5 ms·
PSN database with 2.2 million credit card details up for sale?
- tlrobinson 16y agoThe most baffling thing is the data apparently includes CVV2 numbers, which are never supposed to be stored by merchants. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Card_security_code http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Card_security_code
- elithrar 16y agoDid not Sony state they did not store any CVV2 numbers?
- Nate75Sanders 16y agoI'm in a bar, drunk, and this was my exact reaction. This is what I remember reading on, I think, arstechnica. When will the lying stop?
- auston 16y agoAgreed! I guess Sony was itchin' for that bank approval. For the uninitiated: Submitting a transaction with CVV2 has a much higher likelihood of being approved by the bank.
- jrockway 16y agoSony is probably such a big merchant that the rules don't apply. Sony said, "we have 13 millions users, and we're fucking Sony, not Mom And Pop Coffee Shop". The banks said, "fine, store the damn CVV2s so users don't have to type them every time".
- ra 16y agoNo, it's against the PCI guidelines to store the CVV number under any circumstances [1]. I'm not a PCI expert but as I understand it, if a merchant does store CVV numbers they can be fined for doing so. But that fine will be chicken feed compared to the costs Sony will incur if they are found to have leaked credit card details [2]. [1] http://www.braintreepaymentsolutions.com/blog/merchants-are-prohibited-from-storing-cvv2-csc-per-pci-standards http://www.braintreepaymentsolutions.com/blog/merchants-are-... [2] http://www.braintreepaymentsolutions.com/blog/pci-compliance-and-the-cost-of-a-credit-card-breach http://www.braintreepaymentsolutions.com/blog/pci-compliance... NB: I've got nothing to do with Braintree - but their blog is excellent
- jrockway 16y agoI don't see anything in PCI to indicate that it's a law or that Sony can't negotiate different terms with each of the card issuers / networks. When you have billions of dollars, you can probably get Visa, Mastercard, Discover, and Amex all in a room and dictate whatever terms you want.
- derobert 16y agoVisa, MasterCard, and American Express are each individually bigger than Sony (but comparable). Certainly Sony is big enough that it can negotiate with them, but its hard to imagine them being able to dictate terms. So, Sony may be allowed to store CVV numbers, but if so its likely that they negotiated that, giving up something in return (possibly, for example, agreeing to penalties in event of disclosure). [note: I checked bigger in terms of market cap. I'm confident this is also true in any reasonable way of comparing.]
- elithrar 16y agoSimilar to http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2496317 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2496317
- ra 16y agoAbout 3 or 4 days before the PSN went down, my credit card number was compromised, and handful of small 'test' transactions were made from the mainland US (according to my bank). My bank spotted the fraudulent transactions and cancelled the card. It might be a coincidence, but Sony did have that card number on my PSN account. I guess I'll find out one day when someone bit torrents the database.
- jrockway 16y agoI doubt someone would sell all 2.2 million at once, because it's very easy for the banks to say "all the cards that have ever used playstation network are compromised" and simply deactivate all of them all at once. UPDATE accounts SET flagged = 1 WHERE id IN (SELECT id FROM accounts, transactions WHERE transaction.merchant = 'PlayStation Network'). Done. All 2.2 million numbers useless. (This is a lot of customer service / re-issuing work, so it's probably a last resort that the banks will only do when they're sure that they are not deactivating non-compromised accounts. So if you are the people that broke into Sony for this info, you are probably going to want to sell only a small percentage of card numbers so that the banks' risk analysis does not decide on the above strategy.)
- wccrawford 16y agoDon't bother selling mine, guys. It's already cancelled. And if Sony was responsible and contacted everyone, with big bold letters saying their credit card info was stolen, the rest of them would be cancelled, too. Instead, they waited a week and a half before emailing, and then only said that cards -might- have been taken and they couldn't tell for sure. The only responsible thing would have been to assume they were and inform your customers of such. I've seen people saying that because it 'might' not have been stolen, and it's a hassle to get a new card, they aren't going to bother and just wait to see if any fraud happens. Ugh. Sony actually should do 1 step better and contact the credit card venders directly and get them all invalidated. Just to be safe. It'll be bad PR, but with all the other bad PR lately, it's a drop in the bucket and at least errs on the side of safety for a change.