6 ms·
Github complies with the DMCA, recently famously through the DMCA takedown of youtube-dl. The writer, Joey Hess (a relatively well-known OSS programmer, moreuti
by renewiltord 6y ago
Github complies with the DMCA, recently famously through the DMCA takedown of youtube-dl. The writer, Joey Hess (a relatively well-known OSS programmer, moreutils, for instance), is choosing to interpret this as their banning any repo that hosts the commit hash for youtube-dl (which they banned).
So he is jokingly showing you a way to create a Github poison pill. The joke is that if you include this 'illegal' hash you subject the repo to being DMCA'd out (not really, but it's sort of an 'imagine if'). Which means his repo is now unpublishable on Github (for long anyway).
It's kind of hacker humour in the sort of vein that you'd expect from an old-schooler like him. You sort of have to get the joke to get the joke.
- syshum 6y agois it a joke though.....
- o-__-o 6y ago..... yes
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI'd find the joke funny if it actually worked. Since as far as I can tell, Github isn't actually banning specific hashes (because they care about the content, not the hashes), and there's no sign that they're going to do so in the future, I can't say I understand the humor...
- geofft 6y agoThat was my initial reaction too, but thinking about it, it's potentially (probably not, but potentially) a violation of the ToS even if it's not automatically banned. So, the hacker humor point is that you have a "poison" repo which, if you push it to GitHub, might get your account deleted in the future. You have no guarantee that it won't, for sure.
- DarkWiiPlayer 6y agoThe way I read it, it seems to claim that github will just "insert" a known object with that hash into the new repository when it's pushed, though I'm somewhat confused as to how this would work, or how the submodule trick even adds the hash to the commit log in the first place. EDIT: I read the article again and couldn't find any of that, so I must have read that in a comment here on HN instead.
- vSanjo 6y agoThat was a very well-written comment, thank you. Hit the dopamine and gave me a smile for your explanation.