4 ms·
This is the difference between computer science and software engineering. And the vast majority of people who graduate with a CS degree are going to work as so
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
This is the difference between computer science and software engineering.
And the vast majority of people who graduate with a CS degree are going to work as software engineers, not as computer scientists. They are therefore being mis-educated to the degree that their CS program agrees with Dijkstra's philosophy. (Which doesn't mean that Dijkstra is wrong about CS. It just means that a CS degree shouldn't be the passport to a career in software engineering, or even a job as a grunt programmer.)
- Gibbon1 6y agoDijkstra is totally of the European tradition where if you don't belong to the guild it's flat out illegal for you to work in the field.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoThe European tradition is that if you are not admitted to the guild you must not work in the field without supervision. Nothing wrong with that, tbh. You get something out of it, too, your sponsor is invested in your success.
- mcguire 6y agoYes, this is why computer science students from schools like Stanford, Carnegie Mellon, MIT (well, it's an engineering school, anyway), and UT Austin (EWD's stomping grounds) are almost completely unemployable in the software-related industries. All of the employers learned pretty quickly that they were all grossly incompetent.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoFirst, even UT Austin doesn't run their CS program as EWD would have wanted. See his comments when they switched to Java. Second, I suspect (but cannot prove) that this problem is why computer science grads need a couple of years of close supervision on the job before you can trust them with anything.
- Jtsummers 6y agoThey need supervision because they haven't been apprentices gaining practical experience yet. College (especially the sciences) is not about apprenticeships. If you just want "grunt programmer[s]", we need proper apprenticeships and trade schools. Like electronic technicians and plumbers go through.
- jleyank 6y agoSome folks say the science education system is similar to the Medieval Guild systems: apprentices (grad students), journeymen (postdocs) and various levels of master craftsmen (professors). These are intended as ranks not genders, so s/men/people/g if desired.
- dragonwriter 6y agoAcademia (not just, or even especially, in the sciences) is a guild system on those lines, but if you are looking for employment outside of academia, things are a bit different even if you need to go through some part of the academic path for the career entry you are aiming for.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> College (especially the sciences) is not about apprenticeships. It is and it isn't. Most degree programs don't require it, and some don't integrate it as a for-credit option, but most (including in the sciences) do open opportunities for them, and lots of students take advantage of that opportunity and are more employable because of it.
- mcguire 6y agoFortunately, you can hire newly minted software engineers and they require no supervision whatsoever to solve your difficult problems.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoNice strawman. Oh, wait, no it isn't. It's a really cheap strawman. But in the end, it's just a strawman. But it is my position that a graduate of a proper software engineering degree would take less initial supervision than a graduate of a CS degree. Why? Because they would have already seen ambiguous requirements, and would have an idea of what to do. They would have already seen a multi-hundred-thousand-line code base, and would be more likely to have some idea how to navigate in one. They would have some idea of what production-level code looks like, and how to go about achieving that level of completeness. And so on.
- mschaef 6y ago> Yes, this is why computer science students from schools like ... UT Austin (EWD's stomping grounds) are almost completely unemployable in the software-related industries. UTCS 1997 here. I've been employed in software-related industries continually since graduation, and I can honestly say my UTCS degree has been nothing but helpful in that regard. BTW, the personal website listed in your profile is down. You might want to look into that.
- 908B64B197 6y agoWhat's more confusing is that Software Engineering, Computer Engineering and Computer science overlap quite a bit, but are distinct fields. Furthermore, there really is two kinds of CS departments: the ones that were spun out of a Math department and those that emerged out of an Electrical Engineering one.
- abhayb 6y agoSecret third option: spun out of the Business School!
- opportune 6y agoHaving a good understanding of theoretical CS and its fundamentals makes programming a relatively trivial activity. I don't think a CS degree miseducates you at all, as long as you actually internalize the CS you learn.