5 ms·
I doubt that's true. It's a minor side thing of a project, it's easily explained as done this way because it's the easiest, it's unclear it actually makes adblo
by detaro 6y ago
I doubt that's true. It's a minor side thing of a project, it's easily explained as done this way because it's the easiest, it's unclear it actually makes adblocking that much harder. It seems unlikely that this is a targeted strategy, companies that size generally suck at that.
- rektide 6y agothe whole screen is a big giant canvas. I don't necessarily think it was a diberate decision, but Fluttercs CanvasKit is one of the most pernicious evil backwards awful things anyone has done to the web and it absolutely will make ads much much much harder to block. It uses the web like a vnc session to the app. It is an absolutely sickening perversion of the web & oh it so happens such ads will be unblockable, there'll be no imgs nor divs nor anything else to block, just one massive canvas pushing pixels at you. Gobsmackingly horrible regression for the web, & I am so so so glad someone did a proper job writing up this horrorshow.
- detaro 6y agoOh, fully agreed that it's a terrible idea on many levels that should be reserved for very niche scenarios(I don't think it's totally useless, and would be curious how well it can be expanded to add accessibility features if the developer cooperates). I just think negligence/ignorance/bad priorities are more likely explanations. (another technical argument: today you seldom see ads being served from the app domain, despite it being not that difficult and an easy way around domain blocks, because the ad industry doesn't trust that model - so even if the rendering is obfuscated, at least for now ads from Google would still be fetched through stoppable network requests for anti-fraud reasons)
- darepublic 6y agoI've heard it suggested that you can build an application fully in canvas but also leave behind a semantic and accessible skeleton for screen readers and crawlers
- rektide 6y agoThe two are not two different worlds. Screen-readers might be able to function off a semantic skeleton. But, as the author mentions, tools like Vimium are just going to be forever screwed over, totally shot the hell out of the water, by this post-hypertext abomination. CanvasKit!!!!!!!!!!
- yoavm 6y agoSorry if I wasn't clear - I'm not saying someone sat at a meeting titled "how to stop uBlock Origin" and it ended with Flutter. But I do think the overall approach of Google is let's make the internet more of a controlled experience, and Flutter fits perfectly in that approach.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoNah, Flutter Web clearly grew out of Flutter for smartphones. If the dream is write-once run-anywhere, extending to web is just the obvious next step.
- aUserRightNow 6y agoDid you read the parent comment ? > Nah, Flutter Web clearly grew out of Flutter for smartphones. If the dream is write-once run-anywhere, extending to web is just the obvious next step. Ok. > Sorry if I wasn't clear ... I do think the overall approach of Google is let's make the internet more of a controlled experience, and Flutter fits perfectly in that approach.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoOf course, and suggesting that Google has an “overall approach” and that Flutter for Web is some nefarious manifestation if it is ridiculous.