9 ms·
Geohot Chimes In
- chopsueyar 16y agoWhat about the money from the legal defense fund? What happened there?
- dfischer 16y agoHe gave like $10k to the EFF, no?
- daimyoyo 16y agoHe did. http://www.ultrasn0w.ca/2011/04/geohot-donates-10000-to-eff.html http://www.ultrasn0w.ca/2011/04/geohot-donates-10000-to-eff....
- giu 16y agoYes he did: http://geohotgotsued.blogspot.com/2011/04/10000-to-eff.html http://geohotgotsued.blogspot.com/2011/04/10000-to-eff.html (Screenshot of the receipt: http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-qsLYAGnuRfM/Takp2Re-dgI/AAAAAAAAAew/z5aysW0mRXY/s1600/eff_receipt.png http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-qsLYAGnuRfM/Takp2Re-dgI/AAAAAAAAAe...)
- chopsueyar 16y agoYeah, I missed that one. Definitely enough to pay for one lawyer for several minutes against Sony.
- praptak 16y agoThis is interesting: "Traditionally the trust boundary for a web service exists between the server and the client. But Sony believes they own the client too, so if they just put a trust boundary between the consumer and the client(can't trust those pesky consumers), everything is good. Since everyone knows the PS3 is unhackable, why waste money adding pointless security between the client and the server?" I wonder if he's purely speculating or maybe knows something more. It's also good to see he can at least still talk about Sony security in general (or can he?)
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoSee http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2480141 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2480141 - it has been suggested on HN that Sony can't keep hacked Playstations out of the dev channel. It's likely that GeoHotz is much more knowledgeable/better connected (on this topic, at least).
- shareme 16y agoits not speculation, they passed CC numbers in the clear over SSL instead of hashing them..
- nsfmc 16y ago"in the clear over ssl instead of hashing them"? am i missing something here? is ssl insecure? is there some way to charge a credit card that doesn't actually involve sending the number to anybody?
- scarlson 16y agoThe same way you're able to login to News.YC without sending your actual password via the intertubes.
- dpritchett 16y agoSo some sort of public-key cryptography? I didn't realize that the HN login page didn't send a password on a login.
- xsmasher 16y agoI'm not sure I understand you; CC numbers are not passwords. You can't salt and hash them on one end and then confirm on the other end; you need to send the whole number if you expect to process a charge against it.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoYou mean "not at all"? Just fire up a packet sniffer...
- shawndumas 16y agoYou know; this guy makes some good points: "This arrogance undermines a basic security principle, never trust the client. [...] Notice it's only PSN that gave away all your personal data, not Xbox Live when the 360 was hacked, not iTunes when the iPhone was jailbroken, and not GMail when Android was rooted. Because other companies aren't crazy." "[...] To me, a hacker is just somebody with a set of skills; hacker is to computer as plumber is to pipes. And the same ethics should apply, if you want to mess with the pipes in your own house, go for it. But don't go breaking into people's houses and messing with their pipes."
- _delirium 16y agoThe pipe analogy is interesting, because I've heard a related analogy in the other direction. I can't recall where I read it, but I think it was some textfile from the 80s, justifying breaking into large corporate computer systems to explore them as similar to breaking into and exploring steam tunnels, and guided by a similar ethos (e.g. don't vandalize them while exploring).
- artmageddon 16y agoI thought part of geohot's settlement with Sony was that he wasn't allowed to discuss what happened? Maybe that was just with his case and not with the latest incident. Regardless, I like his attitude, and hope he continues honing his hacking skills. As he points out, at least they used a very strong XKCD style randomization algorithm. It's a real shame that Sony alienates their customers with these kinds of acts while building a flimsy infrastructure for gaming. I'm one of those people who bought the PS3 just for OtherOS(and thankfully never got the removal patch) and honestly, given the lackluster performance it has and this move, I'm highly tempted to just sell it. The rootkit debacle of several years ago still leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Today's Penny Arcade covers it quite nicely: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2011/4/29/ http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2011/4/29/
- veyron 16y agothe scope of the gag order was limited to info relevant to the original case, not this new incident.
- artmageddon 16y agoThought so - thanks!
