4 ms·
When I first started reading HN I learned a TON very quickly and everyday about completely new stuff, and was able to do so because I could easily sort through
by tokenadult 16y ago
When I first started reading HN I learned a TON very quickly and everyday about completely new stuff, and was able to do so because I could easily sort through the legitimacy of opinions based on their upvotes.
And yet the founder of HN said 25 days ago that there is a problem with HN, "the decreasing quality of comment threads on HN."
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403696 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403696
He summed up the problem by saying "The problem has several components: comments that are (a) mean and/or (b) dumb that (c) get massively upvoted." If pg observed a situation like that, isn't it a bad idea to "sort through the legitimacy of opinions based on their upvotes"?
A link and comment in another recent metadiscussion thread largely sums up the back-and-forth about visible comment scores as a signal on comments in active threads:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2465357 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2465357
>> Please bring back the comment scores. It helps a lot in parsing the comments and assigning a proportional weight to each when reading them.
> I had to think about this a bit, and I disagree so far. I'm finding that I'm not pre-judging comments as much. It's nice to be able to read someone's comment without knowing first that 70 or 80 or 3 other people thought it was worthwhile.
Once I had thought about that a bit, I reached the second conclusion. Readers on HN are gaining more quality comments as readers look at comments according to their inherent value and not upvoting or downvoting based on the crowd appeal of what someone else has already voted. Cognitive scientists have done a lot of research on what is called anchoring bias,
http://www.sciencedaily.com/articles/a/anchoring.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/articles/a/anchoring.htm
and I get the impression, after 892 days as a registered user of HN, that comment upvotes and downvotes for the last year or so have not been based on the same careful consideration of comment quality as they were in the early days of HN, but rather have been based too much on what net karma score is already displayed as people vote. I like the new comment score system of not displaying net comment scores on OTHER people's posts (of course I can still see my own comment scores) better than the previous system. In the spirit of pg's statement, I try to help the quality of HN by actively upvoting thoughtful, helpful comments, and being on the lookout for mean comments (which pg hopes will not be upvoted by anyone) and dumb comments (which surely don't help any users relying on comment scores to learn new facts) for downvoting those. A comment that is both mean and dumb ought to be downvoted, not upvoted. We can all do our part to help the quality of the community.
In his thread, pg mentioned comments that are mean or dumb "that (c) get massively upvoted." With that condition of HN less than a month ago in mind, how do the highest-voted comments visible in the bestcomments list
http://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments http://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments
look to all of you recently? Are there fewer mean comments than before? Are there fewer dumb comments than before? Are the comments that are "massively upvoted" since the experiment began mostly comments that are reasonably kind and well-informed, helpful comments on the whole? In most of the treads you visit, do helpful, thoughtful comments seem to rise to a position of prominence, while mean or dumb comments gray out?
Remember, pg's claim is that recently HN has not been a place where there is an "easy way for readers to differentiate the noise," but rather a place where the noise has had an attached badge of being signal rather than noise. That isn't good for anyone reading HN. As you correctly point out, we STILL have "the location on the page," which is useful at least for comparing multiple comments at the same reply level as a comment thread develops, and the actual sources and reasoning used by one or another user in supporting points made in comments. People who LOOK UP what the facts are can find out a lot about who is taking care to do good research and who is just making stuff up. And that's always the safest path to learning, to check the sources to verify other people's factual claims.
- wdewind 16y agoTo be totally honest with you I haven't noticed much of a change in the overall thread quality at all, except that I feel like I'm missing half the picture. The community has definitely felt some growing pains, but it is absolutely not clear that hiding comment scores has helped. Looking at the best comments page, no I don't think it looks particularly better (or worse) than it did a few months ago. On that best comments page, look at how many of them are on threads (including this one) asking to bring scores back. When pg put it to a vote, more people wanted to see them than not. Since the community was the backbone and validity of the voting system, by taking away the visibility voting system we are taking away quite a bit of faith in the community. If we don't think the voting system is valuable for viewable scores, why is it valuable for sorting the threads? Adding to the fact that a significant majority wanted them shown, it doesn't really seem like we've got a lot of faith in the community as a whole. And if we don't have faith in the community, doesn't that mean HN is kind of dead and we just don't know it yet? I don't think it is, and I think the upvote system is imperfect but worked much better than nothing. And maybe exact scores aren't what we need, but just sorting the comments isn't enough.
- zoul 16y agoWithout the score being displayed I simply can't go through the hundreds of comments that get displayed on HN every day. It would be perfect if I could, but I don't have the time and wonder who has. Yes, displaying the votes supports groupthink, but it's better than the current solution, which is throwing out the baby with the bath water.
- vacri 16y agoYou're missing that even if both popular + insightful get upvoted, you can still use this as a prefilter, look at the high upvote counts, and dismiss that which is mean. It's how I used the system. Right now we just get pages an pages of text with little in the way of friendly direction if you don't have time to examine all the commentry.
- hallmark 16y agoI feel compelled to respond to one particular point: Yes, you can LOOK UP facts for yourself rather than rely on the vote count of a comment. But honestly, the expansive tome of information that is HN is not just a series of threaded facts. There is a vast amount of advice, warnings, interpretations, and arguments based on deep experiences and personal trials that are not subject to a simple Google search. We hold up individual critical thinking to such high esteem that we seem to dismiss the value in the collected opinions of others.