8 ms·
I don't doubt this sort of discrimination happens, but is there some sort of data to suggest this is more than isolated? I'm not Indian but rather Bangladeshi (
by rayiner 6y ago
I don't doubt this sort of discrimination happens, but is there some sort of data to suggest this is more than isolated? I'm not Indian but rather Bangladeshi (the low-caste Indians who converted to Islam to get out of the caste system, lol). And I've met the occasional proud Brahmin, but in decades of living here I've never heard of caste discrimination being some sort of systemic thing. And yet I've seen like dozens of articles on this all of the sudden.
I'm not endorsing the idea of "isolated incidents" in general! But you can look at data to show that disparities in how certain groups are treated--e.g. employers being less willing to call back candidates with "Black" names on their resume. But extrapolating from the Cisco lawsuit to a narrative about a larger problem in Silicon Valley can have ugly consequences. It can be flipped around to broadly paint Indians who are in leadership positions in Silicon Valley in a bad light.
- _pmf_ 6y ago> is there some sort of data to suggest this is more than isolated prejudices Nobody seems to ask this question about the apparently rampant racism in the US.
- didibus 6y agoEven isolated prejudices can lead to systematic issues, so even if it was, it would be a problem. For example, if key individuals in certain positions hold the prejudices, it can have a systematic effect, since they have a lot of influence on the design of the systems in place and can easily create an unfair distribution of other people in charge/not in charge.
- crazygringo 6y ago> Nobody seems to ask this question about the apparently rampant racism in the US I can't tell if you're trolling or not, but in case you're not from the US and genuinely confused about this... there are mountains of data on systemic racism precisely because it's one of the biggest questions. Academic journals are full of answers, not to mention endless books.
- garyfirestorm 6y agoLol just look at number of people in tech who are black
- chanakya 6y agoI'm an upper caste male from India (now in Silicon Valley), so I suppose by the standards of discrimination discourse, I shouldn't be talking about this, but I will anyway. The evidence for this happening is poor. I have dozens of Indian friends who have been in the US for three decades, and they've never heard of it either. It could still be happening, of course, but the case for it would be more real if there was one actual case of a company or government censuring someone for it.
- objclxt 6y ago> it would be more real if there was one actual case of a company or government censuring someone for it. To be clear, this story got legs specifically because California is bringing a case against Cisco for caste-related discrimination. So the government is certainly trying to censure someone for it.
- chanakya 6y agoSure, but as far as I know, that is the only case of its kind in the country, and before we raise the alarm about widespread caste discrimination, shouldn't we have at least one case decided?
- Arnavion 6y agoThe only outcome of this is that non-Indians will now start seeing spooks where there are none. There are already a couple in this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24953219 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24953219 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24953346 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24953346 But what can you do.
- booi 6y agoIt feels like the fact that you even identify yourself as upper caste means you’re part of the problem
- garyfirestorm 6y ago
- anonunivgrad 6y agoWell to do minorities are a problem for the racism/discrimination freak out. They are similarly trying to discredit successful Hispanics and Asians.
- weakfish 6y agoAre you implying that we should not be "freaking out" over racism, as if segregation wasn't in my parent's lifetime?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mandliya 6y agoI have been in the US since 2012, never even once in all these years, I experienced or know some one who experienced this.I don’t think well-educated, middle class Indians who represent Indians in Silicon Valley will exhibit this behavior. Like the parent comment, not saying that this didn’t happen to people but it is definitely not a systematic thing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vmception 6y agoMartin Luther King didn’t have statistics, studies to lean on, any spreadsheet either, and yet is universally hailed as addressing a variety of issues. Although he was heavily criticized at the time. So we don’t really have a standard for perceiving an issue, only acknowledging an area ripe for abuse and aiming to mitigate it.
- handmodel 6y agoI think he did have data? There were literally laws that explicitly banned black people from using certain schools and facilities. So - there were a lot areas where he could say that black people are discriminated against with 100% certainty. I don't know enough about the issue in the article to determine how widespread it is - but I don't think it is fair to compare them.
- rayiner 6y agoMLK was speaking out against laws that were on the books, and economic conditions that were well studied and documented by the federal government.