- thomson 16y agoOn a pedantic note, is there a reason why large corporations 'regret' mistakes rather than apologize for them? Is it just so they don't want to go on the record as being wrong? Sony's statement for reference: http://blog.us.playstation.com/2011/04/26/update-on-playstation-network-and-qriocity/ http://blog.us.playstation.com/2011/04/26/update-on-playstat...
- iy56 16y agoTheir lawyers tell them that an apology is an admission of fault.
- eli 16y agoMaybe true, but I don't think that's the real reason. I think it has a lot more to do with ego and cowardice. (It perhaps also belies a shoot-the-messenger mentality that exists within many major corporations.) On The Media did a piece a few months ago about how the 1982 Tylenol recall is pretty much the gold standard for corporate disaster PR: identify the problem, apologize, and explain what you're doing to prevent it in the future. It's not hard, but it takes guts. Even J&J itself didn't meet that standard in later recalls. http://www.onthemedia.org/transcripts/2010/02/12/01 http://www.onthemedia.org/transcripts/2010/02/12/01
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yuvadam 16y agoGotta love the subtle xkcd reference at the end.
- lloeki 16y agoIt's both a XKCD reference and a reference to the PS3 keys, which were generated at some point using a constant instead of a RNG.
- kristofferR 16y agoIt wasn't just a xkcd reference I think, I think it really was a reference from the fail0verflow presentation where the security of the PS3 was totally dismantled (the device itself, not PSN). http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=btDiX319P4w http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=btDiX319P4w @ around 8 minutes in
- mdaniel 16y agoFWIW, one can link directly to a time in a YouTube video using #t=8m tacked on the URL. More information: http://www.google.com/support/youtube/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=116618 http://www.google.com/support/youtube/bin/answer.py?hl=en...
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- swaits 16y agoWhoosh? The f0 talk was referring to the xkcd comic. They were absolutely not saying this is the exact constant used in Sony's ECC code.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- woadwarrior01 16y ago
- daimyoyo 16y agoThe word "hacker" has been corrupted by the media to the point it's nearly derogatory. We need a new term for what we do. Something like "techsmith." Any other ideas?
- shawndumas 16y agoHow 'bout "hacker"?
- beaumartinez 16y agoCoder? Programmer? Although I agree that "hacker" has a new meaning (and has for a long time), much like how the LGBT community adopts otherwise derogatory terms, I don't think we should stop using "hacker" because of outside influences; the actual meaning implied (coder or script kiddie) is often obvious thanks to the context it gets used in (CNN using "hacker" in a news title is different to when Joel Spolsky uses it, for example).
- crocowhile 16y agoI think the proper word already exists since ages and it's "polymath" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polymath http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polymath
- beaumartinez 16y ago| In less formal terms, a polymath (or polymathic person) may simply be someone who is very knowledgeable. It's not specific to the coding field.
- stonemetal 16y agoNor is the term hacker(in the positive sense). In the negative sense it seems to be reserved for coding.
- scarlson 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tech_Model_Railroad_Club http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tech_Model_Railroad_Club Neither is "Hacker".
- pdenya 16y agoStrange how many of the commenters on the article think the Sony was hacked from a rooted PS3. There's no evidence but I'll assume this was done from a PC until I see some reason why doing it from a PS3 would make it easier (in any way).
- allwein 16y agoNot too strange when you consider that most people don't understand networking and the internet. From the point of view of some people: "It's the Playstation Network, obviously you have to use a Playstation to get on the Playstation Network. You can't use a computer, they aren't compatible!" I can't come up with a direct analogy for a similar lack of comprehension, but I keep thinking of the apocryphal stories of people that lock themselves out of their cars with the windows down, and freak out because they don't think of reaching through the window to unlock it manually.
- StavrosK 16y agoApart from the fact that it's already got all the hardware and software to communicate with the servers, and is thus a much better conduit for an exploit, you mean?
- marshray 16y agoWell the protocol turns out to look a lot like HTTP talking to Apache over SSL. This is no surprise, it's easy to develop with and is the most likely to make through proxies and firewalls outbound. Nevertheless, Sony seemed to assume that it guaranteed they would only receive valid messages from actual hardware they controlled. This is not a security feature of SSL/TLS which depends on the client doing its part to prevent the absence of a man-in-the-middle. When the client was hacked, many of their assumptions were violated. We hear rumors of hackers "mapping" their systems onto some internal development networks. What this means exactly I don't know. But if Sony's primary network defenses were the Maginot line, their dev network probably looked a lot like Belgium.
