4 ms·
The committee thinks/thought that the Fraktur letters aren’t just a different way to write letters, but symbols with a different meaning, just as ℂ, ℕ, and ℝ ar
by Someone 6y ago
The committee thinks/thought that the Fraktur letters aren’t just a different way to write letters, but symbols with a different meaning, just as ℂ, ℕ, and ℝ aren’t a different way to write C, N and R.
(And yes, they included not only 𝔸𝔹ℂ𝔻𝔼𝔽𝔾ℍ𝕀𝕁𝕂𝕃𝕄ℕ𝕆ℙℚℝ𝕊𝕋𝕌𝕍𝕎𝕏𝕐ℤ, but also 𝕒𝕓𝕔𝕕𝕖𝕗𝕘𝕙𝕚𝕛𝕜𝕝𝕞𝕟𝕠𝕡𝕢𝕣𝕤𝕥𝕦𝕧𝕨𝕩𝕪𝕫 and 𝟘𝟙𝟚𝟛𝟜𝟝𝟞𝟟𝟠𝟡 in Unicode. In iOS Safari, using the font for entering HN comments, ℂℍℙℚ renders a bit taller and bolder for me. ℝ and ℤ render taller, but not bolder. Why beats me.)
I agree with them on ℂ, ℕ, and ℝ. I also think that makes it hard to disagree with them on the Fraktur letters.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoWhat bothers me is that for some reason only some latin letters and numbers are available as subscripts and superscripts...
- jml7c5 6y agoMost of the Latin subscript glyphs are from the Phonetic Extensions block. They only added those that were actually used in various phonetic notations. This Wikipedia page has a good list of why various ones were added, in addition to those from the Subscripts and Superscripts block: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unicode_subscripts_and_superscripts#Other_superscript_and_subscript_characters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unicode_subscripts_and_supersc...
- Kwpolska 6y ago> In iOS Safari, using the font for entering HN comments, ℂℍℙℚ renders a bit taller and bolder for me. ℝ and ℤ render taller, but not bolder. Why beats me. Font fallback. HN specifies Verdana, Geneva, sans-serif. Geneva has the six characters mentioned. The rest will be rendered using a different font that covers more parts of Unicode, or that covers Unicode math specifically. With the built-in system fonts, that would be Cambria Math on Windows and one of the STIX fonts on macOS. (Source: Firefox → Inspect Element → Fonts tab of the right Inspector pane. Chrome can do that too in a slightly different place, macOS Safari is too user-hostile to have this feature.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Someone 6y agoI guessed that, but still can’t figure out what makes ℂℍℙℚ special. Looking again, I notice ℕ is taller, too, but not bolder. ℂℍℕℙℚℝℤ is much more “I can see why a font would have these, but not others”. That solves the issue enough for me. (And, by the way, iOS doesn’t have Geneva, but it has a version of Verdana)
- dnautics 6y agoCHNPRQ and Z are the ones with actual canonical meaning: - Complex - Quaternion (H for Hamilton) - Natural - Prime - Rational (Q for quotient) - Real - Zinteger just kidding. i think Z stands for something in German.
- pvg 6y agoZ for Zahlen, "numbers". "Zinteger" is an improvement, being more precise.
- runarberg 6y agoI have also seen - ℙ used to denote a probability distribution - 𝔼[X] as the expected value of a random variable X - 𝟙_S as an indicator function for a set S (which is denoted as a subscript) - 𝕕 as the differential and integral operator denouncing which variable to integrate over 𝕕f/𝕕x f(x) or ∫ f(x) 𝕕x
- OscarCunningham 6y agoI've also seen 𝔸 for affine space, 𝔹 for the Booleans, 𝔽 for a field, 𝕂 for a field, 𝕆 for octonions and 𝕊 for surreals. I think I've seen 𝕀 and 𝕚 for identity matrices and suchlike, and I'm sure 𝟘 also gets some use.
- _ph_ 6y agoN are the positive integers including zero, Z are all integers.
- Lvl999Noob 6y agoIsn't N just the positive integers and W the one with zero?
- a1369209993 6y agoNo, the positive intergers are Z⁺ (Z^+ / Z<sup>+</sup>). N is natural numbers aka nonnegative integers aka positive integers along with (not "including", since it isn't positive) zero.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> The committee thinks/thought that the Fraktur letters aren’t just a different way to write letters, but symbols with a different meaning, just as ℂ, ℕ, and ℝ aren’t a different way to write C, N and R. As to the mathematical uses, this thought is correct. Niche, obviously, but Unicode has no trouble with niche characters. It's hard to justify the full alphabet on those lines, though.
- riffraff 6y agoIs it though? There's, imo, a reasonable expectation that if some of those characters were used then some other might be later, and it's easier to have them already in the standard than reserving space for them and then having to backfill it, I suppose.
- jjgreen 6y agoThese can result in crossness amongst mathematicians: everyone uses them on the blackboard (they are called blackboard-bold after all) but half use them in printed matter and the other half insist on actual bold. Discussions on the matter lead to cold stares and the poking of fingers in the chest.