3 ms·
> What has become of HN. Why are so many people defending this practice […] I think people on HN increasingly have FAANG (or even more murky) jobs. “It is dif
by teddyh 6y ago
> What has become of HN. Why are so many people defending this practice […]
I think people on HN increasingly have FAANG (or even more murky) jobs.
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.”
— Upton Sinclair
If these people were to admit to themselves that the place they work is deeply unethical, they would have to either face unpleasant truths about themselves, or face the prospect of abandoning their job. Neither alternative is attractive to say the least, so cognitive dissonance sets in, and an illusion is created is their minds that this behavior is, in fact, ethical.
- chillacy 6y agoPrezi is more a startup in "growth hacking" phase than a FAANG Also, people often have different and mutually exclusive ethical values from each other, there are plenty of defense contractors who believe they are the good guys, privacy activists who think they're doing good, anti abortion activists who believe they are saving lives, pro choice activists who think they're protecting rights, etc. How can we know which is the illusory position? I can't expect to believe that all of my positions just happen to be right. Everyone on the planet believes they're right--the right values, the right religions... I'm not aware of an objective answer to morality.
- na85 6y ago>Everyone on the planet believes they're right--the right values, the right religions... I'm not aware of an objective answer to morality. Moral relativism is the most insidious means to reduce legitimate concerns—whether they be ethical, political, or otherwise—to inconsequential. It's easy to assuage your own feelings of shame/guilt by pointing out that $repugnant_behaviour occurs else where and that's so much worse. At some point it's required that people actually take a stand rather than participate in the race to the ethical bottom.
- chillacy 6y ago> take a stand This same thought process works for suicide bombers fighting for a theocracy as much as you or me. Consider that giving this advice to everyone on earth would just lead to more extremism in all directions. E.g. PETA sees meat consumption as animal genocide, but meat eaters don't see animals as being in the same class as people (they're humanists).
- hda2 6y agoThe argument here is that most agree that including fine-print in a contract most people don't read, can't realistically understand, and can't even renegotiate to allow yourself to do awful things is abhorrent. Well, most do except those who engage in the practice, of course.
- chillacy 6y agoI was responding to the Upton Sinclair quote but I seem to have attracted some moral absolutists and now the conversation is steering philosophical. I agree that corporate lawyers are abhorrent ;)
- admax88q 6y agolol k. So what's your conclusion then. Morals are relative, therefore there are no morals? Who are we to criticize genocide and terrorism?
- chillacy 6y agoNo, morals are relative, just that. We probably have similar morals as frequenters of a tech website site in English compared to hunter gatherers, so we can even have this discussion in the first place. I haven't been convinced that there's anything universal about the morals we hold across species let alone sapiens in the past 10,000 years or across cultures. Unless your definition of moral absolutism only encompasses humans living today (with the implication that technology makes certain things possible), which I might agree with.
- 6y ago