3 ms·
>in the USSR, other leftists were acting as tyrants. Russia had two revolutions back-to-back in 1917, only 8 months between them. First was fighting tyrants,
by nabla9 6y ago
>in the USSR, other leftists were acting as tyrants.
Russia had two revolutions back-to-back in 1917, only 8 months between them. First was fighting tyrants, second was becoming tyrant.
First there was February Revolution that overthrew autocracy and provisional government and Russian Republic were formed. Bolsheviks had <24% of the votes and seats. moderate socialists, national parties, cadets had the rest.
Then there was October Revolution aka Bolshevik Coup where faction of communists led by Lenin and Bogdanov took over, killed everyone other kind of socialist and supporter of provisional government and formed autocracy.
Both the The French Revolution and the Russian revolution are examples of "Revolutions devour their own Children". I think the lesson is that when you fight dictators, you must have a plan for after, and watch the most radical factions. Mensheviks and social democrats were discussing elections and worker assemblies wile Lenin and others were planning to kill them.
- toyg 6y agoYou can see examples of this dynamic even in modern times. The Iranian Revolution: started as democratic revolution, ended into religious autocracy. "Arab Spring" Egypt: started as democratic revolution, moved towards religious autocracy, ended in military dictatorship. These are the most obvious ones, but there are loads more (Lybia pre-Gaddafi, Zimbabwe...).
- kazen44 6y ago> Russia had two revolutions back-to-back in 1917, only 8 months between them. First was fighting tyrants, second was becoming tyrant. both revolutions where just the start of the russian civil war, which lasted for another 5 years and is on of the bloodiest wars in human history.
- Tuna-Fish 6y agoTo put it in less words: Revolutions are not won by the side who is morally right. They are won by the side who are most effective at fighting, and who are the most ruthless. And almost no revolutions have ever had just two sides. This is the main argument for incrementalism in my view. I see a lot of people arguing for radical change, and no matter how much I might agree with their values and how pure their intentions are, I cannot help but note that I do not think they would end up as the winners of any revolution.
- DFHippie 6y ago> I cannot help but note that I do not think they would end up as the winners of any revolution. This. In our current fascist versus antifa moment I hear leftists scorn anyone who wants less than a revolution. I ask them "Who hoards the guns and is really, really eager to use them?"