9 ms·
It honestly worries me that this is the top comment on hacker news. Not because it is wrong (it isn't) but because of all places that website filled with tech w
by godelski 6y ago
It honestly worries me that this is the top comment on hacker news. Not because it is wrong (it isn't) but because of all places that website filled with tech workers and experts in the full software stack, full of people that work on and exploit meta data, it still needs to be discussed how important metadata is.
If we can't convince people with their ear to the ground, how does one convince the general public. Especially since it isn't intuitive how metadata is useful. Though the analogy I typically use is a private investigator following you around. Can't hear your conversations, but can see everyone you talk to, where, and for how long.
- rosywoozlechan 6y ago> If we can't convince people with their ear to the ground, how does one convince the general public. Convince them of what? Some of us don't believe the NSA are bad actors and and possibly we also believe they're doing their jobs and support them in that.
- lostcolony 6y ago"The NSA" - who do you mean here? The org in its official function doing unofficial things without oversight? Or the individual working for the NSA spying on his ex-lover for blackmail material? I mean, either you're saying "no one within the NSA has ever been a bad actor", or you're saying "the bad actions are acceptable collateral damage; no oversight needs to be applied to ensure the trade off between effectiveness and collateral damage is balanced", or you're saying "not ALL actors are bad" and leaving it at that. And...none of those strikes me as a particular defensible position to take.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Shared404 6y agoYou're one of the people this [0] comment is talking about. Also, how can you possibly believe that the NSA are not bad actors? Between trying to hobble encryption, spying on everything, and enabling bad individual actions, and having a horrible success rate [1], what is left to defend? [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24962802 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24962802 [1] https://www.newamerica.org/international-security/policy-papers/do-nsas-bulk-surveillance-programs-stop-terrorists/ https://www.newamerica.org/international-security/policy-pap...
- rosywoozlechan 6y agoNSA's competence or success rate doesn't invalidate the need for such an organization. Individuals part of the organization that behave badly don't either. Other states have organizations like the NSA and in order for the USA to defend itself from them the USA also needs one. We don't question the need for a military because one lieutenant burns down a Vietnamese village, we demand justice and changes, but we continue to support the need for a military. That's my thought around the NSA. I support private companies protecting their customers by utilizing encryption and I support the NSA to do whatever they can to amass all the information they can when private companies fail. Why? Because our enemies are doing the same thing. A moral position that loses doesn't last, and for sure there are some moral positions I would stand by them even if it meant losing, but this one isn't one of them. Not for me anyway.
- arminiusreturns 6y agoThis comment doesn't stand up to any kind of scrutiny whatsoever. One, handwaving institutional corrupt and violation of the constitution by claiming it's only a few "bad actors" ignores how high up that corruption emenates from. Two, it assumes that the violations are needed for national security, a claim which can easily be dissected by understanding what William Binney has told us about thinthread, just as an singular example in a vast sea of examples. Three, it's a strawman to jump to arguing that because other countries are doing this, we need the NSA too. Very few people are actually calling for the dismembership of the NSA, and in general want accountability and a return to constitutional surveillance. Four, implying the constitution is a "moral position that loses" is absolutely a machievellian, realpolitik, ends-justify-the-means policy position that we and the world have suffered enough consequences and blowback of. Your entire argument revolves around using the safety as justification for violations of their mandate and oaths, when all the evidence points towards the truth being quite the opposite: the surveillance program has failed to be effective for safety, and not only that, that failure is largely due to this very kind of thinking in the first place! By being willing to undermine the constitution the NSA (et al intel agencies) inherently reduce long term security and safety in the US by allowing bad actors in all kinds of sectors the ability to abuse the data they get. The totalitarian surveillance system is about control, not safety, always remember that! "Go again and see not just the film and the play but read the text of Robert Bolt's wonderful play "Man For All Seasons", some of you must have seen it - where Sir Thomas Moore decides that he would rather die than lie or betray his faith and at one moment Moore is arguing with a particularly vicious witch-hunting prosecutor (a servant of the king and a hungry and ambitious man), and Moore says to this man "You'd break the law to punish the Devil, wouldn't you?" And the prosecutor, the witch hunter, says "Break it?" He said "I'd cut down every law in England if I could do that, if I could capture him." And Moore says "Yes you would wouldn't you? And then when you corner the Devil and the Devil turned round to meet you, where would you run for protection? All the laws of England having been cut down and flattened, who would protect you then?" - Christopher Hitchens
- cookiengineer 6y agoWhat most people don't understand is that a targeted IP, with a stream size and a timestamp is enough to identify pretty every https page uniquely if it is accessible by a spider. A headless chrome makes measurements of timings even easier these days. The order of how files are loaded, which file size e.g. jquery.123.min.js has, and where and when exactly in which order it is loaded from is very unique among all pages of a website.
