5 ms·
I strongly disagree with the conclusion: Why did Mileva remain silent? Being reserved and self-effaced, she did not seek honors or public attention. She was f
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
I strongly disagree with the conclusion:
Why did Mileva remain silent? Being reserved and self-effaced, she did not seek honors or public attention.
She was failed and denied a degree in spite of having better grades than Albert, probably solely because she was a woman. Albert was probably blocked from employment positions he wanted by the same professor that failed her, possibly because he was treating a woman like his equal.
This reads to me like they coped as best they could with a world that absolutely wouldn't accept a woman as a serious scientist and even with trying to be self effacing, etc, they both paid a high price -- such a high price, it likely destroyed their marriage.
- cvbcvbcvbcvbc 6y agoPure speculation, though.
- DoreenMichele 6y ago"Pure speculation" ...by a woman who is likely the only woman to have ever spent time on the leader board of HN, who is a former full-time wife and mom, who was a top student in her graduating high school class and a National Merit Scholarship winner and ended up a homemaker anyway instead of having a "real career," who has studied social things both formally (in college) and informally (out of personal interest trying to figure out why I didn't get the two-career couple lifestyle I thought I would get)...among other things. (edited to correct a typo)
- jpxw 6y agoThe chip on your shoulder is showing
- DoreenMichele 6y agoRather ironic that my above comment is being downvoted and I am being accused of having a chip on my shoulder in a discussion about how Einstein's first wife got insufficient credit for her contributions to his work. I'm merely explaining what informs my point of view to someone whose handle was about 30 minutes old when I replied to it on the assumption that they have no idea what my background is.
- coldtea 6y agoWouldn't that make it less strong than speculation? It would make it speculation by someone with a stronger bias towards a specific explanation due to their personal experiences.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoIt's a somewhat unique point of view from someone who has studied such things to try to figure out how and why they work that way in hopes of escaping such patterns. It's frustrating but not exactly surprising that this is rapidly turning into a dismissive pile on.
- herodoturtle 6y agoFWIW, I for one enjoyed reading your perspective. This is something my wife and I discuss all the time. We're both ambitious in our respective careers, and your points have added value to my view of this discussion. Thanks for sharing.
- pjc50 6y agoYeah, if a woman suggests that HN might be a bit sexist there is inevitably a horde of people rushing to prove their non-sexism by downvoting the one woman in the discussion.
- Chris2048 6y agob/c if there is one woman in a discussion then that woman is the official rep/mascot/bellweather of all womankind.. or maybe the sex/gender of the user is not relevant to the reason for the downvotes? and maybe even refraining from downvoting a post b/c that user is a woman is itself sexist?
- coldtea 6y ago>and maybe even refraining from downvoting a post b/c that user is a woman is itself sexist? You're not supposed to say that, or treat women as equals -- in that you equally troll them / equally openly disagree / become equally aggresive / or equally "well actually" them as you'd do for any fellow nerd... Equality somehow means "treat women equal, but different". For example "well actually" it's something a nerd does to another nerd all the time. If you do it to woman though, it's "mansplaining" and its sexist...
- jb1991 6y ago> woman who is likely the only woman to have ever spent time on the leader board of HN What?
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThe leader board of HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/leaders https://news.ycombinator.com/leaders My previous handle is Mz. It hit the leader board in October 2017. About six weeks later, I changed my handle to this one. As far as I know, I am the only member who posts as openly female who has spent time on the leader board.
- jb1991 6y agoSince you spend a lot of your time on this social media site and get listed as one of its frequent users, that means you can empathize with Einstein's wife?
- DoreenMichele 6y agoNo, that's just a thing I can relatively readily point to that gets respected here if you have male bits between your legs but gets roundly dismissed as worthless internet points if you have female bits between your legs. I can empathize with her because I was one of the top three students of my graduating class and had the highest SAT scores of my class. I was STAR student and a National Merit Scholarship winner. I was inducted into Mu Alpha Theta, a college-level math honor society, at age 16 in eleventh grade, the earliest you can be inducted. At age 15, I was state alternate for the Governor's Honors Program, a residential gifted summer enrichment program. That means only two other people outperformed me in the entire state of Georgia on a topic I sort of picked randomly out of a hat because I was a well-rounded student and didn't have any particular area of obvious strength like most candidates. But more to the point, I have a form of cystic fibrosis and I have been getting myself well for nearly two decades while the entire world calls me crazy and a teller of tall tales and a liar and throws me off of one forum after another which is why I don't cite it more often as a reason I can empathize with someone like Mileva Einstein. I much more often compare myself to Semmelweis and talk about trying hard to not end up locked up in an insane asylum and beaten to death for the crime of thinking I know something medically useful. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis What I know really ought to qualify me for something like the Nobel Prize in Medicine. But I'm not holding my breath. I'm not likely to ever get any recognition for my accomplishments. The dismissive nonsense in this thread is very much the norm, unfortunately.
