3 ms·
Probably just the training data not including enough bald people...
by mc32 6y ago
Probably just the training data not including enough bald people...
- viraptor 6y agoI'm sure the training data also didn't include this person http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_XU9x8G7khv0/SklFgSPQOdI/AAAAAAAAGiE/o_-Q5LI3hnc/s400/ball-buzz.jpg http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_XU9x8G7khv0/SklFgSPQOdI/AAAAAAAAGi... And it's just bound to happen at some point.
- devmunchies 6y agoOr it misclassified the training data too and they didn’t catch it. It’s not like AI engineers manually run all varieties of footage against the trained model to check accuracy.
- raverbashing 6y agoThis is not about training data I think the ML specialists often forget there's a gap between pattern matching and solving a problem The problem here is: locating a ball and moving the camera If you just try to find a ball on static image by static image you're going to have a bad time. Even worse if you try to find only the ball but without the play contexts (kicking, flying, being held, etc) Balls "teleport" but not always Yes, a ball can be on top of a player, but not all the time So, no, if you didn't see the ball go there, it didn't suddenly appear in the middle of the field (but then again, with some exceptions).
- papaf 6y agoIf you just try to find a ball on static image by static image you're going to have a bad time. This isn't the point you were making, but as an aside, I think converting video into static images is throwing away useful information. Most video codecs work by encoding the changes between video frames which includes movement information. It seems hard, but worthwhile, to use this information for object recognition. I just did a search and saw that these techniques go by the name "compressed domain analysis" [1]. [1] https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=de&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=compressed+domain+analysis&btnG= https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=de&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=comp...
- pvaldes 6y agoCould have been much worse. Imagine the same camera falling in love with the white shirt of a exuberant woman in the public. Focusing and refocusing all the time. That would be glorious meme food. Go home camera, you are drunk. Can be solved adding a "too-sexy" list. The fake ball was always in the same part of the field. When the problem starts, a human should be allowed to enter a command ordering to ignore the area around coordinates X,Y of the grid. Putting a virtual black rectangle in the area only to be seen by the camera. Coordinates could be passed as arguments. When the real ball enter this area the camera of course will lost it, but will quickly relocate it at the other side so is not much of a problem.
- numpad0 6y agoI’d think the camera isn’t good enough than model being wrong. Dude really look like a ball on my phone screen, it’s only contextually clear to me that he’s not it. They’d need a more high resolution or higher frame rate camera.
- pvorb 6y agoThis context is what should be learnt by the AI.
- Someone 6y agoOr a system with some memory that knows how balls tend to move. This system, to me, looks like it works on individual video frames (the camera seems to move away whenever the ball is even half-covered by a player’s body, or hard to see looking against the sun). A smarter system would know the ball doesn’t move 20 meters in a single frame, and tends to move faster than other objects on the field. That may not trivial to implement, but, I expect, would lead to a much more robust system.
- dwd 6y agoWhen I hear "referee with bald head", I think Collina, who officiated World Cup, UEFA Cup and Champion's League finals. Their training data must have been seriously lacking.
- riffraff 6y agoHe's also still today Chairman of the FIFA referees committee. I literally cannot think of a more iconic referee. But in defence of the software: this was a sideline ref, so probably a different kind of behaviour from the main one.
- Shivetya 6y agojust pan it across the audience and see what it flags.