11 ms·
Another Now by Yanis Varoufakis
- mmm_grayons 6y agoHe's definitely right about problems. The state has too much power, and it abuses it to curtail the liberties of its citizens and enforce a crony-capitalist structure. But his solutions are wrong, and furthermore, beyond small critiques of his policies, I take broad issue with his vision. The world which he imagines - a world in which everyone is more or less equal, with some a little richer but not too much so, is not one in which I want to live. He also seems to enumerate the many wrongs of state force, then conveniently omit the sort of force that would be necessary to seize all this property. He mentions that all land would be held in common - this wouldn't just be taking the wealth of a few billionaires and giving everyone a few extra bucks. I am glad we do not live in such as society, and hope America will never head in such a direction. Edit: I cannot reply to comments on this thread for some reason, so I will reply to 'uxcolumbo's response here. You ask why, say, $100m is not enough. Perhaps it is - it's probably enough for most of the things I could think to do, though not all. That said, the article implies that very rich people would have much less than $100m. And finally, I don't believe it's moral to cap wealth. It's a poor attempt to address the symptom rather than the disease - taking away their wealth won't fix it. Perhaps under a government with less corruption it would be difficult or impossible to amass the levels of wealth we see today, and I'd have no issues with that occurring under those circumstances.
- uxcolumbo 6y agoCan you provide more details why you don’t want to live in a world where everyone is more or less equal? I think Varoufakis is trying to paint a future where the gap between rich and poor isn’t as wide as it is now. Do we need billionaires for our society to function? Is having 100,000,000 USD not enough?
- scollet 6y agoEven just assets in general or access to resources. He makes a good point about equality in merit but people often misread the scales on what a meritocracy should be. It's not what you do produce, it's what you can produce. And in this egalitarian world, people who need access to resources should not have to hurdle to get them.
- roenxi 6y ago> Do we need billionaires for our society to function? Is having 100,000,000 USD not enough? Nobody knows. Maybe yes. Maybe no. Notice that billionaires can't spend all their money on themselves. They can't exactly buy a billion dollars worth of cheese and eat it all. They can sink whatever they like in to property but realistically they probably only spend a few million dollars on property and the vast bulk of their wealth goes in to directing the economy via shares and real estate. So if all the billions of dollars was removed from the billionaires they will experience a very modest (potentially no) change in quality of life and there will be far reaching economic consequences because the control structure was just reworked. It is totally unclear if it would be a win or a loss for most people.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Do we need billionaires for our society to function? I think so. Since antiquity, the advantages and disadvantages of monarchy, oligarchy and democracy have been mooted. The Founding Fathers vested the efficiency of monarchy in the executive and its long-term orientation in the Supreme Court. But there is unique strength in the union of long-term orientation and efficiency. It enables a portfolio of moonshots. Musk, Ford, Edison, Bezos and Gates each pursued long-term non-commercial (or semi-commercial) projects that benefited the public. The government could have done some of these things. But it didn’t. And it couldn’t have done all—there isn’t enough political bandwidth. As long as that money doesn’t turn into military power, and its effects on our politics are checked, the existence of billionaires is a net positive.
- the-smug-one 6y agoThere is a certain irony in you describing what billionaires have done but govt has not as "moon shots". You really have no proof that the govt could not have done these things, especially as govts has funded a lot of technology which has benefitted industry enormously (DARPANET, GPS, essential parts of Wi-fi). Could you please account for all of the negatives that billionaires have caused and show us your arithmetic for how they come out as net positive. >Since antiquity, the advantages and disadvantages of monarchy, oligarchy and democracy have been mooted. No idea what this means to be honest.
- eli_gottlieb 6y ago>Do we need billionaires for our society to function? Definitely not. They're exploiters, not producers.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Can you provide more details why you don’t want to live in a world where everyone is more or less equal? Because every time someone tries this to create a world like this... it ends up a living nightmare. Creating equality usually ends up involving taking away freedom and oppressing people. Maybe it's inherently not such a hot idea for some social reason we don't yet fully understand? I don't know but I'm not sure we should keep trying as millions of people end up dead every time someone gives it another whirl.
- claudeganon 6y ago> Because every time someone tries this to create a world like this... it ends up a living nightmare. How would you describe the US now, out of curiosity?
