4 ms·
> The politics behind promoting Hindi is a religious one. It makes convenient to promote the varna system(modern caste system). As someone with some knowledge
by quadrifoliate 6y ago
> The politics behind promoting Hindi is a religious one. It makes convenient to promote the varna system(modern caste system).
As someone with some knowledge around this subject, this is a simplistic and inflammatory bad-faith reading of a very complex topic – how do you create a common country out of hundreds of splintered cultures, languages, and religions spoken by millions of people? The nearest parallel to how many languages India is the European Union, and I would wager that given the differing scripts and such, India's diversity of languages exceeds that of the EU's.
And people have been trying to unite this complex mixture as a country since the 1700s! (thinking of the British attempts here; much earlier if you include pre-British empires).
The imposition of Hindi has been the one of the (failed) ways to have such a common language. It is quite a vast topic, but one example is that Mahatma Gandhi himself started the South India Hindi Outreach Institute to promote Hindi as a means of integration between (broadly speaking) North and South India.
Also, the issue of caste in India is a pretty complex one as well, but having spent some time in south India, I can confidently say that casteism is way more prevalent there than Hindi, which casts some doubts on the effectiveness of the politics you allude to (even presuming it exists).
----------------------------------------------------
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dakshina_Bharat_Hindi_Prachar_Sabha https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dakshina_Bharat_Hindi_Prachar_...
- naruvimama 6y agoNo discussion of India is complete without dragging caste into it, just like no discussion of Germany is complete without the holocaust. However, unlike the holocaust "Caste" and the "Caste system" originates in Europe. It is time that the textbooks are updated to reflect reality and not carry on a colonial-evalangical propaganda.
- saagarjha 6y agoNot every discussion of Germany needs to bring up the Holocaust, just like not every discussion of India needs to mention caste.
- naruvimama 6y agoIt was a joke, because every thread on hn about India, has a motivated group bringing out caste. Just like every Hollywood movie involving Germany, has to have a hitler reference.
- known 6y agoCaste matters everywhere: schools, jobs or life at large https://www.livemint.com/Opinion/wquRqpqgRGfDP58kN9BNOM/caste-matters-everywhere-schools-jobs-orq-at-large.html https://www.livemint.com/Opinion/wquRqpqgRGfDP58kN9BNOM/cast...