5 ms·
For hydrogen skeptics, here's an excellent but long two part series about Europe's massive investment in hydrogen, starting at 40GW and ~30B$, and moving on to
by epistasis 6y ago
For hydrogen skeptics, here's an excellent but long two part series about Europe's massive investment in hydrogen, starting at 40GW and ~30B$, and moving on to $500B after that.
Part 1, EU hydrogen supply: https://about.bnef.com/blog/liebreich-separating-hype-from-hydrogen-part-one-the-supply-side/ https://about.bnef.com/blog/liebreich-separating-hype-from-h...
Part 2, EU hydrogen demand: https://about.bnef.com/blog/liebreich-separating-hype-from-hydrogen-part-two-the-demand-side/ https://about.bnef.com/blog/liebreich-separating-hype-from-h...
And Spain is already focusing 800MW directly into fertilizer production (usually the hydrogen comes from natural gas): https://www.iberdrola.com/press-room/news/detail/iberdrola-fertiberia-place-spain-forefront-green-hydrogen-europe-with-1-8-billion-investment-projected-2027 https://www.iberdrola.com/press-room/news/detail/iberdrola-f...
And as noted in the Part 1 article, China is making massive investments in hydrogen.
The US effort is orders of magnitude smaller than others efforts, about $50M/year: https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/h2scale https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/h2scale
Our oil and gas sector is also far too focused on fracking, a business that wasn't making money even before the crash in oil prices that have refocused capital from companies like Exxon to extractors with super low costs in the Middle East.
The US is often viewed as being late to the party, but a big player when it finally arrives. However I fear that the business competition in the EU and China will be too strong for us unless we start focusing ping term investment in these areas soon. Every bit of news I see makes me feel like we are getting further and further behind, which will leave us far more strategically weak than if we don't have, for example, semiconductor fabs.
- ricw 6y agoThis still misses the primary reason why hydrogen won’t ever be useful, where lithium-ion batteries can do the job. Hydrogen is just too energy inefficient from an end-to-end efficiency perspective. Lithium-ion achieves a 80%+ efficiency from energy input to usage via an AC motor, or more if DC is usable. Hydrogen fuel cells only achieve 40-60% efficiency, and that’s just one step (converting it back from storage to electric energy, not even the motor itself). No matter how much is being invested, this can’t just be wished away and effects how expensive something is per kWh. On top of that, there’s a massive Li-ion R&D and production train already under way that will be hard if not impossible to catch up with. In short, right now it looks like this will only be useful for a few edge cases that battery electric can’t feasibly support.
- philipkglass 6y agoIf we stop using fossil fuels to make chemicals and materials, we'll need vast quantities of electrolytic hydrogen. Ammonia production alone was about 175 million tonnes in 2016, requiring 31 million tonnes of hydrogen. At 50 kWh per kg of hydrogen, that would be roughly 177 GW of electrolyzer capacity working at a 100% duty cycle. Using hydrogen in place of coal for reducing iron ore would consume even more hydrogen. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonia_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonia_production Japan is interested in it as fuel, despite the well known drawbacks, because Japan has such limited domestic energy resources.
- omgwtfbyobbq 6y agoThere's also been work on getting solar thermal to the point where heat alone could be used at input into an industrial process. https://www.fastcompany.com/90477609/this-startup-uses-mirrors-to-create-solar-powered-1800-degree-heat-for-industrial-factories https://www.fastcompany.com/90477609/this-startup-uses-mirro...
- wil421 6y agoWhat if we lived in a world where EVs are ubiquitous and they are powered by lithium ion batteries charged by renewable energy and/or nuclear. Specialized plants can still exist in this scenario to provide hydrogen and even diesel for industrial processes. The existing gas and coal plants wouldn’t be used for powering the general population anymore and would become more specialized producers.
- pjc50 6y agoBut the original article's project isn't stopping using fossil fuel. It's using fossil fuel to make hydrogen. This is just money laundering for carbon atoms.
- philipkglass 6y agoYou are correct. I originally thought that this was another article about this Australian hydrogen project, also targeting Japan (and other energy importers) but powered by renewables: "Western Australia’s multi-gigawatt green hydrogen giant edges forward" https://www.pv-tech.org/news/western-australian-renewables-hub-to-expand-to-26gw-solar-and-wind-generation https://www.pv-tech.org/news/western-australian-renewables-h...
- mlindner 6y agoWhy do you think countries investing in it would make me not a skeptic? I'm a skeptic because of the technology being a bad idea pushed originally by oil companies. Hydrogen is only green if you produce it yourself by green electricity by electrolysis which is quite inefficient and then convert that energy back into electricity with another quite inefficient process. Now as to the reason why Japan has been investing, it's because the actual way Hydrogen is produced is from fossil fuels. It's done by taking methane and other hydrocarbons and pulling the hydrogen off and expelling the CO2 (ideally capturing it). This process is called steam reforming. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_reforming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_reforming This is the sweet lie people aren't told when hydrogen is brought up. Japan happens to have extensive offshore methane clathrate deposits on the sea floor and if they can make a hydrogen economy happen then those clathrates may become economical to mine.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoRemember George Bush pushing hydrogen? The big problem with hydrogen is that it currently is a smokescreen for a certain industry that has a ton of hydrogen attached to carbon atoms desperate to maintain relevance in the "green" energy revolution. It is staring down a massive economic challenge as well, shared with any new five-year nuclear reactor project or similar cutting edge power generation scheme, is that solar/wind/storage is in the prime curve of double-digit improvements to various aspects of cost, scale, storage, performance every year. BEVs are poised to undercut ICEs fundamentally in cost and simplicity. Solar/wind is about to drop under even natural gas in LCOE for even installed turbines. All of those have three year projections of continued double-digit percentage drops in cost and massive increases in scale. Even worse for hydrogen, most of that is using existing infrastructure for transmission, so while charging stations need to be built out for EVs, it is far easier to do that than put in hydrogen storage / transport infrastructure. So even if some hydrogen article targets a certain cost on the batteries / EVs / power transmission lines, in five years things will look completely different. Maybe aviation?
