2 ms·
I am quite convinced Popper would have disagreed that the line doesn't needs to be drawn (in some cases) before violence — at least this is what I learned about
by atoav 6y ago
I am quite convinced Popper would have disagreed that the line doesn't needs to be drawn (in some cases) before violence — at least this is what I learned about him when I studied philosophy in Vienna, the city where he grew up in.
Popper e.g. also says that the goal of elections is to have a transfer of power without having to have civil wars, guillotines and other violent means. This means to prevent violence we have to maintain certain rules.
This doesn't mean however, that we have to wait till bad actors in fact act violently, after e.g. having stated they want to abolish these rules, after threatening violence, after breaking present rules and stretching present conventions etc. This means that he didn't want to suppress intolerant views (IF they can be hold in balance with rational arguments and public discourse) — instead he would plead to limit their effects on society (thus reducing potential future violence).
But it has been over a decade since I read Popper, so maybe you read something I didn't.
- tupputuppu 6y agoPopper's idea was that people need to be free to discuss and debate different perspectives. When most people don't feel free to voice their opinions I think it's safe to say the culture and institutions we have don't support that goal.
- pas 6y agoThere's a difference between "not allowing racists/bigots to shout whatever insult they happen to come up with", and "banning research into biological underpinnings of cognition, intelligence, etc". Most people are not scholars, at best pundits, but even if they are, most of their thoughts are still not careful and nuanced constructive arguments. And maybe, just maybe, putting some brakes on the global cyber hate wave machines, where anyone can share/amplify the most damaging shit with one click is not a bad idea. That said, partisanship bias, fairness, justice are all related problems when it comes to how to apply those brakes. And yes, the institutions are shit, both old and new. Academia, FB/Tw, MSM, parties/congress, religions. But they are not without advantages, not unsalvageable.
- brigandish 6y agoI'm confused, who is saying that a line doesn't need to be drawn? The line already has been drawn, in law. SCOTUS has made the line clear and present danger[1]. That is, a threat made via speech has to be clear, credible and imminent else it is not considered a threat and hence not speech that may be interfered with legally, but if it is then it can be. It's distinctly possible you've read more Popper than I have but his words seem very clear here too[2]: > I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion He goes on to contrast that with those who give up on speech and respond with violence (and it's all within about a page). So we have a clear line and there's no need to wait for violence to actually occur before legal remedy can be sought, which would appear to me to fit with Popper's statement and what you studied. I completely agree with Popper on elections, and free speech fits the same mould, it's primary function is to reduce violence. Without free speech the options for those who wish to change society are only violent. With it there is no excuse for violence. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clear_and_present_danger https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clear_and_present_danger [2] https://archive.org/details/TheOpenSocietyAndItsEnemiesPopperKarlSir/page/n837/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/TheOpenSocietyAndItsEnemiesPoppe...