4 ms·
The problem with decoupling amnesty for illegals and high skilled immigration is that the administration doesn't care about high skilled immigration. Illegal im
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
The problem with decoupling amnesty for illegals and high skilled immigration is that the administration doesn't care about high skilled immigration. Illegal immigrants, were they to become legal, will vote Dem. Thus Dems favor it, Reps oppose it. High skilled immigrants don't show a large bias, neither party gets a political advantage from high skilled immigration, so it goes nowhere.
However, don't think that work authorization will stop innovation from fleeing the country. I'm a US Citizen, and I'm leaving the US to start a business in India in few weeks. My partners are both Indians with a green card.
It would be preferable for us to start our business in the US. We'd love to hire unemployed low skill Americans to act as mechanical turks for us (we need quite a bit of AAI). Their cultural knowledge would certainly be superior to Indian college students (important, since the US is our target market). But Americans are simply too expensive - the business wouldn't be feasible at US minimum wage rates, let alone wages high enough to convince Americans to give up unemployment benefits and come back to work.
- ajju 16y agoWow! What business are you starting?
- yid 16y agoVery interesting, would you care to elaborate on your business, since you're making such a strong commitment to it?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIt's a search engine for fashion - Google Boutiques is the natural point of comparison. Of course, we are hoping to do considerably better than Boutiques. It would be great to hire Americans, because while the girls we have in Pune are great, they don't know things like who Lady Gaga is or what she might wear.
- acgourley 16y agoThat's quite an edge case though, you must admit. In most cases immigrant entrepreneurs would come to and stay in America if the laws allowed.
- theoj 16y agoLet me see if I have this right: You complain about the US not allowing high skilled immigrants in the first paragraph, but then you say you want to hire low skill mechanical turks at below minimum wage in your last paragraph. You are upset that workers in the US will not work for Indian wages when they have US expenses. Furthermore, you imply that your wages are so low that people prefer the small unemployment benefits instead of working for you.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI made no complaint, nor am I upset. I was merely giving objective reasons why, no matter how many visas you give out, some businesses are simply not going to be built in the US. I also explained why politicians focus on low skill illegal immigrants rather than high skill legal immigrants. Personally, I'm looking forward to moving to India. The food is tasty, the women are beautiful, and it's time for me to do something different. I have no complaints.
- rumpelstiltskin 16y agoPersonally, I'm looking forward to moving to India. The food is tasty, the women are beautiful. ...and the bureaucracy and corruption are out of this world. Good luck.
- sigzero 16y agoOh...and let's not forget all those they murder for not believing religiously as they do. No thanks.
- learner4life 16y agorumpelstiltskin has a very valid point, but your's is unsubstantiated cant. Where is the evidence that you get murdered for just not believing religiously as they do?
- geebee 16y agoGood luck! Obviously, I want the US to be competitive, but this is far more out of a desire to see the US prosper than a desire to "beat" other countries in some non-existent competition. Yes, I want silicon valley (and the US in general) to remain home to many innovative companies. No, it doesn't bother me to see India prosper. There are a billion people living in india, many in horrendous poverty. It almost seems nuts that people would fret about the notion that some of the worlds great businesses would happen in India and lift people out of desperate poverty. Seriously, it's highly desirable for people to start businesses in India. While the US should try to be a good place for business, we must not start to see it as some innate failure when other countries prosper as well.