3 ms·
One of the earlier proposals for DST suggested shifting by 20 minutes four times in spring and back four times in autumn. Counting hours from sunrise or sunset
by fanf2 6y ago
One of the earlier proposals for DST suggested shifting by 20 minutes four times in spring and back four times in autumn. Counting hours from sunrise or sunset (instead of noon) was common in the ancient world. (They were often rubber hours so there were always 12 hours of day and 12 of night regardless of the season.)
Some years ago I sketched a way to do smoothed DST based on when the sun rises. The trick is to avoid time zone differences due to differences in latitude (as well as longitude). I chose to use sunrise at the nearest tropic as the benchmark, which gives you a gradual DST adjustment of about an hour and a half between winter and summer, changing by up to a minute or two each day. http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/search?query=Sunrise+time+Finch http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/search?query=Sunrise+time+Fin...
- dahart 6y agoYes exactly, I like this proposal! "The essential idea is that our clocks should be set using sunrise as a benchmark instead of noon." Are you pursuing it, and did you get any valuable feedback?
- fanf2 6y agoWell, it was originally intended as satire (hence the reference to Jonathan Swift in the subject line) - even though its logic makes some kind of sense, it is completely impractical :-) I do have a bit of sketchy software that compares various times (local apparent solar time, local mean solar time, standard/daylight time, smoothed sunrise-based time, times of sunrise/noon/sunset) but I have never found a good enough reference for the astronomical calculations to be happy with it.
- dahart 6y agoOh jeez, hahaha whoosh, the joke went totally over my head - is that whole publication satire? Do you think it's becoming more likely to be practical over time? I'd guess it's still impractical, but the percent of the world's online-connected clocks has definitely skyrocketed in the last 10 years with the proliferation of smart phones...
- fanf2 6y agoRISKS is mostly sensible though it has a sense of humour especially around the 1st April :-) RISKS is one of the oldest mailing lists, since 1985, worth subscribing if you have an interest in computer systems security.