, Linux + x86 was the default platform (still is). Similarly, the technical computing market (clusters, supercomputers, etc.) more or less completely migrated to x86 + Linux. IBM sort of survived this carnage by retreating into the high end, and by having a lot of other business (consulting, mainframes, software, etc.) that they could leverage. Sometimes I wonder if Sun could have survived if they had gone for the x86 commodity hardware route. They already had built the first generation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun386i https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun386i ) but instead decided to go all-in on SPARC and bespoke hardware.
- ghaff 6y agoYeah. Windows NT and commodity x86 killed Unix workstations. That's where the software support was. I'm actually not sure to what degree Linux "workstations" became a big deal. You have Linux clients but most of the software ran on back-end servers.
- dkarl 6y agoI can't claim any authority on this topic, because I only witnessed the tail end of it as a clueless junior dev, but one thing I saw at a couple of companies was Linux creating a less risky path to commodity workstation hardware. People with Unix-based computing workflows saw that they could achieve something similar on Linux on commodity hardware, and the hardware was cheap so it was wasn't a huge risk to try it out. After they were successfully working with Linux and could see that the commodity hardware was sufficient for their workflow, then it wasn't so radical to cast their eye over to Windows and see what software was available there, maybe be tempted by more polished desktop software and easier IT solutions for businesses. And they could try it out by dual-booting their existing Linux workstations. I'm sure some people made the double jump straight from commercial Unix workstations to Windows, but for people who did not want to take any big risks, Linux broke up the leap into smaller steps.
- 6y ago
- bluedino 6y agoNT killed the workstation market. Once you saw the applications ported to NT (CAD, GIS, 3D graphics), people realized they could run them on much cheaper PC's. You would be able to buy 4 Pentium II's running NT for what a single Sun/SGI would cost. Hell you could buy two PC workstations for what a graphics upgrade cost on the SGI machine.
- vidanay 6y agoYou could buy 20 x86 workstations for the cost of a EDS/Unigraphics workstation (Running on DEC Alpha)
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoAnd you could always use a Hummingbird X server to run critical apps remotely off the *nix servers.
- justin66 6y ago> Sun seemed to be very aware of the problem and fought really hard, but they couldn't cut off Linux completely. Given how baffling Solaris x86 was as a product (is it supported? is anyone at Sun taking it seriously? is hardware coming? are they all breathing swamp gas over there?) over the years to those of us who really wanted to like Solaris x86, this seems like a pretty generous comment. I think you're right about IBM. I don't know if they were the least poorly managed of the Unix vendors, but they had some real customers because of their mainframe business. They definitely deserve some credit for stretching Linux to that hardware.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIBM wasn't the least poorly managed. It's just that they weren't a workstation vendor in the same sense. IBM had some Unix workstations, but that was never their core. Their core was mainframes. IBM could lose the Unix workstation business without blinking. Whereas Sun, SGI, etc., if they lost the Unix workstations, they were dead, because that was who they were.
- justin66 6y agoThere was a time when it wasn't crazy to think that Sun might be able to survive on the basis of a strong server business. https://www.zdnet.com/article/server-sales-sun-wins-the-battle-but-ibm-the-war-5000114605/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/server-sales-sun-wins-the-batt... That was never really true of SGI.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYeah. Sun wanted to be internet servers (along with workstations); SGI wanted to be render farms along with workstations. But internet servers were a lot bigger market than render farms. Which left SGI with the workstation business. I remember that some guy at SGI wrote an article titled "Pecked to death by ducks", that argued that SGI would never be done in by commodity hardware - that commodity hardware wasn't powerful enough, so it would be as absurd as being pecked to death by ducks. Then dual CPU machines came out, and so he wrote a sequel: "Pecked to death by ducks with two bills". In the end, though, SGI got pecked to death by 700-pound, 15-foot-tall ducks - the commodity hardware got better faster than SGI's did. But in the mid-to-late 90s, I loved SGI machines. Not by 2005, maybe, but in their day, they were great.
- fit2rule 6y agoChina killed the workstation vendors, yo. Cheap and easy PC hardware, self-assembled, simply started to kick ass in cycles much more aggressive than the ivy-league boys and pencil-pushers who ran the Big Iron companies could deal with.
- loopz 6y agoSo everybody using laptops and VMs didn't kill workstations? Typing this from a workstation with 64 GB RAM. Maybe not a lot these days, but this comp is ancient by now and still chugs along nicely.
