4 ms·
> Are you sure that's right? It's right. > Suppose you're just inside the event horizon, from the perspective of an external observer. Whether or not you are
by pdonis 6y ago
> Are you sure that's right?
It's right.
> Suppose you're just inside the event horizon, from the perspective of an external observer.
Whether or not you are inside the event horizon is not a matter of perspective. All observers will agree on it.
> You're traveling outward at a velocity of .95c.
Relative to what?
Outside the horizon, velocities, such as the escape velocity you mention, are usually meant as velocities relative to static observers--observers who are maintaining the same altitude above the horizon.
But below the horizon, there are no static observers. It is impossible to maintain a constant "altitude" (which here just means the surface area of the 2-sphere at your location, centered on the hole) even for an instant. So "velocity" relative to a static observer has no meaning inside the horizon.
> That's lower than the escape velocity (which is > c), so you're going to fall back in before you actually get to the external observer.
No, that's not what happens. Relativity is not Newtonian physics.
The event horizon is not a place in space. It is an outgoing null surface: a surface formed by radially outgoing light rays. Spacetime around the black hole is curved in such a way that this particular outgoing null surface has a constant surface area: in other words, even though there is a full 2-sphere's worth of radially outgoing light rays at the horizon, the surface area of the 2-sphere formed by those light rays is constant--the 2-sphere does not expand, as you would expect a radially outgoing spherical wave front to do, because of the curvature of spacetime.
If you are just a little bit inside the horizon, you are on a slightly smaller 2-sphere, and on that 2-sphere, even radially outgoing light rays cannot stay in the same place, much less expand; they contract--that spherical wave front, even though it is radially outgoing, decreases in area with time, i.e., it is falling. So you, having to move slower than light, will fall even more. You can't move outward at all; you can't even stop moving inward. (The fact that there are no static observers inside the horizon is a consequence of this.) That is true no matter how hard you accelerate, since no amount of acceleration will let you move faster than light.