- chrisseaton 6y agoFor all the complex and serious problems the US has, I think it's still generally a stable and safe place with plenty of opportunity and nice people. I'd feel safer there than many other historical places that had aimed more aggressively at more-or-less equal societies. Few people seem to risk their lives to defect from the US. And they wouldn't even have to because the US lets you leave!
- claudeganon 6y ago> I'd feel safer there than many other historical places that had aimed more aggressively at more-or-less equal societies. ...but almost every developed country with greater social safety nets and less inequality performs above the US on all measures of “safety,” whether you’re talking about actual violence or more abstract things like infant mortality. How do you square that material reality with the current state of the US?
- chrisseaton 6y agoI think in general moving towards allowing people to achieve equality themselves is good. I think going hell-bent on more-of-less-equal starts to bring out the monsters in people.
- rutledge87 6y agoWho should have more power then? Mobs of open carrying "poll watchers" or folks in white hoods? Corporations? Uninformed voters who are easily convinced by targeted FB ads? Old, wise people with nothing to gain or lose?
- nine_k 6y agoIf we want democracy, it should be voters. If we want a working democracy, voters should care. Currently a lot of them don't, and thus stay uninformed, or take the elections as a sports event where they need to take a side and root.
- rutledge87 6y agoI don't think you understand what's going on. There is no democracy, it's a pantomime theater where the rich and their lackeys hold veto over the people's pseudo-choice. Being informed is futile if the system is rigged against the people.
- pharos92 6y agoI am so sick to death with the statement that "capitalism isn't working." We don't live in a capitalist economy, we live in a corporatist economy. Almost all the negative aspects of this current economic climate come down to: [1] Government misspending/policy at the behests of 'special interests' and [2] Monopolies that go untouched. When you realize that the government creates 9/10 monopolies, and that the remaining aspect of the equation is both fiscal corruption (at worst) or incompetence (at best), you realize that more government (socialism - event 'democratic') IS NOT the answer. True capitalism is responsible for much of the innovations, competition and successes of the 20th & 21st centuries. Sure there are aspects that it needs to answer for, and be held to account for - but that should be/is baked into the capitalist model.
- mmm_grayons 6y agoI believe you're right, but you must realize that your statement is similar to that some communists make: "real communism/capitalism/whateverism has never been tried yet," i.e. the No True Scotsman fallacy. The fair question to be asked is, "How can we restrict the state to prevent bastardizing capitalism and falling prey to corruption?" Capitalism seems to be much more resilient to it than communism, but we need to figure out how to further strengthen the state against this, because it's clearly slowly failing.
- jahaja 6y agoThe problem here is that too many of the detractors of socialism only recognizes a single version of it, a.k.a USSR and its off-spring. It doesn't matter how much democratic socialists were against it (and persecuted by it) at its inception, during its reign, and after its collapse. What example do you see of Socialism that started out democratic and still went down in misery?
- the-smug-one 6y agoGovernment funded research is responsible for much of the innovations, competition and successes of the 20th & 21st centuries. Let's be honest: Every single company which is dependent on the internet has the govt to thank for their success. There's just no way that the internet would've been a success without govts. I do agree that we live in a "corporatist economy" (neo-feudalist more like it) though and I agree that [1] and [2] are issues. I believe that the solution is more democracy, more equality, and more socialism.
- bluepoint 6y agoI think people are too gentle with this guy in this thread. He really does not deserve any of the attention that he gets and he desperately seeks. When he was in power he caused major damage, and as part of the current opposition he is basically a clown, looking for opportunities to get some more attention saying silly things. And since even in Greece he tends to get ignored (even by journalists who used to enjoy making fun of him), he is seeking for attention abroad. Like other commenters say, he raises some interesting issues about the society and then he proposes solutions that are at the same depth of political thought as discussions in a party (of the wild ones, with drugs and alcohol). He became important, when he was appointed as the minister of finance by the populist prime minister of a populist government, which came to power because people were really angry about the economic crisis. The prime minister, simply did not know much, he did not even speak english (he is still learning), or held any job before being a prime minister (yeah, Greek politics broke through the floor), but he finally realized his grave mistake and kicked him out, but not before capital controls were imposed in the country. Those capital controls were largely because of his useless role in the debt relief negotiations where he was basically avoiding to take any action or talking seriously to anyone, hoping that with this vague attitude (by the way, he termed his “creative vagueness” and he is proud of it, I am not making this up) the biggest leaders in europe will just bend the knee in fear of vague threats. He loves attention and he wants to be a sensation, which is not what you want from the guy who can kill the banks overnight (but admittedly less than your pilot or your surgeon). Some people that may not know him, may project on his image their own frustrations about life, politics or the economy. Maybe it is understandable, he is relatively photogenic and expresses himself with complete sentences (with verbs and nouns and propositions and all). But, really, we can all project our frustrations to people of higher quality, pretty please?
