4 ms·
One argument for not getting excited just yet: This was not a blinded clinical trial. The subjects all knew whether they have COVID-19 or not and knowing how s
by krajzeg 6y ago
One argument for not getting excited just yet:
This was not a blinded clinical trial. The subjects all knew whether they have COVID-19 or not and knowing how strong psychological effects can be, what's detectable in their cough might be their knowledge they're sick. The researchers even acknowledge in the paper that "sentiment" is a big part of how a forced cough sounds.
What's worrying is also how little of the data was from a diagnostic test (over half of "positive" samples were "self-diagnosed" COVID-19, whatever that means).
I don't think FDA or any other regulatory body would accept such an app as a screening tool without a proper trial being done.
If it works, that would be the most practical and coolest application of ML I've seen - but it still feels like something from the "too good to be true" category at the moment.
- colechristensen 6y agoIt’s just junk science and the title is false. They used an ML model to detect if a person knows they have a diagnosis through a fake cough into a phone app. Even then their results could quite possibly just be overfitting, even with the verification data set separated.