2 ms·
I don't see how this is worse than FPTP. In FPTP, the candidate with the most votes just wins, even if that is only 15%. A second round for the two most popular
by mcv 6y ago
I don't see how this is worse than FPTP. In FPTP, the candidate with the most votes just wins, even if that is only 15%. A second round for the two most popular candidates is still better than that.
The issue in your example is of course that both parties send all their candidates to the election, instead of just their most popular one, and that dilutes the vote, but the same would happen if they did that in FPTP.
It's only in systems like approval voting or instant run-off that parties can afford to send all their candidates.
- wtallis 6y ago> In FPTP, the candidate with the most votes just wins, even if that is only 15%. A second round for the two most popular candidates is still better than that. In practice, most US elections are preceded by explicitly partisan primaries, and that's the status quo you should be comparing against.
- mcv 6y agoBut that's something that they can continue doing. There are many countries where they have a second round between the two candidates with the most votes, and in those countries, parties generally send only one candidate. And that's what they'll keep doing under this system, because they want their candidate to end up in the top-2. So unless you actively ban any kind of candidate selection by the parties, that is what would also happen in the US.
- winstonewert 6y agoI believe the particular design of the top-two primary allows anyone to enter the primary and list any party as their "preferred party." So the party might endorse a particular candidate, they can't prevent other candidate from getting on the ballot under their party name.