- dfox 16y agoI agree with you that it was probably done from PC (or well just about anything including PS3, but not because it was required to use PS3), but on the other hand it seems plausible that information extracted from (probably rooted) PS3 was significant help.
- Jun8 16y agoThis is an excellent piece, my esteem for geohot got even higher. It vilifies Sony (rightly so) but also is balanced. The plumber analogy is spot on and funny: "To me, a hacker is just somebody with a set of skills; hacker is to computer as plumber is to pipes. And the same ethics should apply, if you want to mess with the pipes in your own house, go for it. But don't go breaking into people's houses and messing with their pipes. (Note that I do not endorse water piracy)"
- pushingbits 16y agoGood Christ, what comments! "You're the perfect example of someone who can't even grasp the simple concept of how YOUR actions have consequences for OTHER people. If Sony wanted to remove Other OS that's up to them, people like you and George should have just dealt with that. Instead like children you have this sense of entitlement and so the PS3 was hacked and root keys published. No thought was given to how this would be used by other people, all that crossed your tiny little minds was how this affected YOU." http://geohotgotsued.blogspot.com/2011/04/recent-news.html?showComment=1303986868731#c8287228180500063419 http://geohotgotsued.blogspot.com/2011/04/recent-news.html?s... You see people become inoculated by all sorts of kooky ideas (usually offering salvation or universal insight), but to see people get their mind twisted around some faceless video game company... the mind boggles...
- marshray 16y agoI think the part about "all that crossed your tiny little minds was how this affected YOU" is the most telling.
- pyre 16y agoWell, their minds must seem tiny to someone with such a big head. ;-)
- huhtenberg 16y agoThere is a good chance that this particular comment came directly from Sony as a part of some sort of misdirection and damage control campaign. It does not read like something a teenager would write, it sounds more like a mom lecturing her adolescent, but I can't see parents taking time to comment in GeoHot's blog. So given the context it looks artificial.
- yardie 16y agoIf you think that's bad you should check out the Kotaku comments or the PSN forums. Some of them were promising bodily harm geohotz. I know people get worked up over cheaters but some of the comments were just right off the rails crazy. Seems to be a correlation the more time you spend playing the system the more you hate people that screw around with it. I know people like to make fun of Mac and Android fans but some playstation fans took it way too personal.
- leon_ 16y agoI don't understand those comments. Are those frustrated kids who can't play online anymore?
- marshray 16y agoMy understanding is that the "battlefield graphic murder" online simulator games are quite popular and they've had a problem with cheaters. Players have built up quite a rage against these cheaters and they look to Sony to fix it. When hackers come along having the goal of running their own OS on the PS3 or even restoring the ability to run as a guest of the hypervisor (OtherOS), many players don't see the difference. Probably any research into the inner workings of a PS3 has the potential to benefit cheat development as well, but I for one do not accept the idea that we would turn off our inquisitive nature and forgo our home supercomputers so that others might gain a more fair killing field.
- eli 16y agoI think you're exactly right. But I think you need to respect the opposing viewpoint: that supporting OtherOS actually isn't worth the risk of new cheats for a lot of people. It is a game console after all.
- marshray 16y agoNo, I think there's some fallacies there: * It's not a "game console" by definition. It's a box with semiconductors inside it which I can purchase for a few hundred bucks at any of many local stores. These semiconductors are equally well-suited for doing vector calculations in support of many applications, frivolous and serious alike. * It's simply a mistake to think by not "supporting OtherOS" it will significantly reduce the "risk of new cheats" in anything but the very short term. OtherOS is happening whether it's supported or not. That's probably true of cheating too. * But that's not even what Sony did though, Sony actively removed OtherOS from units people had previously purchased, and only then _after_ it had already provided its (relatively small) boost to hackers. The idea of keeping secrets locked in a box that millions of people purchase and physically control is simply ludicrous and has failed every time it's been tried.
- awakeasleep 16y ago"And let's talk about Sony's use of the word illegal. It is illegal, criminally so, to break into someone else's servers. But when the same word is used to refer to streaming a song from a non RIAA approved website, or to gasp playing a homebrew game on your PS3, respect for the word and those who say it is lost." Who is this kid? He's like 20 years old and he talks like this? Geohot, you have my respect thats for sure.