- OliverJones 6y agoIn stories of the demise of workstations, don't forget September 11, 2001. Sun Micro had made a spectacularly successful push of their products into what we now call Fintech. But a vast installed base fell with the Twin Towers, along with a vast maintenance revenue stream for Sun. A lot of replacement equipment was ordered from large manufacturers of commodity computing products. Are those highly capable devices workstations? PCs? I think they're both.
- etaioinshrdlu 6y agoThis all made sense to me until the end. It sounds like the author wants to just build pc’s that are customized, which one can totally do without trouble. I’m not sure what there is to lament except maybe a lack of processor and OS variety?
- MrBuddyCasino 6y agoGot the same impression. He writes: > In high-tech domains, an engineer could readily have a toolchest of suitable computers in the same way that a mechanic has different tools for their tasks. This one has an FPGA connected by both PCI-E and JTAG to allow for quick hardware prototyping. This one is connected to a high-throughput GPU for visualisations; that one to a high-capacity GPU for scientific simulations. Thats just different PCIe cards. You don't need a dedicated vendor for that, just a screwdriver.
- synack 6y agoEven USB 3.0 is fast enough for many of those use cases and makes it much easier to mix and match devices to get the right balance of portability, power consumption, and functionality. The only remaining problem there is untangling the cable squid on your desk.
- MrBuddyCasino 6y agoUSB 3.0 maybe not, but Thunderbolt 4 is, as it can tunnel PCIe traffic at 32Gb/s.
- baybal2 6y agoIndeed this is how it's done. Especially given how fragile/buggy the "professional" software is, or is limited to DOS/Win98/ME/XP/2000, or need an exotic driver for PCI-to-PCIE converter, hardware license key etc. I worked in companies where EDA, HDL, EE instrumentation machines were purposefully left running 24*7 just because the lengthy ritual of applying the needed set of hacks to get them running. Or because Windows update was killing a certain Labview function. My favourite was a PC with a sticker "DO NOT PLUG INTO INTERNET UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES, WINDOWS UPDATE PIRACY DETECTOR WILL TRIGGER CADENCE ANTIPIRACY DETECTOR"
- keyle 6y agoI feel like I've read this article, every decade.
- Deukhoofd 6y agoOff topic, but what a horrible font. I had to switch to reader view to actually be able to read the article.
- jonathanstrange 6y agoIn Firefox Preferences>Fonts and Colors:Advanced uncheck Allow pages to choose their own fonts, instead of your selections above. Problem solved.
- frou_dh 6y agoNot just off-topic, against the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jacquesm 6y agoI went from an SGI workstation that fully decked out cost more than my car would have cost new to a Linux based PC that cost much less than $5K at the time and ended up with twice the computing power. Graphics took a while to catch up though, and it never felt quite as integrated but there is no way that justified the price difference.
- arethuza 6y agoAt one point, 1990 or so, I used a high-end Sun workstation that cost about the same as the flat I lived in at the time. When the RAM was upgraded an engineer flew from London to Edinburgh to install the upgrade! A few years later I downloaded Slackware onto multiple boxes of floppy disks and installed it on my PC at home and got a comparable development for a tiny fraction of the cost. Mind you, the screen wasn't quite as nice...
- varispeed 6y agoWhen an engineer takes a flight to install memory, it is clear that you are being over charged. These companies milked their monopoly position quite well.
- arethuza 6y agoThe memory was from a 3rd party supplier, not from Sun. People on the same project drove from Milan to Edinburgh with their equivalent workstation in van to give one demo....
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThis is what it what it was like back then. I used to travel up and down the country installing systems and often wondered if there was somebody driving in the opposite direction to do the same job somewhere else.
- arethuza 6y agoYeah - my first job (in 1988) was mostly travelling about installing new software and fixing problems with various breeds of Unix/Xenix systems. Remote access was pretty rare.
- a-dub 6y agothe joke of it is that apple won the unix wars. i'd be shocked if they haven't shipped more unix workstations than all the other vendors combined and they're certainly the last vertically integrated workstation vendor standing. (they just didn't call them that) as far as linux on the desktop, that never quite happened... but again i'd wager there are almost certainly more handsets running android on linux than desktop pcs in operating existence.
- forest_dweller 6y ago> as far as linux on the desktop, that never quite happened... but again i'd wager there are almost certainly more handsets running android on linux than desktop pcs in operating existence. Why does it matter than Android is Linux when all the benefits of using something like Linux aren't there?