- lambdatronics 6y ago>The big problem with hydrogen is that it currently is a smokescreen for a certain industry that has a ton of hydrogen attached to carbon atoms desperate to maintain relevance in the "green" energy revolution. I see this attitude often and I think it's detrimental. If 'blue' hydrogen (ie, extracting hydrogen from natural gas & storing the carbon) provides an economical stepping-stone toward a fully fossil-free energy system, why not take it? If the only comeback is reflexive disdain for incumbent technologies, give me a break. Your points on battery vehicles vs hydrogen vehicles are in agreement with in the second Bloomberg article linked by the GP.
- elihu 6y agoWell, it would make the US strategically weak if there weren't reasonable alternatives. Wires are cheaper and more convenient ways of moving energy around than refrigerated/insulated pipes or tankers. So anywhere you can use electricity directly you probably would. Batteries are already good enough for cars. Hydrogen might be good for energy storage, but pumped hydro is probably simpler and cheaper where geography allows. Hydrogen might be very useful for some applications that require high energy density (electrified aircraft, perhaps?), though maybe those use cases will be served by conventional liquid fuels that might be increasingly made using renewable energy inputs rather than made from fossil fuels.
- epistasis 6y agoFor the demand side, I agree with the Part 2 article that I posted. Namely, hydrogen will be used primarily for non-electrical industrial purposes, and perhaps for seasonal storage of excess electricity that wouldn't have been used anyway. I don't see much use for shipping hydrogen around, unless it's as a minor component of a synthetic mixture that replaces natural gas, but that's super speculative. However for ammonia (fertilizer), steel, maybe shipping, there's few other options. (And I'm super hopeful that we figure out how to build more wires in the US, probably by repurposing existing right of way. But I'm also skeptical that we will be able to fight NIMBYs for that...)
- barney54 6y agoThe US government spends over $150MM a year on hydrogen. https://www7.eere.energy.gov/office_eere/program_budget_formulation.php https://www7.eere.energy.gov/office_eere/program_budget_form... It’s closer to $200MM when you include work from DOE’s Fossil Energy Office and Nuclear Energy Office. Also California has funded a number of hydrogen fueling stations and the US has the most fuel cell vehicles on the road (almost all in California). The US has seen hydrogen hype cycles before when George Bush called for a hydrogen highway in a State of the Union. My point is that the US is not going to be left behind given significant investment over the last couple decades.
- epistasis 6y agoThanks for this, I hope you are right. I have seen California's H2 station map and have caught glimpse of a few Mirai in the Bay Area. However only a tiny fraction of the hydrogen stations were for electrolysis derived hydrogen. Any money going to steam reformation or other fossil fuel based hydrogen is absolutely wasted investment. We need commitment to electrolyzers, and can't let the money go to dead technologies. I look forward to reading more about how this program operates.
- cbhl 6y agoIt sounds like you have some domain knowledge, so some layman questions-- Does electrolysis research make sense in a region that is already short of freshwater and experiencing drought? Would you say that the science of electrolysis of seawater is worth researching and investing further?
- qchris 6y agoI actually might argue the opposite direction; anything involving electrolyzers is likely wasteful. It's inherently an inefficient process even a theoretical maximums, and we can probably put that capacity to better use through other mechanisms with a higher conversion efficiency. On the other hand, there are a ton of sources of methane that society pretty much will always generate through agriculture or landfills. For example, BMW ran a pilot a few years ago running a large factory's forklifts on hydrogen sourced from biomethane from a local landfill[1]. Cost and technology improvements in areas like steam methane reformers and anaerobic digestion could drive costs down to the point where those facilities can actually gain meaningful adoption, and meaningfully, co-locate hydrogen sources near points of consumption, so you can worry less about the headache of transporting H2 molecules around. Hydrogen is unlikely to wholesale compete with battery electric at this point, but it absolutely shines in certain niche performance applications. To me, aligning the supply chain to leverage those particular instances seems like the best way to work it into a green(er) energy portfolio. For what it's worth, while in school, I did a 7-month co-op a few years ago working on next-gen R&D of PEM fuel cell stacks, so I generally consider myself fairly well versed on potentially out-of-date information. [1] https://www.energy.gov/articles/garbage-power-out-south-carolina-bmw-plant-demonstrates-landfill-gas-hydrogen-fuel https://www.energy.gov/articles/garbage-power-out-south-caro...