- breakfastduck 6y agoThe Greek economy had its death warrant signed the second he was kicked out of the party. He was one of the only people willing to stand up to the EU bullies & should be respected for that reason. I think your comment here is a bit of a stretch, and is presented as fact instead of opinion.
- 6y ago
- cblconfederate 6y agoThis guy is pompous and childish. Reminds me of everything that is wrong about greece
- LatteLazy 6y agoAh, yes, the man who crashed Greece and blames everyone else...
- grenoire 6y agoIn which way he crashed Greece? I'm not knowledgeable on this enough and would like to know more in details. I thought that the situation in Greece prior to him being instantiated as MoF (for a rather brief period of time) was not necessarily on a good track.
- pessimizer 6y agoBy suggesting that a road not taken should be taken, he's committed the sin of being a possible source of regret. Without him, Greece could just pretend their situation since is due to the weather. If you're an ideologue, you can somehow twist that regret into blaming him for German banks making massive loans to Greece to pay for things like military equipment that they didn't need, and the inability of Greece's currency to adjust in order to keep this from happening. That's a lot accomplished for an economist who was mostly ignored, except by the voters who his party ultimately ignored.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 6y agoThat's a fair question. This is a long and semi boring answer but I think it's accurate. I shouldn't have used the word "crashed", a more nuanced description would have been "made the crash much worse, longer and more painful for people leading to excess deaths and a great deal of suffering for no actual gain". But that's not as piffy. Background: Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece and Spain all spent more than they took in in taxes after they joined the euro. Greece was especially bad, tax evasion was endemic, public sector workers all retired at 50 etc. These countries kept borrowing and borrowing. Until the credit crunch happened (when the sub prime mortgage bubble burst in the US). When that happened there was suddenly a lot less cash available AND lenders got quite risk averse. So suddenly (it took about a year I think) all 5 countries had difficulty borrowing. When a country can't borrow, it had a few options: it can cut expenses, it can raise taxes or it can print money. Since the euro came in, no one in it can just print money. So these countries all needed to cut a lot of spending and raise a lot of taxes to replace their borrowing. The other option is to default on the debt. But that's a double edged sword because it saves you interest payments but it also means you can't borrow at all. So then you need to completely balance your books overnight. For comparison, Greece in 2009 was borrowing about 30% of its gdp per year. Thats about 60% of its tax base. So it would need to either halve its spending or more than double its taxes to close this gap. Imagine if you earned 40k a year, but then borrowed another 60k and spent 100k a year. Huge problem right? At the same time, here in the UK, we were implimenting an austerity program because although we were a lot better positioned than Greece et al, we didn't ever want to slip even 10% toward where they were. But remember, Greece got itself in this position by constantly lowering taxes and increasing spending for decades. No one made them do that. Some countries have dictators waste/steal money. Some have natural disasters like earthquakes that cause a sudden issue. Greece has no such excuse. Greece was in the worst position but Italy wasn't far behind. Spain wasn't far behind them etc. And these countries were sort of linked together: Italian banks owned Greek debt, so if Greece defaulted, Italian banks would need a bailout and the Italian government would need to borrow to do that which it couldn't really do. So a Greek default would likely mean an Italian default and so on. In order to make these unfortunate events less brutal, the IMF offered these countries loans. No one else would lend to them, and its that IMFs job: lender of last resort. But the IMF are strict, they won't just lend you money, they want to see how you'll cut costs and increase revenue and borrow less next year. They want it done and done quick. And that's understandable, you can't just keep lending someone money that they have no plan to repay right? And no one forces anyone to take these loans, they take them because its a better deal than not taking them and doing everything the IMF asked for plus more when you have no money at all... The EU (really Germany under Merkel) stepped in, and said that they would part fund (a third roughly) the loans with the IMF if the IMF made the terms lighter. The IMF agreed