5 ms·
From the way this non-apology is written, these NumFocus people seem very full of themselves and their organization. What are their credentials and achievements
by kazinator 6y ago
From the way this non-apology is written, these NumFocus people seem very full of themselves and their organization. What are their credentials and achievements?
Okay, they sponsor existing projects and then take credit for them, calling them "our open source tools" which are used by everyone "from Netflix to NASA" to "solve the most challenging problems".
Where is the money coming from?
Their site makes deceptive claims:
https://numfocus.org/case-studies https://numfocus.org/case-studies
Here, there is a representation made that there is "NumFOCUS stack" that is being used in various industries to solve problems.
"First Photograph of a Black Hole -- Made with the NumFOCUS Python Stack"
This strongly suggests that there is some actual software component by the name of NumFOCUS Python Stack. But when you read the case study in detail, it comes to light that this refers to some tools that have supposedly received support from NumFOCUS:
"Although the HOPS pipeline Dr. Chan helped develop is mainly written in the C programming language, [watch how we're going to take credit for it anyway, as follows:] EHT scientists also developed a lot of Python code around it to drive the analysis. Dr. Chan explained that there is a huge advantage in using Python."
Right ... , we would not have Python without NumFOCUS, the purveyor of Python! Never mind that Guido guy and what he had been up to since, oh, 1988.
"Dr. Chan pointed to NumFOCUS-supported open source tools — Numpy, SciPy, pandas, Astropy, Jupyter, and Matplotlib — as crucial to this iterative scientific thinking process."
I don't see any references to NumFOCUS in the NumPy Wikipedia page. The NumPy homepage makes absolutely no reference to NumFOCUS at all.
The other "case studies" are like his also.
ScumFOCUS is more like it!
They look like a bunch of status-seeking parasites, from where I'm sitting.
Non-profit organization, right? Sure, after salaries and expenses are paid out.
- re 6y ago> Okay, they sponsor existing projects and then take credit for them [...] I don't see any references to NumFOCUS in the NumPy Wikipedia page. The NumPy homepage makes absolutely no reference to NumFOCUS at all. I have no connection to any of these projects but some very basic browsing on these sites refutes your assertions. You're using questionable criteria to make dubious claims. NumFOCUS was founded by the primary creators of many of these tools specifically to support them; it's not some unaffiliated third-party trying to take credit. > NumPy is a Sponsored Project of NumFOCUS, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit charity in the United States. NumFOCUS provides NumPy with fiscal, legal, and administrative support to help ensure the health and sustainability of the project. https://numpy.org/about/ https://numpy.org/about/ > By 2010, a critical mass of projects were in need of a more formal structure to provide support and help to organize the community. [...] Travis Oliphant (author of NumPy), Fernando Pérez (author of IPython), Perry Greenfield (author of Numarray and Astropy), John Hunter (author of Matplotlib), Jarrod Millman (release manager for SciPy), and Anthony Scopatz (who came up with the name “NumFOCUS”) became the founding board of NumFOCUS. https://numfocus.org/history https://numfocus.org/history
- kazinator 6y agoYou got me. The author of NumPy, Travis Oliphant, is still with the organization, as is Fernando Pérez. Mostly, it consists of other people, though.