- toyg 6y agoI’d argue they are not “vertically integrated”, since they’ve effectively killed their server offerings. I don’t know the specifics, but I bet they don’t sell anything like a bank-teller system either, the bread & butter of workstation sellers (Sun had some amazing stuff there). But Apple are certainly the only large unix-workstation seller left.
- jacques_chester 6y agoYou might be thinking of horizontal integration. Apple is most certainly an increasingly vertically-integrated company.
- Tsiklon 6y agoI'll be interested in seeing how their new computers turn out - as they're turning away from commodity hardware, and going back to bespoke silicon for their CPUs, it's like we're going back in time to the more heterogeneous Unix Workstation days.
- a-dub 6y agoit's going to be interesting. i think they captured a lot of the developer/systems market because most server infrastructure is x86-64 and folks can run the same vms/containers locally. i wonder how much of that they stand to lose by forcing those folks to maintain separate builds or use slow emulation. granted, a lot happens in higher level languages, but introducing a new supported cpu architecture is painful... there are always native libraries. i think a lot of apple's comeback, at least in the early days, was fueled by developers and systems people evangelizing them as the usable unix...
- fxtentacle 6y agoI find the article slightly confusing, but what I believe the author wants to say is that special-purpose machines allow for better optimization than having to support a wide variety of generic hardware. So in effect, this is the same argument as game consoles vs. desktop PCs. Every PS5 game can use primitive shaders, because the developers know that every PS5 will have them. For a generic desktop PC game release, though, only 1% of all buyers will have a new enough AMD RX Vega GPU, so it doesn't make sense to invest much resources into supporting primitive shaders there. That said, pretty much all of the specialized hardware that Workstations used to have in the past is now commonly available everywhere as vertex, compute, or pixel shaders. So in my opinion, the workstation marked died because suddenly everyone gained access to what was previously reserved only for workstation users.
- 7952 6y agoOne of the big selling points of early cloud products (like GMail) was that specialist hardware outperformed local hardware. It just happened to be in the cloud. You got to store your data on a limitless specialized server platform instead of your little hard drive. The irony now is that a terabyte hard drive for a laptop costs very little. A lot of business devices have plenty of space that is completely unused. So we spend our lives downloading from SharePoint/OneDrive/Outlook etc.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoCloud's pitch is elastic scaling and centralized IT.
- TristanBall 6y agoSo.. I guess this really is nostalgia for a time when you could go out and spend $10-100k, and buy a workstation that had capabilities simply not available on a consumer pc. Thats kind of a hard thing to do these days.. and there doesn't seem to be a market for it. If you want to do that now you just look at “server“ class equipment, or its "workstation“ smaller siblings, to get ”truck” features... multiple cpu sockets, more ram, more pcie lanes etc. Add pcie cards to as required for the workload. All the old-school unix workstation benefits, and it will still be able to run excel and outlook, which matters in lots and lots of environments.
- tyingq 6y agoThere is still a gap of sorts. Support for ECC memory in desktops is pretty hard to find, and not well documented.
- willyt 6y agohttps://www.apple.com/uk/mac-pro/specs/ https://www.apple.com/uk/mac-pro/specs/ ‘Memory Configure up to 1.5TB of DDR4 ECC memory in 12 user-accessible DIMM slots’ And it can even cost over £10k just like the good old days.
- znpy 6y agoWell SuperMicro sells workstation motherboards that you can use to assemble a workstation and they can go even higher than 1.5TB. The dumb thing is that most people compare the Mac pro (a workstation) to a consumer PC, not to workstation-class PC (ThinkStations from Lenovo or HP Z8xx from HP). Example: The HP Z8 can be equipped with 3TB of memory: https://www8.hp.com/us/en/workstations/z8.html?jumpid=in_r12139_us/en/psg/ws_desktops/products/z8-learn-more https://www8.hp.com/us/en/workstations/z8.html?jumpid=in_r12...
- tannhaeuser 6y agoIt's been a while, but Supermicro has/had plenty of options for workstation or server mainboards with ECC, special power requirements, etc.
- adrianmsmith 6y agoI'm not sure workstations did suffer a demise? If workstation vendors like SGI, NeXT, Sun, HP-UX workstations etc. still existed in 2020, what would their products look like? Surely just like a modern Mac or PC? Powerful multi-core CPUs, as much RAM as you have money to spend (e.g. >1 TB), high resolution full-colour graphics (e.g. 5k iMacs or similar PC monitors).
