3 ms·
Standard "cash-for-clunckers" schemes are about subsidising the auto industry, they are about boosting sales. Now this one seems different but what is missing
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
Standard "cash-for-clunckers" schemes are about subsidising the auto industry, they are about boosting sales.
Now this one seems different but what is missing is an analysis on whether it is a good use of resources and actually positive for the environment to spend money on scrapping an existing car instead of continuing to use it for its useful lifetime and only then to replace it for a better car or mode of transport.
- pjc50 6y agoDoes Lithuania have a car industry?
- nimmen 6y agoSuch small country does not have proper car industry, but there are some local electrical trolleybuses made(maybe few dozen a year), or some parts for automotive industry - like continental tire factory in Kaunas, some parts made for mercedes, etc, etc...
- rmind 6y agoPerhaps you meant electric buses, e.g. https://www.dancerbus.com/ https://www.dancerbus.com/ ?
- nercury 6y agoNo, trolleybuses: https://kauno.diena.lt/sites/default/files/styles/940x000/public/sites/default/files/test/652__31051b.jpg?itok=NFf8N3iM https://kauno.diena.lt/sites/default/files/styles/940x000/pu...
- mk3 6y agoWe don't construct cars, but we have some companies here, Siemens has wiring factory, CIE Forge is manufacturing engine parts for VW concern, And some super specialized CNC workshops manufacturing parts for car industry too. But it's not a major contributing factor for economy.
- vanderZwan 6y ago> what is missing is an analysis on I highly doubt it that this is missing - it's just not mentioned in the article. Also, this argument sounds a bit like sunk cost fallacy to me: the car already exists, so whatever embodied energy it has is irrelevant. It is likely to stay on the road for decades if not encouraged to be removed. Meanwhile the embodied energy of an ebike or escooter is tiny by comparison, can in principle be powered by renewable energy, and the difference in energy footprint is so huge that I would be very surprised if it doesn't earn itself back long before the expected life-time of the car ends. On top of that there's reduction of traffic congestion and air pollution, and less pressure to create infrastructure (like parking space) for cars. All of which is the kind of externalized cost that isn't actually externalized if you're a government.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoYou have a very high opinion of politicians and policy-making. Perhaps too high an opinion, I fear. It's not that uncommon for such policy decisions not to be fact-based because "of course it's better", so I'll keep my critical stance on governments' policies. > Also, this argument sounds a bit like sunk cost fallacy to me: the car already exists, so whatever embodied energy it has is irrelevant. No this is not the point. It costs energy and resources to scrap a car and to produce and distribute its replacement so this should be taken into account. Keeping a car longer reduces the need to produce more cars and to scrap existing cars. If I scrap my car every year than a car must be scrapped and a new car produced every year. If I keep my car for 20 years then this process occurs much less often, which is much more economical in terms of energy and resources. The cost of the subsidy could also be spent on something else that may or may not have an higher impact. I am just saying that this is the sort of decision that cannot be judged at face value, which seems to be what many people do ("great decision", "of course it's positive", etc), without digging quite deep into the numbers. And I must say that your comment goes in the same direction. So, maybe it is positive and useful, maybe not so much. They would need to show the numbers for anyone to make an informed opinion.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jmull 6y agoMy guess is the level of subsidy here is low enough that not too many cars with a lot of use left in them are being scrapped. That is, the cars being traded in were going to get scrapped soon in any case. The main effect of the subsidy is to move people to greener alternatives, rather than finding another car.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> That is, the cars being traded in were going to get scrapped soon in any case. Would not that make this subsidy no more than a "windfall gain", then? I.e. it makes little to no difference and people are just happy to pocket the extra money. > The main effect of the subsidy is to move people to greener alternatives, rather than finding another car. An ebike/escooter is quite different from a car so I have my doubt that people will change their purchasing decisions base on a small-ish cash bonus: If I need a car I will still buy a car but if I was already thinking of buying an ebike/escooter than obviously I like the windfall as a bonus. Or maybe I'll buy an ebike with the subsidy cash in addition to buying a new car...
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoPeople have cars for all sorts of reasons. To the degree this program works, some good will have been done. And it is likely to sway some who had not considered the options yet. Especially with the subsidy. Sad the article doesn't report anything about changes in e-bike use etc. Just that people are applying for and taking taking the money. Of course they are.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> To the degree this program works, some good will have been done. You need to objectively define what "works" means. We need to compare the cost with the effect and with the likely course of events without the subsidy (the latter is often difficult to do especially when the 'natural' trend already goes in the same direction as what the policy tries to encourage, and in this case sales e-bikes and e-scooters are already booming). I may sound very critical. This is because I do think that many of these so-called "green initiatives" at the moment cost public money with no clearly quantified or quantifiable benefits at a time when public finances in most European countries are already pushed to the limit. > Just that people are applying for and taking taking the money. Of course they are. Indeed.