- vagrantJin 6y ago> ...a National Merit Scholarship winner and ended a homemaker anyway instead of having a "real career," I would be interested to know why you feel you are entitled to a 'two-career' lifestyle. That you are not is a choice you made, unless you can give the name of the person who pointed a gun to your head to prove otherwise. If you are unhappy with your choices, take responsibility and make amends.
- watwut 6y agoNone of that however makes you more likely to be right about 1930 Germany social structures and behavior. It does give you some insight into stay at home situation and such. > possibly because he was treating a woman like his equal This for example is complete speculation. Him being Jew and him being undisciplined (his bad grades in math were totally due to that) had likely to do with it a lot more.
- tpush 6y ago> [...] (his bad grades in math were totally due to that) Einstein never had bad grades in math, that’s a myth.
- watwut 6y agoHis undergraduate and graduate results were mediocre. He had good high school results, but not in college.
- cvbcvbcvbcvbc 6y agoHe was given extra reading material and read advanced math books while in high school, afaik.
- will4274 6y ago> the leader board of HN Fwiw, the [hacker news guidelines](https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html) ask that you avoid commenting on voting (like this one). > Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. This pattern - posting something controversial and breaking the rules - and then blaming it on people not liking the controversial thing you said - is not uncommon. Indeed, I frequently see comments to the effect of "See Trump was right about the tech companies being monopolies but people here will downvote me because they hate Trump" sitting at the bottom of every thread when I enable "showdead". In sum - if you want to get more votes (as you apparently care about votes) and for people to give your ideas more consideration - consider not self-sabotaging by pairing your ideas with a rule breaking comment. Fwiw, this is the third time I've seen you bring up your rank on the HN leaderboard. It's also the third time I've heard of the HN leaderboard. I'm not sure if somebody being ranked on HN makes me more or less likely to consider their argument - probably less, because it means they spend too much time on social media - but it's not a strong effect in any case. Simply put - does literally anybody care about that leaderboard besides you?
- fxtentacle 6y agoBoth of them appear to be highly rational people. And I'd wager that the scientific world was already a "winner takes all" competition back then. 1 scientist ranking in the worldwide top 10 will likely earn much more than 2 scientists ranking on the top 11-20, because at the extreme, compensation tends to go up exponentially. My understanding of the article is that they were aware and, thus, Mileva made the rational decision to boost her husband's career at the expense of her own career. Albert: "I need my wife. She solves for me all my mathematical problems." Mileva: "Before our departure, we finished an important scientific work which will make my husband known around the world." To me, that sounds like a rational plan to make him famous by letting him pretend to also possess the skills that in reality his wife provides. Plus, we now know in hindsight that it worked. And obviously, a groundbreaking work attributed to only one person seems even more impressive than if it was attributed to a team. EDIT: It also appears to me that Mileva was smart enough to recognize the value of her assistance: "In 1919, she agreed to divorce, with a clause stating that if Albert ever received the Nobel Prize, she would get the money. When she did, she bought two small apartment buildings [..]"
- DoreenMichele 6y agoKaren Blixen (17 April 1885 – 7 September 1962) published her first book under the male pen name Isak Denisen. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karen_Blixen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karen_Blixen Colette (28 January 1873 – 3 August 1954) initially ghost wrote for her husband and when they split she ended up dirt poor because he owned all the copyrights in his name and she had no claim to any of it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colette https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colette These are people from around the same time frame. Sexism was a much bigger problem at that time than it is today and it remains alive and well. Edit: See, for example: Homme de Plume: What I Learned Sending My Novel Out Under a Male Name https://jezebel.com/homme-de-plume-what-i-learned-sending-my-novel-out-und-1720637627 https://jezebel.com/homme-de-plume-what-i-learned-sending-my...
- fxtentacle 6y agoI agree with your first 2 examples. But in my opinion, the fact that back then sexism caused strong income differences only makes it even more likely that this was a rationally coordinated team effort by the Einstein's. As for that destroying their marriage, it seems that she got pregnant from another man, while he had multiple affairs, so I wonder if they were ever strongly physically attracted to each other. To me, it seems more likely that they were mentally best friends, but physically craved others. I kind of dislike your Jezebel link because in my opinion, their goal is mostly to spread hate as opposed to improving the situation. So I'd wager that their experiment was skewed to produce the intended result. I mean even the magazine's name is provocation aimed at conservative christian men: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Revelation+2%3A20&version=NIV https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Revelation+2%3A... Plus, they haven't been exactly balanced on gender issues in the past ;) "Men are in crisis. The successes of women in the workplace have caused them confusion [..]. They’re becoming radicalized [..] romantic rejection [..] mass murder." https://theattic.jezebel.com/the-paradox-of-how-to-feminism-for-men-1845218608 https://theattic.jezebel.com/the-paradox-of-how-to-feminism-...
