3 ms·
You have a very high opinion of politicians and policy-making. Perhaps too high an opinion, I fear. It's not that uncommon for such policy decisions not to be
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
You have a very high opinion of politicians and policy-making. Perhaps too high an opinion, I fear.
It's not that uncommon for such policy decisions not to be fact-based because "of course it's better", so I'll keep my critical stance on governments' policies.
> Also, this argument sounds a bit like sunk cost fallacy to me: the car already exists, so whatever embodied energy it has is irrelevant.
No this is not the point. It costs energy and resources to scrap a car and to produce and distribute its replacement so this should be taken into account. Keeping a car longer reduces the need to produce more cars and to scrap existing cars. If I scrap my car every year than a car must be scrapped and a new car produced every year. If I keep my car for 20 years then this process occurs much less often, which is much more economical in terms of energy and resources.
The cost of the subsidy could also be spent on something else that may or may not have an higher impact.
I am just saying that this is the sort of decision that cannot be judged at face value, which seems to be what many people do ("great decision", "of course it's positive", etc), without digging quite deep into the numbers. And I must say that your comment goes in the same direction.
So, maybe it is positive and useful, maybe not so much. They would need to show the numbers for anyone to make an informed opinion.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vanderZwan 6y ago> You have a very high opinion of politicians and policy-making. Perhaps too high an opinion, I fear. Could we please not use personal accusations like these? I disagree with your viewpoint, fine. To point at that as if this must mean it is an unreasonable and naive opinion, without giving any factual back-up of your own viewpoint isn't going to get us anywhere. > It costs energy and resources to scrap a car and to produce and distribute its replacement so this should be taken into account. - the scrapping of said car is an eventual cost regardless - the replacement is not another car
- mytailorisrich 6y agoI don't understand the reason for arguing and turning aggressive here. My only viewpoint is to reserve judgement on these policies if the facts are not known and to state that governments do not always make fact-based decisions on these issues (all issues in fact) because these are difficult and technical issues and that politics dictates a level of showing that something (anything) is done. If this policy is indeed fact-based then very good. If it is, and will be, assessed on clearly defined metrics then even better.