- parliament32 6y ago>stream size and a timestamp I think that's more complicated than you realize. That list would be impossibly large to scrape and search, not to mention collisions and dynamic content problems. >The order of how files are loaded It's a good idea, but you don't know what files I have in my cache and when they expire, or what files my extensions are blocking. This'd only work in an ideal-case scenario.
- pessimizer 6y agoThe people who visit this website are the people who are paid to create and administer all of this technology. They're not only the last people you would be able to convince of something that would affect their livelihoods, but even the ones who do understand feel like it is part of their duty to deceive the less technically adept about the capabilities and dangers of the technology that they're surrounded with. The comfortable upper middle-class are the most conservative elements of any society; they're providing the management and expertise to implement any dystopia that's coming. Beneath them are the tradespeople and unskilled laborers who choose between working or starving, and above them are morons. Nobody who has spent more than a moment thinking about it fails to understand the dangers of metadata, they just don't think they it will be a problem for them. Hence the most common response is something about how their lives are boring, and how they have nothing to to hide. "Who cares if I'm at Starbucks at 2 o'clock?" Technologists know full well what they could do with that information, that's what they're paid to know, and they're who are going to be doing it, or they're going to have to find another job.
- charlchi 6y ago> The people who visit this website are the people who are paid to create and administer all of this technology. Exactly, some falsely assume all technologists somehow share an enthusiasm for morality. Many of the most successful technologists I know simply work for the highest pay from military/intelligence contracts.
- arminiusreturns 6y agoThe term "hacker" in "hacker news" is too misleading, especially those of us who use the more RMS-esque definition of it. Petition to change to something more appropos.
- kimjongtrill 6y agoLol petition to stop naming anything because eventually all labels become bad. /s
- frobozz 6y agoAn analogy I like is that they know you called a suicide hotline from a tall bridge in the middle of the night, but they don't know what you discussed.
- futureproofd 6y agoI believe I read the same example in 2600 quarterly some years back, in which the metadata was described and scrutinized in greater detail. It was impactful enough at that time for me to recall even today.
- seppin 6y agoMetadata is data.
- HNsFault00 6y agoBlame VCs (hi Ycom) When the time series data of conversations is MRR, gains, and ephemeral frameworks of the week 90% of the time, and 10% “same old physics” what do you expect from a bunch of humans still recovering from black & white “forever good life!” thinking? Tell the cohorts titillating people with fairy tales to bug off a bit, humanity. Or do like the Romans and watch it all die Only this time it could be the entire species
- arthurcolle 6y agowhat are you talking about?
- endgame 6y agoIn the lead-up to Australia's metadata retention legislation, some org posted the following examples. I found them reasonably effective at convincing normal people, but we failed to convince the decision-makers in Parliament: - "What if your call logs indicated a 45-minute call to a suicide hotline made from a bridge. Do they need to hear exactly what was said?" - "What if your call logs showed you receiving a call from a sexual health clinic, and that you then called a bunch of people in rapid succession. Do they need to hear exactly what was said?"
- friendlybus 6y agoI think the lynchpin is not knowing. We don't know what all the data is used for or why it's taken. As long as we don't know we lack the ability to judge. We don't have the power to make a strong rhetorical argument without shared knowledge. Colbert's white house correspondent's address covered it. Politicians don't talk about super depressing stuff like guantonomo bay and journalists have the courtesy to not try and find out.. We don't talk about data collection in any serious manner. I think the weakness of data collection is when it gets in the average joe's way and it hasn't done that yet in a big way. The more we hammer home that it must facilitate movement through life and not hinder it, the better the middle ground will be.. maybe. There is a requirement that both sides get really good at eviscerating lies and liars. Neither side of the fence wants fake data or betrayal.
- tester34 6y agoWell, HN doesnt seem to be security oriented community. But it's ok, security isn't as important as algos are during FAANG interviews, so who cares.
- rolandog 6y agoIt's sometimes useful to say a different thing when explaining to someone that doesn't understand. For me, the importance of metadata can be conveyed by comparing its usefulness to knowing the answers to the game of 20 Questions.