and most countries were pleased. Ireland actually went further than the new terms because they wanted to get their act together and get back to economic growth asap. To be clear here: the terms were tax increases and spending cuts. Spending cuts means reducing people pensions and spending less on schools and hospitals. It's not "nice", but you can't spend money you don't have. And Greece especially had some pretty corrupt programs (people were paid a 13th month, like a whole extra pay packet for no reason, state worker retirement age was 50 for many jobs, tax evasion was endemic). That sort of sets the stage for what was going on in southern Europe. Yanis Varoufakis's Part: All the other countries grumbled but took their medicine, because they didn't have a better offer. Greece refused, because Varoufakis (and the government he wad part of) refused to accept reality. He gave long speeches calling the IMF the problem and talking about how people have a right to whatever they want for free. He even made off colour comments about the Nazis while in Berlin "negotiating" with Germany, who owed Greece nothing and were making a pretty selfless effort to spare Greece some pain. Sort of like slapping the firefighter trying to put out the fire in your house. For about a year, it actually sort of worked. Greece were able to avoid actually cutting their spending or increasing revenue and Germany bailed them out, not because he was a genius at economics as he claimed, but because it was cheaper to loan (give) Greece another chunk of cash and keep them from defaulting than it was to bail out Italy and the others when Greece defaulted. But after a year or so, Italy and the others had cut spending and upped taxes. They were recovering. And the risk of a Greek default no longer meant problems in other places. So Germany stopped writing cheques. Then Greece had to enact harder, longer, more sudden austerity than it would have, because they could no longer extort Germany etc. That austerity ultimately worked. But there was a lot more pain and it all took longer than it could have. All because Varoufakis was a popularist who ran around convincing people that Germany/The IMF/Capitalism was the problem instead of simply saying "we should live within our means". Doing so of course increased support for him and crazy right wing parties and there were a bunch of xenophobic incidents. If he hadn't done that, if he'd done the opposite (like Ireland) then Greece would have had a much better time of it, exited austerity sooner and had less austerity in general. That's what I meant by crashed Greece. He didn't cause the core long term problem. But he, personally, made it much worse and made it last longer. On a personal note, I am a leftist. I really believe in markets working for people not the other way around. But to make that work, countries need to be self disciplined, spend within our means and make hard choices. Varoufakis is exactly the opposite of that: loud and rude and short termist and popularist. He and people like him are the reason we can't have more social programs and less inequality. That's my personal dislike of him. He's wrong and dangerous, but he's confident and everything he says sounds easy, so people believe it. Then you end up in turbo austerity with the IMF running your budget. I think he falls under that rule that it "exponentially more time to refute bullshit that to produce it". Thanks for reading.
- johnchristopher 6y agoTotally meta and OT but at the moment almost half the comments of this page are greyed out. It shows how lively the debate is (or maybe it'll settle one way or another, idk).
- lainga 6y agoI think the opposite is true. A lot of people expressing disagreement by trying to hide things they disagree with instead of rebutting them. I think the down arrow should be reserved for cases where you think they break "The Rules" (not the site rules, but your own judgment of good taste). But then again, maybe I am too lax in my judgment.
- pessimizer 6y agoOften when one disagrees with positions one also thinks they're lazy and a waste of time to discuss. If somebody in the thread "X is a problem" posts "Why don't we just do Y?" but when you google "X" every article starts with "We can't just do Y, because...," just downvote. This doesn't mean that doing "Y" isn't the answer, it means that if you're going to bring "Y" up, bring up all of the best arguments against "Y" that you already know first. Otherwise, you're just throwing out a low-effort troll tempting some good neighbor to spend a half-hour crafting an elaborate response for you; one ultimately unnecessary for anyone who has interest enough in the subject to google "X" and read the first hit. Your particular comment has probably been posted thousands of times, but HN isn't organized in a way that makes them easy to find.
