4 ms·
In particular, you can only create a world where everyone is equal by taking away the freedom to not be equal. Now, if we want to take away the "freedom" to be
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
In particular, you can only create a world where everyone is equal by taking away the freedom to not be equal.
Now, if we want to take away the "freedom" to be not equal on the downside, I'm not sure that I have much problem with that. If people aren't "free" to live in abject poverty, to have to choose between there medicines and their food, to not have air conditioning in summer or heat in winter... yeah, I don't have a problem with removing that "freedom".
But I have a problem with removing the freedom to be unequal on the upside. If I want to have more than you, and I can get it by producing more than you... why not? If I can't get rewarded for producing more, I probably won't produce more. That leaves less for everyone. Who does that help?
Thus those who try to prevent inequality on the upside remove freedom, and make everyone worse off. Worse off in two ways. First, society doesn't get the extra that some people would have been motivated to produce. And second, they made everyone less free.
Less free plus less stuff? Sure, sign me up... not.
- skedaddle 6y agoBut that's not how any of it works to begin with. Inequality isn't caused because people produce proportionally more or less. The very wealthy generally own property that has appreciated in value, or have inherited it. Among working people, the differences fundamentally come from labor markets, not our productivity. An engineer might make more or less than someone else on their team, but they both make multitudes more than the people assembling beams for an apartment building. You should totally enjoy the freedom to be a productive member of society, that's not where inequality originates.
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago> An engineer might make more or less than someone else on their team, but they both make multitudes more than the people assembling beams for an apartment building. That is, an engineer produces more of what society values than an assembler does. And why does society value it more? Scarcity. More people can assemble beams than can do solid engineering. You can say that society isn't valuing the right things. That might be a defensible position. But in general, attempts to "fix" that problem run into the problem that the fixers don't know enough. The results are sub-optimal - not just theoretically, but in very concrete ways. But even if you put everyone on roughly equivalent wages... the people who enter YC aren't doing it because the wages are higher. They're trying, with a very small number of people, to build something useful to many people. That's productivity. Why do they do it? Somewhat because they believe in what they're trying to do, but also because they see it as a chance to make a lot of money. They're not doing it by owning property. They're not inheriting it. They're making it by building something. Now, are you going to let them become inequal? Or not?
- throwaway2245 6y ago> If I want to have more than you, and I can get it by [exploiting labour and existing material resources]... why not? >If I can't get rewarded for [exploiting labour and material resources], I probably won't [exploit labour and material resources]. >First, society doesn't get the extra that some people would have been motivated to produce. "Society" doesn't get that extra anyway, if we are talking about billionaires keeping hold of an 11-figure income. The same labour and material resources exist in the world either way (perhaps moreso, if they are not used up unsustainably to the point of scarcity); the "extra" only accrues to the person doing the exploiting.
- platz 6y ago> The world which he imagines... with some a little richer but not too much so, is not one in which I want to live. He specifically says people will not be equally remunerated in the article; this whole thread is basically attacking a straw man of some other position that he is not himself advancing.