- tinus_hn 6y agoThere’s still a market for supported, super high end workstations. There just isn’t a market for these weird operating systems these companies were selling. The operating systems may have been the best since sliced bread, they are useless without applications. And then without the operating system you get commoditized and it’s impossible to charge the amount of money these companies were charging.
- blihp 6y agoBasically what the workstation companies did was sell capabilities that would be available years down the line at a premium with much better margins. The problem (for them) was that Wintel kept shrinking the gap. In 1981 they were selling stuff that PC's wouldn't have for 10-15 years. In 1991 they were selling stuff that PC's wouldn't have for 5 years. By 2001 they had been largely lapped on their core systems. Had a company like SGI managed to survive their business model would have likely remained the same[1]: they might have looked like a boutique nVidia selling extreme high-end parallelism solutions (i.e. graphics, neural net hardware etc) that GPU makers wouldn't yet be able to match with commodity hardware. Probably some combination of extreme transistor count and boatloads of FPGA/specialized silicon coupled with extreme power consumption and cooling. They also would have been able to go after smaller verticals than nVidia can. That was always their game: selling solutions that were relatively harder to produce because they had to be engineered and hadn't been commoditized yet. The problem is, those doing to the commoditizing can move faster than those doing the innovating. When those doing the innovating die off, the technology doesn't advance as quickly. [1] I say this because all of these companies seemed to have a similar fault: they were never able to move down market so that they could scale up their volumes. The same thing is slowly killing Intel right now.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoI used Sun workstations and DEC Alpha early nineties, apart from the responsiveness of the window system (due to the fact they weren't being asked todo much compared with today), what I remember most is the reliability - we didn't shutdown our machines in the evenings or weekends and they'd happily carry on running without apps crashing for over a year, often without air conditioning.
- arethuza 6y agoMy absolute favourite memories of using Suns were NeWS/HyperNeWS - I've never used anything like it since (pretty much the Lisp of the 2D graphics worlds).
- tinus_hn 6y agoActually the Suns had an issue with their harddisks getting stuck after being turned off for 2 weeks, they’d be unable to start again.
- qayxc 6y ago> we didn't shutdown our machines in the evenings or weekends and they'd happily carry on running without apps crashing for over a year, often without air conditioning. I really don't understand this. Apart from the minor detail that modern (e.g. younger than a decade or so) PCs can go to stand-by mode and wake up within seconds at most, I've yet to come across commodity hard- and software that doesn't do the same. The current up time of my machine is 4 days 13 hours, 20 minutes - because I ran some system updates last week. Without those, even my mediocre machine running all the software I use on a daily basis (IDEs, web browser, several terminals) just keeps running for weeks on end and never ever crashes. Am I just lucky or is this "crashes and blue screens"-business just a persistent memory from the late 90s and early 2000s?
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoThere's a difference in weeks and years. I think the main reason was the OS and nearly all hardware was developed and tested by the same company - no 3rd party graphic card kernel drivers etc. It was also a fact that a lot of these machines were expected to be up 24/7 - running mail/file servers etc. OS updates, including kernel updates wouldn't require rebooting.
- fooblat 6y agoWorkstations haven't died, they have evolved. Proprietary hardware and software have been mostly replaced by commodity hardware and open source software. The jobs that once required powerful proprietary workstations and now done with powerful PC based workstations running Linux, BSD, or even Windows.
- MarkusWandel 6y agoI read it all the way to the bottom, then had to scroll back to the top to check the date. Then do a ^F and look for the word Linux, not there. Obviously an alternate universe. In the this one one, the use cases of the old workstations (personal experience: Apollo DN4500, a couple of Suns) have been replaced by commmodity PCs running Linux. Works just as well, end of story.
- Tepix 6y agoAnother piece of the puzzle is that PCs got a lot better. Once PCs got the PCI bus they were no longer completely inferior to a SUN Sparc while under load. Before that, ISA was a serios bottleneck.