- calcifer 6y ago> half the comments of this page are greyed out Deservedly so. Most (if not all) of those comments are ad hominems and doesn't address the proposed system in the article at all. In fact, there is no evidence those commentors have even read the article. One of them actually complains about how photogenic he is!
- mmm_grayons 6y agoNot really. Up until this morning, my comment had a positive number of votes; it is now very gray. It was not an ad hominem attack. It was a critique of the author's value more than his proposed policies, but I certainly read the article.
- llamataboot 6y agoI find Varoufakis to be dead-on in his critique, but would often like more focus on many possible post-capitalisms. The failures of ΣΥΡΙΖΑ were many, and it is easy to simply call them hopelessly naive (from one side) or abject sellouts (from the other) - and there is no doubt Greece was in a hole partially (only partially) of its own making with no good way forward. And yes, he has a bit of "I'm the most important rockstar in the room energy" but so do a bunch of VCs and founders. The idea of moving towards market socialism with universal income and using central banking as a mechanism to reduce inequality is new-ish. There are many threads in his writings that are not about anti-capitalism, nor a return to previous types of socialisms, but of how to harness market forces to continue to generate progress while reducing their massively negative externalities. In any case, his ideas are worth more discussion than his personality.
- cblconfederate 6y agoYeah it s kind of weird, but even your own comment focuses on his personality. In reality, the article is empty of something to discuss about. It's longish, yet, where's the argument? please enlighten. The structure is, a litany of random facts interspersed with generous self-promotion. But you may be right, the fact that i couldn't pay my servers when he shut down the banks might have something to do with it. To put things in perspective, imagine if Elizabeth Holmes was writing in the Guardian about the tyrrany of Big Pharma.
- calcifer 6y ago> It's longish, yet, where's the argument? please enlighten. I'm sorry but this really comes off as trolling. It's right there in the article. Everything after Suppose we had seized the 2008 moment... describes an alternative system that doesn't sound bad at all.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cblconfederate 6y ago
- Synaesthesia 6y agoI think some form of democratic socialism is clearly the way forward. We can see what has happened in the unregulated capitalist countries like USA and UK. Poverty levels are way higher than they should be, very poor response to Covid, just insane levels of wealth inequality.
- ameetgaitonde 6y agoMy problem with his solution is that it lacks two key components of an implementable design, better incentives and a competitive advantage. As a result, you'd seemingly need an authoritarian government to force these types of changes, which has the potential to cause greater harm than the problem it's fixing. Incentives - While such a system seems better for workers, it doesn't show any benefit for entrepreneurs or investors. Why would anyone start such a business if they lose control almost immediately? What is the incentive for investment if it doesn't come with the potential for a return? Competitive Advantage - The reason you'd need an authoritarian government is because anyone using a traditional ownership model would have an advantage against these types of companies. As we've seen in cooperatives, one-person-one-vote creates freerider and horizon problems, and the pressure to form smaller firms would eliminate the economies of scale that many firms today enjoy. This feels more like a political solution, and seems liable to succumb to predictable economic behaviors.
- cblconfederate 6y agoIndeed there s no self-reflection on the viability of the supposed "plan". Yet again, this is the same guy who was supposedly planning to counter the ECB's demands by setting up a guerilla currency through blockchains and I-owe-Us.
- calcifer 6y ago> Indeed there s no self-reflection on the viability of the supposed "plan". Perhaps the viability is examined in the book, which is mentioned within the article title? > Yet again, this is the same guy who was supposedly planning to counter the ECB's demands by setting up a guerilla currency through blockchains and I-owe-Us. "Supposedly" as in conspiracy theories backed by thin air?
- cblconfederate 6y agooh no, it's what he claimed to be doing. I don't believe he could pull it through of course, but he himself claims he came up with that crazy plan . https://www.keeptalkinggreece.com/2016/01/20/varoufakis-reveals-plan-x-parallel-currency-in-case-greece-would-have-been-kicked-out-of-the-eurozone/ https://www.keeptalkinggreece.com/2016/01/20/varoufakis-reve... https://news.yahoo.com/varoufakis-parallel-currency-ploy-sparks-uproar-greece-140830211.html https://news.yahoo.com/varoufakis-parallel-currency-ploy-spa...