- klempotres 6y agoSo is the caste system of India. It is in books, it is in public transportation, it is in job market, it is in kitchen, it is schools. To have formal statistics, you first need to acknowledge that the issue exists and then to investigate it. By the same token, the absence of the formal statistics does not disprove discrimination, quite the opposite, it proves that the systematic discrimination is not yet recognized as a problem. Which is systematic discrimination "by definition".
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoCaste discrimination is illegal in India.
- rayiner 6y agoBut we’re talking about California. For obvious reasons, I find it a bit problematic to accuse immigrants of bringing a negative cultural practice to the US with them without concrete data.
- nabla9 6y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/07/13/new-lawsuit-shines-light-caste-discrimination-us-around-world/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/07/13/new-lawsu... >In 2016, Equality Labs conducted the first survey on caste discrimination in the United States, helmed by Dr. Maari Zwick Maitreyi and myself. Surveying more than 1,500 respondents, we uncovered a problem that was much larger than we expected: One in four Dalits surveyed reported facing physical and verbal assault, one in three faced educational discrimination, and two in three workplace discrimination. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/58347d04bebafbb1e66df84c/t/5d9b4f9afbaef569c0a5c132/1570459664518/Caste_report_2018.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/58347d04bebafbb1e66df... https://www.equalitylabs.org/castesurvey/#key-findings https://www.equalitylabs.org/castesurvey/#key-findings
- rayiner 6y agoWow, thank you! I wish this data was in the article.
- radu_floricica 6y agoI worry a bit about this kind of surveys. By this standard, I've faced sexual assault because a drunken guy started petting me once (I'm a straight guy). By any reasonable standard it was a funny incident, but in a strict interpretation of a "have you ever" survey, I'd be a sexual assault survivor. Could be the same here. Say that in 1/100 of interactions between a upper and lower caste there is some form of discrimination, regardless the intensity. I'm too tired to do the math, but it seems reasonable that would lead to a high percentage of people ending up answering yes to a "have you ever been discriminated" question.
- chanakya 6y agoNot to speak of cases where there is an inaccurate perception of discrimination, perhaps because of a real family history of it happening in India.
- pfiwxruxta 6y agoRebuttal: https://medium.com/@rachelgotham5/a-rebuttal-to-equality-labs-caste-report-6535b883050 https://medium.com/@rachelgotham5/a-rebuttal-to-equality-lab...
- oh_sigh 6y agoNo reasonable person thinks that every powerful man was impugned by #MeToo, and no reasonable person would think that all powerful Indians are impugned by some kind of caste scandal.
- rayiner 6y agoIt’s different when you’re talking about a group (Indians) the broader public might not have much exposure to or understand very well to begin with.
- js2 6y agoI recently listened to an interview with Isabel Wilkerson, author of Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents which is about America, but she spent years doing research including visiting other countries. She tells an anecdote about visiting a conference in India on caste and even though the reason everyone was there was to discuss ways to undo the effects of the caste system, she was able to see effects of the system right there in the conference by how various participants interacted with each other. It was so ingrained to the participants that they didn’t realize they were doing it. It was small things like how one person would yield to another during conversation. Interesting listen. https://www.vox.com/2020/8/25/21399479/caste-the-warmth-of-other-suns-isabel-wilkerson-the-ezra-klein-show-race https://www.vox.com/2020/8/25/21399479/caste-the-warmth-of-o...
- vijaybritto 6y agoExactly!! Thanks for pointing this out. Caste is the way of life in the Indian society. Segregation and discrimination is so normalized that it needs an outsider to point that out.
- qart 6y agoIt is extremely isolated even in India itself. I have interviewed with about a hundred people so far. No one asked me my caste, and I never asked anyone theirs. Some north Indian names give away the caste from the last name. That's less likely to happen in southern India, where most of us don't even have a family name.
- pkphilip 6y agoThis is blatantly untrue. Caste discrimination is a harsh reality in India that millions of people face on a daily basis.
- qart 6y agoFor the millions in villages, yes. It is not common in cities. Are you Indian? How often do people ask you for your caste? And please don't tell me my own lived experience is "blatantly untrue".
