4 ms·
> Torrents are nothing more than a clever idea without The Pirate Bay No, there are magnets now. You can send a torrent as a hash. The reason it won't work is
by pessimizer 6y ago
> Torrents are nothing more than a clever idea without The Pirate Bay
No, there are magnets now. You can send a torrent as a hash.
The reason it won't work is because you can just take that hash, log all of the swarm ips, send secret letters to all of the isps to reveal the seeders and leechers, bust in their doors and arrest them, publicize their arrests in every newspaper and on every television channel, interrogate them to expose more of the network, then if the law lags create parallel constructions to convict the most important people as the ringleaders of a copyright-violating cartel, and let the rest languish in jail for a little while before dropping the charges six months later and releasing them after their names have been in the paper.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoHas anything like that ever happened?
- Matt3o12_ 6y agoIn Germany it is quite common to get a fine for that (an adhortatory letter or Abmahnung in German). Media companies monitor torrents, and as soon as they see a new German ip address seeding, they send a letter to the ISP with the IP address and timestamp. The ISPs send the law firm the real user address and then they send you a letter demanding a fine for illegally uploading copyrighted material often between 1000-3000€. If you don't pay up, they take you to court. This is quite common and many people see letters even if they only seed for a few seconds. Apparently the easiest way is to just ignore the letters and pretend you don't live there but I wouldn't be so sure (a friend told me that's what he did and it allegedly worked but I have no experience with either). So this is a lot less drastic but still quite as effective. And it even makes VPNs risky because disconnecting and exposing your real IP for even one second is enough to receive that letter (though not all torrents are monitored and private torrents are usually safe because the German RIAA doesnt have access to it). I recommend you take a look at the Wikipedia about "Abmahnung" how that is even possible when the copyright holders don't sue themselves: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abmahnung https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abmahnung
- BlueTemplar 6y agoDo you have any proof that this actually works? My experience is that instead most people switched to Netflix, Spotify, YouTube (et al.) because they were more convenient and cheap enough, and the MAFIAA mostly stopped caring about torrents. And people that were worried about getting fined started using VPNs/seedboxes. I still haven't heard of anyone in my circles getting a fine.
- gamblor956 6y agoIt used to happen in the U.S. quite frequently in the days of Kazaa/Limewire. If you got caught pirating a movie, your ISP would cut you off after 1-3 strikes. It doesn't happen as much anymore because it's now easier to get a high-quality version of the movie through legitimate means than through illegitimate ones.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoThat's very different then the implication of a SWAT team busting in your door and carting you off to prison for some unspecified amount of time on account of copyright infringement.
- gamblor956 6y agoThat was never the MPAA. The law firms they originally hired for those cases were behind that and were sanctioned for it. The RIAA and MPAA are aggressive, but they're not stupid.