3 ms·
Is this mentioned? It's crazy complicated underground in large old American cities. Been putting pipes etc under there for a couple hundred years. A Seattle tun
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
Is this mentioned? It's crazy complicated underground in large old American cities. Been putting pipes etc under there for a couple hundred years. A Seattle tunnel got stalled for months when they hit an old service main iron pipe that'd been put there a century before and forgotten.
My sister worked for a pump company, been in business for 150 years. Got calls all the time for replacement pumps that had failed after a century etc. One was 6 stories underground in NYC. Had to dig a tunnel down through a maze of services (electrical, tunnels, drains, water, gas) to get to it. Then had to have exactly the same pump to fit exactly into the geometry it used to have (no problem; they still had the drawing for the pump in a drawer and made an exact copy). Pulled the old one up, dropped the new one down, hooked it up and then buried it for maybe another century.
- zepearl 6y agoMh, many other non-american cities are older => I don't think that "age" matters directly in the context of the cost-comparison shown by the article. If complications caused by conflicting stuff that you mention is one of the factors that drive up the cost, then I guess that general panning for all kind of infrastructure is just constantly done better (for whichever reasons) in non-amerian cities?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoIts the frantic rebuilding and updating that makes it complicated. The largest industrial centers in the world (at the time) were built and rebuild countless times, each adding another layer of services. City centers are particularly complex, and everything seems to go through there. NYC went from 125000 in 1820, to 5.5M in 1920.
- Ichthypresbyter 6y agoCompare to large old European cities, which have many of the same issues plus unexploded WW2 bombs, archaeological sites, and plague pits.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- peteey 6y agoNo. What you say seems true, but this is a comparison. I would expect other nations to also have pipe etc underground for a hundred years too (probably longer).
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoYes. The rapid growth of American cities (zero to millions in a single century) is different from European growth.
- cr1895 6y agoWhy would that mean the underground complexity is any less so in Europe?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoWell, infrastructure for 5,000,000 people built in surges over a century, one that saw unparalleled advances in technology and industry results in every kind of wire, pipe, conduit, pump, tile, fill and foundation conceivable. All built on top of one another in a big hurry. If you have 1000 years to do it and grow slowly enough, maybe you have 2 or three layers.
- cr1895 6y agoAre these American cities that unique in this regard, or for that matter, even that old? Probably this is a genuine difference between a novel development in a new Chinese city, but the fact is these major infrastructure projects are done much more cheaply in places like Paris and London. _In some ways, M.T.A. projects have been easier than work elsewhere. East Side Access uses an existing tunnel for nearly half its route. The hard rock under the city also is easy to blast through, and workers do not encounter ancient sites that need to be protected._ _“They’re claiming the age of the city is to blame?” asked Andy Mitchell, the former head of Crossrail, a project to build 13 miles of subway under the center of London, a city built 2,000 years ago. “Really?”_ https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-construction-costs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-...
- txru 6y agoThe pipe that stopped drilling in Seattle was 10 years old, not 100. It was meant to measure the seismic stability of the viaduct that was eventually removed. The tunneling firm was found to be aware of the pipe and liable for delays. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bertha_(tunnel_boring_machine)#Damage_to_cutterhead_and_two-year_delay https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bertha_(tunnel_boring_machin...