4 ms·
Less fundamentally democratic? As in you mean that most views are subsumed into the two big parties? I sympathize with the view that large parties eliminate div
by renewiltord 6y ago
Less fundamentally democratic? As in you mean that most views are subsumed into the two big parties? I sympathize with the view that large parties eliminate diversity in political thought but I'm trying to understand what "less fundamentally democratic" means here.
- dosshell 6y agoI interpret the writer as referring to the democracy index. [0] U.S. is at place 25 and is categorized as a flawed democracy, lower than Canada and some European countries (but far from all). [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index
- CameronNemo 6y agoThis index does not take into account the way some constitutions give certain groups greater say in policymaking, adjucation, or execution.
- CameronNemo 6y agoUS Senate (and by extension the federal court system) Electoral college
- bleepblorp 6y agoThe Canadian constitution is not designed to grossly overweight the views of rural areas over those of populated areas. Canada doesn't have an institution like the US senate, where voters from the least populous state have over 80 times more power than those from the most populous state. The spread in riding (electoral district) size in Canada only varies by a factor of 4.5 if the (mostly unpopulated) northern territories are included (the three territories have one MP, each, to represent populations of less than 30,000) and a factor of 1.5 among the populated provinces. Canadian federal governments are generally comprised of whichever party received the largest share of votes nationally. This is not always the case in the US.
- kcolford 6y ago> Canadian federal governments are generally comprised of whichever party received the largest share of votes nationally. This is not always the case in the US. I'm going to disagree with you on this. In Canada, the general votes usually result in 1/3-1/3-1/3 split between the Conservatives, Liberals, and NDP. It's our first past the post system for MPs that results in the uneven split at the final tally. The only reason that the system hasn't succumbed to gerrymandering as badly as elsewhere is that district changes must be prompted by a change in the number of provincial seats from the census. The changes themselves are proposed by an unelected third-party with members chosen by the judiciary of the province and the speaker of the house (who is chosen by the MPs through a secret ballot vote). Otherwise, it would be all too easy to gerrymander an election in Canada and end up in the same situation as the US.
- scarab5q 6y agoA vote in the US matters significantly more or less depending on what state you live in. California has approximately 40 million people living in it and yet it still has only 2 senators which means that in California 1 senator represents 20 million people. Wyoming has approximately 600,000 people and still gets two senators meaning that 1 senator represents 300,000 people. Given that senators are needed to pass laws, your vote has significantly more weight if you live in Wyoming than if you live in California. What this means is that even though republicans have a majority in the senate they represent a minority of the American population. I mean even the president was voted into office with fewer votes than their opponent. Contrast this with countries that use proportional representation which means everyone's vote basically means more or less the same as anyone else's vote. The US is currently ranked 25th in the world by "democracy ranking" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index
- kansface 6y agoSure, but compare the relative power of a CA state representative or the governor to those of Wyoming. CA environmental or privacy regulations for instance often function as de facto national law because the consumer market is so large. Rectifying the imbalance of senators would almost certainly see CA lose that overwhelmingly undemocratic power (~12% of US population - democrats who write the laws are maybe 60% of that subset so 7 million voters). edit: CA accounts for 15% of the US GDP
- atharris 6y agoOkay? This sounds like a great trade if your goal is to have a representative government instead of minority rule.
- kansface 6y agoNo, it is just another form of minority rule. Why should 7% of the country get to set its environmental policy in exchange for less voice in the national government?
- 6y ago