3 ms·
So in essence, you don't like citation needed comments because you believe (a priori) that anyone making one is acting in bad faith and their comments cannot be
by bawolff 6y ago
So in essence, you don't like citation needed comments because you believe (a priori) that anyone making one is acting in bad faith and their comments cannot be taken at face value? Or is it just that you believe attacking the veracity of a premise is not a valid counter argument?
Isn't one of the guidelines of this site "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."?
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoSaying “you have to prove your premise” is not a good faith attempt to show the premise lacks evidentiary support. Maybe the premise has plenty of support, maybe not. Maybe everyone else already has that context and you being ignorant of it isn’t the other party’s problem to solve. Or maybe the other party is a conspiracy crank and telling them they failed to supply evidence is solely flame bait. None of these options advance the conversation or assist other readers. If you say “citation needed” and you believe that has rebutted or refuted or challenged the other party in some way, you are wrong. It has not done so, regardless of the merit or lack of merit of their claims.