3 ms·
>The alternative is “internet originalism” — no censorship. If social media companies returned to their original roles, there would be no slippery slope of poli
by krapp 6y ago
>The alternative is “internet originalism” — no censorship. If social media companies returned to their original roles, there would be no slippery slope of political bias or opportunism; they would assume the same status as telephone companies.
The author seems to believe the original role of social media platforms was to provide censorship resistant channels for maximal free speech under the presumption that this was the original "intent" of the internet, and thus the only valid utility for any site on the internet. Apparently forums that moderated content didn't exist before Facebook, etc.
But this is historical revisionism. The intent of social media is to monetize user-supplied content and data. They are not and have never been utilities, the are and have always been businesses.
And it's ironic for someone arguing "internet originalism" to invoke the First Amendment in the spirit of "Constitutional" originalism to support an argument that the First Amendment is explicitly not intended to support. A truly originalist interpretation of both the First Amendment and the internet would support the right of social media platforms to do exactly what they're doing, and strictly oppose attempts by the government to interfere by, for instance, forcing them to act as "utilities" and publish speech against their will.