- arexxbifs 6y agoWell, today a cheap gaming PC runs in circles around even the most advanced workstations of yesteryear. My cheap as chips consumer laptop easily accumulates an uptime of a month or more before I decide a kernel update would be a good idea and I have to reboot. Also, the computers in use by professionals today _are_ specialized. As a web developer, I don't need the expensive GPU(s) required by an AI researcher and thus my computer doesn't have one. If I was doing video editing I might have a different storage solution than my current SSD-only setup, etc. I think the downside of the demise of workstations is mainly a psychological one: we no longer have the ability to marvel at and dream about highly specialized computers offering a significantly different user experience than that of our ordinary home computers. A small text about this: https://datagubbe.se/coolcomp.html https://datagubbe.se/coolcomp.html
- musicale 6y ago> we no longer have the ability to marvel at and dream about highly specialized computers offering a significantly different user experience than that of our ordinary home computers I still dream of Nvidia-style personal supercomputers stuffed full of GPUs and RAM. (Not to mention other accelerators like Tensorflow, FPGAs, etc..) And quantum machines.
- DrNuke 6y agoJust curious to try some benchmarks with the very latest Raspberry Pi 400 , the all-in-one Linux-based PC going for $70 from Raspberry. If needed, a spare, old but not spent, supporting external HD is waiting for recall in one of my office drawers already.
- fanf2 6y agoWhen the Raspberry Pi compute module 4 was announced recently, I did a quick update to my Raspberry Pi / Sun E450 comparison: https://twitter.com/fanf/status/1318322060477763584?s=21 https://twitter.com/fanf/status/1318322060477763584?s=21 - the Pi is about 10x better in most performance metrics, and nearly 1000x less in size, weight, and price!
- swatson741 6y agoI came across a quote from Alan Kay that came to mind when reading this: > It’s worth pondering this. One argument against mine, is that “people need and want ‘appliances’ “ that only have one function. This was in response to a more widely known quote of his: > Simple things should be simple, complex things should be possible. The only people who need specialized personal workstations are people working with large data. But, even with that the cost of the cloud has made workstations a poor investment in most cases. I don't think I'd agree with the notion that the demise of the workstation is "untimely." Maybe in a retro, nostalgic or, cultural way it's demise is upsetting but, in the larger pragmatic sense it's quite welcomed. Workstations always felt like a stop-gap solution for what we have now.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoFor a long time I thought the market would bifurcate again. With consumption devices at one end and creation devices at the other. Sadly it looks that isn’t happening and we will end up with nothing more than a web browser on our desks and anything complex running in the cloud. I don’t like this model at all and it isn’t about culture or nostalgia but rather the loss of control and agency.
- swatson741 6y agoWhy would you think that for a long time when the trend has clearly been towards where we are today? PC's kept getting more powerful and sophisticated architectures. Workstations never had a future. I remember even back in the 2000's personal workstations were considered legacy. PC's had networking capabilities that were more than enough for what many organizations were doing and they didn't want to support or purchase workstations.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoWhether it is called a PC or a Workstation is immaterial, it's the capacity for work that is the distinction.
- michael1999 6y ago
- rsecora 6y agoCAPEX is the key. I have fond memories of offering an x86+tomcat+mysql solution to clients competing with other solutions based on Sparc+iPlanet+Oracle. The offer was so low compared with previous ones, that some customers ask for confirmation. This CAPEX was also mirrored in the development workstations. No need to have Sun based hardware, a commodity PC was enough to develop without surprises when deploying.
- sgt101 6y agoThis is why I put together a business case for DGX's from Nvidia because the vertical integration saved us so much time.
- anthk 6y agoA lot of Motif propietary sw and custom tools were recompiled for Linux with nearly no changes in late 90s at a many times lower cost.
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoNothing killed the workstation market. It's still totally a thing. Lenovo, Dell, HP, Apple ... all of these companies will quite happily sell you a dual CPU machine with masses of cores, oodles of ECC RAM, extremely high performance graphics with certified driver support etc. All that's changed is that the architectures for workstations and "business class" desktop machines have converged, and the distinctive operating systems that were needed to support those older workstation architectures have gone away.
- wtracy 6y agoThe author seems to use the word "workstation" specifically to refer to machines running a proprietary Unix variant, usually using a specialty (non-x86) CPU architecture. What you're describing are workstation-class PC-compatibles, not workstations (as the author defines the term). What the author is really talking about is the death of systems where the hardware (sometimes all the way down to the CPU architecture) and the OS are produced by the same organization as a single, integrated solution targeted at a specific vertical.
