4 ms·
I also use Anki daily. Just off the top of my head: - The UI is an ugly light gray with too much text. I'd make the design far more minimal. - Too much of a f
by keiferski 6y ago
I also use Anki daily. Just off the top of my head:
- The UI is an ugly light gray with too much text. I'd make the design far more minimal.
- Too much of a focus on text. Video, audio and GIFs should be more integrated into cards, especially for stuff like foreign languages.
- Way too many options: note types, sort fields, tags, on and on. I've been using Anki for years and I don't even know what half of these things do.
- The entire process of adding cards is confusing and not immediately obvious. There's not even a tutorial.
- Premade decks have zero quality control and you have to go looking for them online.
- Above all, Anki just looks and feels like a chore. When I show it to people (like OP), the overwhelming reaction is always, "Meh." There's nothing exciting, beautiful or futuristic about it.
- kazinator 6y agoI use AnkiDroid on Android. The UI supports a dark mode. I can't imagine why anyone would want to use the original desktop Anki, which chains you to a PC or laptop. Though in the pre-mobile-computing era, such a program would have been attractive. This technique begs to be mobile, so you can do reviews in any occasion when you would be otherwise idly waiting for something, like standing in line somewhere. Buses, trains, planes, waiting rooms, washroom stalls ... You can micro-review. If you have just a few seconds to spare, you can whip out your phone and just do one review and put it away. That's one less to do later. I sometimes do AnkiDroid reviews lying down in bed, before sleeping. You can turn of screen rotation and work sideways. I've woken up in the middle of the night and completed the last few reviews of the day. That's possible from having the phone near the hand; no way would I get up, and sit at a desktop PC to do that, or even laptop. The desktop Anki is completely pointless except for (1) serving as the reference implementation and (2) certain complicated maintenance tasks on large decks.
- keiferski 6y agoI use Anki on desktop because it lets me type 1000x faster than on a phone. Hugely important for Cloze cards and language learning. It really isn't even a comparison...the mobile app is only useful if I'm on the go and have a minute to do some cards. An hour on the desktop version will let you do hundreds, even thousands of cards, while mobile is maybe a hundred, tops, assuming you want to stare at your phone that long.
- kazinator 6y agoThere isn't anything to type; just buttons to hit.
- keiferski 6y agoThat's an inefficient way to learn. Especially with foreign languages, where it's beneficial to type out the word or phrase.
- kazinator 6y agoOther than keyboarding/IME practice, there is no benefit to typing out a word or phrase compared to recalling the word or phrase and seeing that it matches exactly. If you see the right spelling in your mind and "hear" the word, you obviously know the word and could type it if required. (For languages with an ideographic writing system, there is a benefit to writing by hand, but that's a whole separate story.) It sounds as if your flashcards are in a format where the foreign word is the answer, or embedded in the answer via a cloze. That's not the only way Anki is used. If the flashcards are in a foreign-word -> definition format, the typing would have to be definition-side, to which there is little benefit. All the more obviously so for definitions that are in your native language. Definitions are too verbose to type out, and difficult to machine-grade due to variations in wording. I understand the efficiency benefit that keyboarding can bring, but it's not realized in Anki. I made a very good application for kanji memorization, where the keyboard is the key to efficiency. The reason is that in this program, all of the characters you are tested on appear on the same screen simultaneously. You type answers into blanks next to each character, and use Tab to move from one to the next. The machine grades your answers when you're done; you don't have to engage in time-wasting self-checking. This is extremely fast because you can operate in pipeline mode: your eyes scan ahead several characters while your fingers type without stopping. Also, if you're having trouble recalling, you can just leave the answer blank and then easily return to it before submitting the test for grading. Often, your mind will come up with the answer in the background, while you are filling other answers. The main source of inefficiency in Anki is the stop-and-go blocking: being shown one card at a time, and not being able to go to the next card until passing the current card. Anki is best used for the cards for which that is the most efficient approach: cards that have a simple front, and a complex back that requires self-evaluation. For cards that have a one or two word answer that can be machine-checked, I would find (or develop) something much more efficient than Anki.