- throwawayL0v3 6y agoHi, yes I am an Indian and its astounding to me that you as an Indian whose life, education, wealth, quality of life, access to healthcare, choice of life partner, friends, status in society, place of residence is all determined by your caste being completely oblivious to it. You have been so internalized into the caste system that you count only explicit and physically hurting ones as forms of discrimination. You are either incredibly privileged possibly a Brahmin or you're ignorant so much that you deny the suffering of more than a billion people as outright false!!
- pkphilip 6y agoIt is still very common in the cities. A survey from 2018 points to how prevalent it is in the urban regions - including in Delhi - even untouchability is practised in the cities. https://indianexpress.com/article/india/untouchability-high-in-urban-up-and-rajasthan-even-delhi-survey-5021282/ https://indianexpress.com/article/india/untouchability-high-...
- heelix 6y agoPerhaps a silly question - but what is considered a black name? I could not tell you if the resumes that end up at my stage are filtered or not.
- guan 6y agoIf you look at the last two pages of this classic paper (admittedly almost 20 years old now), you’ll see a list of some names they used in the field experiment. https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w9873/w9873.pdf https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w9873/w9873...
- vijaybritto 6y agoFirst of all caste is not invisible as you say. The discrimination starts from the names. Segregation based on caste is the way of life in India. I'm expecting may be its hard for a foreigner like you to notice but for the victims its very real and persistent everyday in their life!
- elboru 6y agoLegit question as a non Indian. Is there other ways to identify castes other than names? Probably accents? physiognomy? place of birth?
- throwawayL0v3 6y agoYes. Lots and lots. The easiest ones to identify is food preference. The upper castes ask you if you are a vegetarian. (Because they consider vegetarian = pure. Meat eaters are impure.) Also caste determines my job, education, wealth, where I live, where I pray, who I marry and many more. There are ways to find it from the ornaments and things, clothes you wear. It would be simply called 'tradition'. Caste segregation is the way of life here in India and there are so many different and easy ways to figure out another Indian's caste.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoYes. Easier to ask them. Honestly, I think the only way to legitimize the delegitimization of the caste system is for everyone to declare their castes. No shadow games. It’s all out in the open.
- Arnavion 6y agoHeck, when I moved to New Delhi, everyone thought I was Sikh because my last name is Singh, even though my last name is a common Hindu last name in general and not specific to Sikhs. So not even Indians are guaranteed to have the mapping of last name <-> demographic correct. (Speaking of, do all Sikhs count as Kshatriyas? Even the farmers in Punjab and Haryana? So confusing...)
- 6y ago
- fmajid 6y ago> the low-caste Indians who converted to Islam to get out of the caste system Sadly Muslims were not much better in this regard and created their own caste system of sorts, with descendants of foreign invaders given more status than descendants of local converts (Afghan good, Middle Eastern better), who were assumed to be low-caste fleeing oppression for that specific reason. I've heard the same from a Christian Indian from Mangalore. Perhaps that's why Dr. Ambedkar opted for Buddhism rather than Islam or Christianity as his recommended path forward for the Dalits (former untouchables).
- yowlingcat 6y ago> the low-caste Indians who converted to Islam to get out of the caste system, lol I know you're saying this in a bit of an off the cuff manner, but there is a lot more to the history of Bangladesh than you were letting on, and even in a joking manner it kinda contributes to this idea that Islam was this great emancipatory force in Bangladesh, which is...a bit reductionist. The idea that Bengal is historically a nation of low-caste Indians is 100% not the case. Bengal's distinct identity goes back to the Vedic period of 1500BC - 500BC. Its historic wealth predates Mughal era Bengal when Islam was introduced, and relates back to its historically rich breadbasket/river delta land and strategic placement as a thalossocracy very well placed along the maritime section of the Silk Road. Secondly, caste has always been somewhat complicated, and has a long history of systematically resistance in the Dharmic tradition in Bengal. That pertains to the historical development of Buddhism in the Maurya and Pala empires. To say it was "low-caste Indians" who converted to Islam to get out of the caste system that created the identity of "Bangladeshi" rather than competing ideological traditions (pro-Brahminical Old Vedic religion vs anti-Brahminical Buddhism) is really white-washing things. Islam's interaction with greater South Asian religion and philosophy was a lot more syncretic than that. By the time it had gotten there, there were already existing religios traditions that had begun to explore an idea of a religion without caste against religion through caste.