- dragontamer 6y ago> What the author is really talking about is the death of systems where the hardware (sometimes all the way down to the CPU architecture) and the OS are produced by the same organization as a single, integrated solution targeted at a specific vertical. Isn't that the iPhone and iPad? EDIT: Even the camera sensors + DSP for processing is specially built for phones these days.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoArm licensee and not a workstation.
- MarkusWandel 6y agoIn a way, of course the "workstation" distinction is still here. Gamers aside, if you see a machine decked out in 27" or bigger, high-DPI monitors, double digit gigabytes of RAM and so on, it's probably because it's being used for work, be it graphic design or video editing or electronic design. The unwashed masses have mini laptops and big smartphones and Chromebooks.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago... or writing native software in a compiled language.
- fmakunbound 6y agoI got my company's HP9000 workstation after they dumped all that for x86 and Linux. It was fully decked-out, very heavy and was so loud I eventually had to get rid of it. Fun times – I learned assembler on it. Later I got one of the faster UltraSpac-II workstations. It was pretty cool that you could drop into the OpenFirmware and pretend to be a Forth programmer whenever you liked.
- DFXLuna 6y agoI work in the workstation division of one of the companies listed in the article and the market for workstations is not going anywhere for a long time. It's not that workstations died, it's that they look different and solve a different problem. Anyone can build a computer with off the shelf parts that has the absolute maximum specs that any vendor can produce. Anytime a new workstation makes the news (see Apple's latest workstation), the "PC Master race" gang is quick to point out that they can build the same system without the Apple/HP/Dell/Lenovo tax. What they somehow always forget about is that, if I'm an ITDM and I need 100 or even 1000 systems and they need to be configured, validated and ready to deploy from day one, custom built computers aren't feasible in any sense of the word. The value add from workstation companies is a mix of scale, availability, validity and uniformity.
- runjake 6y agoOn the other hand, the "PC Master Race" gang is a home/enthusiast demographic and from their perspective, they're probably correct. They don't need that value add from workstation companies. And heck, they probably welcome excuses to tinker on their workstations. And this is great. It keeps the open, build-able computer market going -- contrary to the alarming trend of locked down computing devices.
- noir_lord 6y agoI build my own desktops (which are workstations in all but name) for work because I want to know exactly what goes into it and make sure it's quality parts that are widely available without vendor specific motherboards and other stuff. It's never bitten me, worst case I'd have to next working day a part from amazon. For development workloads you simply can't beat that approach. Recent example, unit tests on work issued macbook pro, 2 minutes, same tests on my PC, 39s. There simply isn't a laptop that fits my workloads better than a modern Ryzen with a crap-tonne of RAM
- fctorial 6y agoWhich ryzen? What are the other specs?
- pketh 6y agoRE the idea of having a toolchest of machines for specific tasks, between my mac and monitor is an eGPU. It's a separate box and I bought it to run blender better. Maybe it's not that workstations are dead, but that their shape has changed: At the core of the modern version is a general purpose computer, and then hardware modules (internal cards, or external peripherals via thunderbolt) are added to make task-specific workstation computing happen. Most people don't need their computers to be workstations, but that's always been the case I suppose.
- therealbilly 6y agoI use a repurposed Dell Precision workstation here at home and it's great. The Xeon 6-core rips through applications and the 64GB allows for multiple VMs as the case may be. In my mind, this setup is superior to ordinary desktops.
- brundolf 6y agoProprietary, vertically-constrained systems are a weird thing to be nostalgic about
- mixmastamyk 6y agoThere’s a number of comments here dancing around the themes of The Innovators Dilemma (book) by Christiansen so I thought I’d mention it specifically. It describes how and why high-margin companies are unable to pivot to lower margins as technology advances, getting left behind.
- nbzso 6y agoI just build a hackintosh with Ryzen 3900x/32gb/500gbNVME and Saphyre Nitro with expensive case. Total cost: Under 2000 usd. Kicking iMac pro (11 000 usd +) to dust. So thank you Apple. PS. My Trashcan looks at me with silent blackness. But I don't care.
- nsxwolf 6y agoWhat counts as a workstation these days? If the goalposts haven't moved, then just about everything anyone uses today counts. For me back in the mid 90s, the major differentiator was ethernet, and everything has that now.
- blodkorv 6y agowell windows + intel became a much faster and cheaper computer then anyone else could produce. I think its much better this way. Only weird sysadmin geeks seems to believe there is any real value in using some "workstation" with a custom cpu and os.