3 ms·
I think it is you who missed a point, and don't have a sensible definition of "just" in "just a tool". It's "just" a tool because it is not good or bad by itse
by Brian_K_White 6y ago
I think it is you who missed a point, and don't have a sensible definition of "just" in "just a tool".
It's "just" a tool because it is not good or bad by itself, and does not even favor good or bad employment.
If you have a problem with a bad use of science, then you have a problem with a bad user of science.
By contrast, it's not like saying some deadly poison is "just a chemical" that might possibly have one or two possibly good uses but is otherwise entirely a bad thing that we could all live without if it were erased from the world.
Science is nothing but codified rationality.
There is no possible way to twist irrationality into being prefferable to rationality. And so there is no slightest trace of a valid argument that science is a problem that should be disfavored.
Yes it is in fact "just" a tool.
The human experience doesn't change this at all.
You don't need science to rationalize removing the top half of a chimpanzee skull. People who will do a thing, will do a thing with any tool. Science, religion, politics, "think of the children", plain might, anything.
- zdragnar 6y agoTo your point, most medicines, vitamins, minerals, and even water are life sustaining in some doses and toxic to fatal in other doses. Judging an abstract notion by specific incidents seems to me to be both profoundly human and profoundly wrong.