2 ms·
@sircmpwn Sort of implies [0] he'd need a contributor in order to fund a lawsuit (really puts his money where his mouth is on open source & privacy issues, at
by OJFord 6y ago
@sircmpwn Sort of implies [0] he'd need a contributor in order to fund a lawsuit (really puts his money where his mouth is on open source & privacy issues, at least, truly admirable) - but is that actually the case? Doesn't AGPL grant the user (casual observer even?) the right to view the source, not just the contributor to have it be available?
(Perhaps he just means that he's supportive but doesn't care enough to pursue it alone - absolutely fair enough if that's the case, not trying to suggest he should do something, just checking my understanding.)
[0] - https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecomment-720002351 https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom...
- csande17 6y agoThe AGPL says, roughly, that in order to be allowed to use the code you have to give all users the right to see the source. If they refuse to do this, the legal problem is that they're not allowed to use the code anymore -- in other words, they're violating the contributors' copyright. And to sue for copyright infringement, the plaintiff needs to be someone who holds the copyright. That's my non-lawyer understanding of why Drew needs a contributor to start a lawsuit.
- OJFord 6y agoI meant user of the (erroneously) proprietary version - aren't they supposed to receive/be enabled to access the source code for the original work and by extension the derivative (erroneously proprietary) work in their own right?
- saagarjha 6y agoI'm also a non-lawyer, but I believe Drew is mistaken in his claims that that he can get sue for the code. All he can do is sue for damages due to the infringement. (Your comment seems to be correct, FWIW.)