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> a world that absolutely wouldn't accept a woman as a serious scientist Wouldn’t Marie Curie’s Nobel Prize present a counterfactual to the absolutism of this claim?
- part1of2 6y agoIt’s not as simple as that. They tried to award it just to her husband before splitting it in half and awarding both. Marie Curie’s Wikipedia page says: “At first the committee had intended to honour only Pierre Curie and Henri Becquerel, but a committee member and advocate for women scientists, Swedish mathematician Magnus Gösta Mittag-Leffler, alerted Pierre to the situation, and after his complaint, Marie's name was added to the nomination.[45] Marie Curie was the first woman to be awarded a Nobel Prize.[24”
- goto11 6y agoNevertheless she got awarded a second Nobel Prize after the death of Pierre Curie. One and a half Nobel price is still more recognition than almost anybody else, including Albert Einstein.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoTo my mind, Marie Curie wasn't exactly met with acceptance. It was a really huge uphill battle for her from the beginning. For example, in defiance of laws against women getting an education, she attended a secret university for women. https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/the-secret-polish-university-for-women-where-marie-curie-got-her-start https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/the-secret-polish-univ... Mileva Einstein had unprecedented support and was initially admitted to an all boys school thanks in part to family backing, but later tried repeatedly to complete her degree and was denied a degree and finally gave up. I will suggest that Marie Curie ended up with more recognition in part because she had to go to school secretly in defiance of the law. Mileva Einstein began with a really remarkable and unusual degree of family support for her interests and aspirations and this may have left her ill-prepared for dealing effectively with an openly hostile sexist social climate. It also possibly made her more of a target because she was performing a full frontal assault on sexism instead of quietly doing an end run around the issue. That tends to get a lot more push back. To this day, the #MeToo movement suggests most women with serious careers pay a rather high price in terms of having to face constant sexual harassment and even sexual assault. There would have been far less support at that time than there is now and women generally tend to express the idea that there is far too little now. In my own life, where I have persisted in the face of an uphill battle it has consistently been a situation where I felt like I had no real choice. I felt backed into a corner and like this -- whatever "this" was -- was the least-worst option available to me or the only option. I believe that one of the things that accounts for poorer performance/outcomes (career-wise) for women is that when women have options -- like letting their husband provide for them while they raise their children and pursue their interests in a more hobby-like fashion -- they tend to take them. Taking a stand tends to come at a high price. Many people simply choose to not pay that price if they have any way out, even if it means letting their career dreams die as a consequence of trying to protect themselves. I don't think most people breaking barriers are really people who just want to take a stand and make a statement and make a difference. I think most of them are like me: Someone who has some ability to outperform others in some metrics whose situation doesn't readily give them a way out of the confrontation with society. I don't think anyone should be sitting in judgment of Mileva for wanting to try to support her husband's career and eschew credit for herself in some vain attempt to try to get a comfortable life that didn't really materialize. And I think it is ugly behavior when people act like "Well, she made a choice and didn't want it badly enough" or something like that (as is all too often the way this gets framed). It's kind of like that scene in Good Will Hunting where he talks about his abusive father laying out three things and giving him a "choice" as to which one he wants to be beaten with. In a sick system, most people are trying desperately to find some way to say "Well, I really don't want to be beaten at all." while the world looks on and says, more or less, "You chose to be beaten because you answered the abusive question as to which instrument you would like to be beaten with." To my mind, that's the crux of a sick system and it underlies an awful lot of social ills, such as sexism, racism and homophobia. If you are "the wrong kind of person," the world simply doesn't give you the option to have nice things. It insists that you must choose between these various ugly options and then acts like you have no right to complain about your suffering "because you made this choice." Sometimes, people are some combination of talented and lucky and manage to quietly have a nice life anyway, in spite of being "the wrong kind of person." But that tends to not go hand-in-hand with breaking social barriers and becoming extremely prominent in your field. People who become extremely prominent in spite of being "the wrong kind of person" tend to pay a price for it beyond the usual price for success.
- goto11 6y agoMore likely he was discriminated because he was Jewish.
- staunch 6y agoMileva sat for the intermediate diploma examinations in 1899, one year later than the other students in her group. Her grade average of 5.05 (scale 1–6) placed her fifth out of the six students taking the examinations that year.[6] (Einstein had come top of the previous year's candidates with a grade average of 5.7)[8] Marić's grade in physics was 5.5 (the same as Einstein). In 1900, she failed the final teaching diploma examinations with a grade average of 4.00, having obtained only grade 2.5 in the mathematics component (theory of functions).[9] Einstein passed the exam in fourth place with a grade average of 4.91.[10] Marić's academic career was disrupted in 1901 when she became pregnant by Einstein. When three months pregnant, she resat the diploma examination, but failed for the second time without improving her grade. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mileva_Mari%C4%87 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mileva_Mari%C4%87