5 ms·
Once liberalism collapses, there isn't much of a choice between the two. If you accept the premise that liberalism has failed and that re-establishing it is imp
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Once liberalism collapses, there isn't much of a choice between the two. If you accept the premise that liberalism has failed and that re-establishing it is impossible, then as a bourgeois you have two choices.
Either you do accept the socialization of your property, and live the life of an ordinary person, which is morally by far the best thing to do, or:
In an attempt to maintain your capital, you decide that you'd rather see fascism with you in a privileged position.
As far as anyone is concerned, if you decide that fascism is good for you because it helps you maintain your privilege, you are a fascist.
No one has ever said that all bourgeois are hidden fascists, but history tells us that, when (if) liberalism collapses, most bourgeois follow their class interests and support fascism, instead of trying to maintain liberalism and becoming neutral when that fails.
Why is this? Because the issues that historically led to the collapse of liberalism can always be linked back to economic issues. Therefore, trying to install a system that provides democracy, peace, and equality for all if/when liberalism collapses will necessarily require the revision of the economics that led to such an issue. This is why, in this event, there really isn't much of an alternative between severely limiting the private ownership of capital and fascism.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"If you accept the premise that liberalism has failed and that re-establishing it is impossible ... Either you do accept the socialization of your property, and live the life of an ordinary person, which is morally by far the best thing to do" Life is seldom made of binary choices like you imply. And what you think is "morally by far the best thing to do" really does not have to match others morals. My morals are, I do not judge absolute morals, like you. I judge only concrete situations. And since so far a egalitarian society is only a theory that failed multiple times in reality, I do not believe in supporting such a theory with all my energy and posession. Which would be "accept the socialization of your property, and live the life of an ordinary person, which is morally by far the best thing to do". In other words, if I would have to take the choice between fascism and socialism I would rather try to gather what I have and go away.
- sudosysgen 6y ago>Life is seldom made of binary choices like you imply. And what you think is "morally by far the best thing to do" really does not have to match others morals. If there is another choice, then none of what I said applies. That being said, history has been such that there often has been no such other choice. >My morals are, I do not judge absolute morals, like you. I judge only concrete situations. If your morals are such that you would prefer fascism to any kind of socialism, then I do judge, and I think most do. If they aren't such, then the rest of my comment applies. >And since so far a egalitarian society is only a theory that failed multiple times in reality, I do not believe in supporting such a theory with all my energy and posession. Which would be "accept the socialization of your property, and live the life of an ordinary person, which is morally by far the best thing to do". No one, not even Karl Marx believed in an egalitarian society. What socialists do believe is that private property is an issue that will inevitably lead to the fall of liberalism, and that it must be heavily reformed, along with the removal of the class system. All socialist societies had some inequality in them, and no one complained about it, because everyone can agree that those more capable or who work harder should receive more. >In other words, if I would have to take the choice between fascism and socialism I would rather try to gather what I have and go away. That is an understandable choice, and I don't think anyone would object. Of course, getting your capital and other kinds of private property would be much harder as the fascists would certainly not let you do so.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"If your morals are such that you would prefer fascism to any kind of socialism" Ok, so if you would have the choice between Pol Pots socialism and Franco's Fascicm. You would choose Pol Pot? "No one, not even Karl Marx believed in an egalitarian society. " Then you have not met many socialists. I did and many of them do in fact believe in a literal egalitarian society. And it is news to me, that Marx did not.(but I read not much of Marx) Sources? "Of course, getting your capital and other kinds of private property would be much harder as the fascists would certainly not let you do so. " And about that: I am pretty much aware of what fascists do. Which is why I was involved in antifascist actions of different kind. I was just trying to get you socialists see a different point of view. That the view "for the people or against it" is not really a helpful one for most other people, who do not believe in fixed classes of people.
- fallingfrog 6y agoThis is such a great point, and distills a lot of complexity down to a few sentences.
- birdsbirdsbirds 6y agoWhen we look at Facebook and other social networks, isn't it a settled issue that moderators are needed? Who moderates in a socialised society? From the point of view of a bourgeois, fascism can also be a service to society because socialism is a future that will lead to chaos - not only to the collapse of liberalism but the collapse of civilization.
- hutzlibu 6y agoWell, when you ask me, no, it is not a settled issue that moderators are needed. But that is a big side-topic. "Who moderates in a socialised society?" And you probably mean a theoretic anarchistic society with no authority? Because in implemented socialist societies, there was plenty of moderation going on.
- birdsbirdsbirds 6y agoAnarchistic society is one thing, but 'Animal Farm' another. If socialism means re-establishing the same structures with different names, why should a bourgeois person with good intentions give up their privileges with which they can do something for the greater good?
- sudosysgen 6y agoWho moderates in a socialized society? In so far as law enforcement and general government is needed, exactly the same as in liberal society, you vote for people to form a government and do so. No one seriously believes that socialism would lead to a collapse of civilization, and no one seriously believes that fascism will lead to anything but death and despair for anyone that isn't highly privileged. What it would lead, is for a collapse of your privilege as a bourgeois, and all the rest is rationalization in order to make yourself feel better about contributing to the death of (hundreds of, in the case of what the NSDAP wanted) millions so that you can conserver your privilege.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> No one seriously believes that socialism would lead to a collapse of civilization I think lots of people who believe in capitalist ideology (probably not most of the visible preachers of that ideology, who have narrower self-interested motives, but many of the true believers) do indeed believe that. I think they are wrong, but I don't think dismissing their honest if grossly misguided belief is helpful.
- jariel 6y agoThis is painful to read in 2020. There is no such thing as 'socialization of your property' - this concept exists only as intellectual fantasies. There is only confiscating by a new, probably more ruthless and murderous regime. We have entire century and a several dozen national experiment to debunk this rubbish, we know what the outcomes really are; 'Socialism' is literally the 'collapse of liberalism', we can see some of that right now with orthodox impugnment of our academic systems by certain groups to the point wherein literally the more traditional Liberals have had to come out and take full page ads in major newspapers to plead their cause for rationality and reason.
- sudosysgen 6y agoHave you actually read the book we are talking about? In the real world, the CNT/FAI did not take ownership of the private property, it put it under the property of those that used said property. In any case, the collapse of liberalism is inevitable. Liberalism requires capitalism which requires infinite sustained growth. Infinite growth cannot be sustained, therefore eventually capitalism will collapse. There are, of course, a dozen other ways in which liberal capitalism is an unstable system which must collapse, and most of those reasons can be eventually boiled down to misalignment of the incentives of those with economic and political power, and of the rest of us. So any durable alternative will inevitably have to bridge this divide, and this will mean going after the class system. When that happens, you have a few alternatives that open up. I'd rather not go for a death cult. By the way, the reason why academia is full of socialists is not because of some perversion, or subversion, or anything of the sort, it is because the first people to ever apply the scientific method to the analysis of society came to the conclusion that liberal capitalism is incredibly problematic and that it is existential that it should be changed (on historic timescales). Indeed, you can Google the "fathers of social science" and you might be surprised on the political views of those three.