4 ms·
Don't let Uber get away with it
- seibelj 6y agoI don’t want everyone who drives for Uber to be forced to be classified as an employee. The rules are too rigid for employment in this country. No matter how many words are written about this, I simply prefer increased flexibility of employer / employee relationships, for Uber or any company. It’s a philosophical difference of opinion.
- wilg 6y agoLA Times makes a good case that this is simply the wrong solution to that problem https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2020-09-23/proposition-22-uber-lyft-doordash-wrong-solution https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2020-09-23/proposition...
- thatswrong0 6y agoFrom the article: > Rather than accepting the bad bargain Proposition 22 presents, voters should demand a better, broader answer from Sacramento. IMO, while that's in principle a decent idea, that's not really a great alternative practically speaking. We're supposed to just hope something different happens in the legislature, and in the mean time, we'll see diminished service and many drivers will be out of work / lose the flexibility of setting their own hours?
- nwallin 6y agoI agree that Prop 22 is not a perfect solution. But I think Prop 22 is a better solution than AB5. If independent contractor work is insufficiently protected, then independent contractors should be given better protections. Gig workers need the flexibility to open up the Lyft, Uber, Doordash, and Instacart apps all at the same time. They need the flexibility to refuse a fare for any reason. They need the flexibility to work whatever hours they want. I don't see how to build that flexibility into the rigid structure enforced by the employer-employee relationship. Trying to 9-to-5-ify gig workers doesn't make any sense to me.
- rexpop 6y agoI do not consider "flexibility of relationship" to be at stake, since all employment is "at will," anyway. It's just a question, in my mind, of to what compensation a worker is entitled. Market dynamics demands gig companies shrink compensation as much as possible. Since gig-workers cannot negotiate their wages, they've no recourse but state intervention to balance out these market forces.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoFlexibility will definitely at the stake though. For example, if I want to drive only a few hours every week, I just won't be worth it for Uber to put on its payroll. "At will" is irrelevant because I won't have the job to begin with. I am left strictly worse off. No employer is going to offer me healthcare and insurance and what not for working a few hours every week. I am left strictly worse off. In the present system, I can just switch on my app for the hours I want to drive and that's the end of the story.
- whamlastxmas 6y agoIt sounds in this hypothetical that you want the ability to have a job that can't pay its workers enough for basic necessities. I believe these jobs shouldn't exist.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoI want the ability to convert some of my hours into money by working. I don't expect 4 hours of work a week to convert into a happy life for a family of four.
- rexpop 6y agoSeems like that's a choice Uber's going to make. I, as a voter, am not going to bend to their tantrum-throwing. If a business can't provide adequate compensation, it shouldn't operate. Edit: To be clear, I guarantee Uber/Lyft will not leave. If they did, a clone would eat their lunch.
- 908B64B197 6y agoI find the paternalism of AB5 to be a little bit problematic. It really assumes that the drivers are too stupid to do their own accounting and figure out if they are making money or not. Pretty sure most drivers wouldn't be driving for $9.21 if a job at the local ice cream parlor could get them almost double on the spot. Yet you still see folks driving 30 hrs per week for years. Not only that, but with the higher prices guaranteed by AB5 and the higher cost of having employees, there's absolutely no guarantee that current drivers will meet the bar for full time employment as drivers (and the company will need less of them).
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoProp 22 is not a problem created by Uber, it's a response to the problem created by the legislature through AB5. They passed a bill that would effectively hamstring rideshare companies and other independent contractors while providing carve-outs for 50+ other businesses, and these companies are now using the process to pass a proposition that will undo this. Of course they are trying to do it in a way that maximally benefits them, but it needs to be borne in mind that they did not make the first blow. The assembly did. Both Assembly Bills and Ballot Propositions are a part of California's legislative framework. In fact Ballot Propositions are the purest expression of the will of the people, and hence supersede legislative action. Given how extensive lobbying is in the US, it's not like assembly bills are pure and unsullied while Prop 22 is tainted by Uber's blood money. The problem in America is that instead of the government providing safety nets, affordable healthcare etc. to all its citizens, it forces these things onto an employer-employee relationship, with no regard for financial fundamentals. CA is a giant state with no realistic public transport options for the vast majority of its population. Services like Uber and Lyft aren't merely 'luxuries' for its people, they provide a necessary service for many of them, without which their lives would not merely be inconvenienced but often be drastically affected. It's just not possible for Uber to be profitable while being affordable to a similar number of people and treating all its drivers as employees. The second and third order effects of these are all negative for the people of California. Employment law should be about removing highly coercive situations, but other than that, adults should be allowed to provide a service in return of a payment without getting embroiled in byzantine regulatory requirements.
- salamimonger 6y ago>CA is a giant state with no realistic public transport options for the vast majority of its population. Services like Uber and Lyft aren't merely 'luxuries' for its people, they provide a necessary service for many of them, without which their lives would not merely be inconvenienced but often be drastically affected. Agreed. I am from LA and as a poor person, for the majority of my life (when I am on my own and without friends/family), my only choice was to walk or take the bus to places. When Uber came along, the idea of paying less than $10 to get a ride completely changed the game for people like me. Now we can actually be on time to important appointments that are too far off to walk or take public transportation reliably. And if we are running late, that's less than $10 to get to work on time, which is arguably worth it even if you were working the shittiest minimum wage job in CA, since minimum wage here is above $10. For us poor folk without cars and the money to pay for car insurance, the ability to call an Uber gave us freedom and choice beyond walking, cycling, and public transpo, which are a joke in a lot of situations - without having to rely on the good will of family and friends.
- rainyMammoth 6y agoI said this before, but Prop 22 is NOT the right solution to this problem. Uber and Lyft want to dodge Medicare and Social security (estimated in the 100 M$ per year) for their workers. That's really what is going on here. Prop 22 let them get away with it. I don't want every Uber driver to be an employee, but I also want to prevent Uber and Lyft using taxpayers money to dodge their obligations.