6 ms·
> why we don't just pay the ranchers for livestock killed Ah ha. A HN thread close to home (I live within earshot of wolves in Montana). So...we do [1], [2]. R
by dboreham 6y ago
> why we don't just pay the ranchers for livestock killed
Ah ha. A HN thread close to home (I live within earshot of wolves in Montana). So...we do [1], [2]. Ranchers (generalizing, of course) just don't like wolves. It's a really deep cultural thing. So if you as president want to take some step that will cause a bunch of folks in ranching areas to high five, you'd delist wolves. That they may not in fact be impacted by wolf activity is moot.
[1] https://missoulian.com/news/state-and-regional/montana-makes-record-payments-for-livestock-killed-by-wolves/article_df2275cc-2a91-5831-b79e-84373526e0f9.html https://missoulian.com/news/state-and-regional/montana-makes...
[2] http://liv.mt.gov/Attached-Agency-Boards/Livestock-Loss-Board http://liv.mt.gov/Attached-Agency-Boards/Livestock-Loss-Boar...
- perbu 6y agoIn Norway we pay ranchers for sheep which are taken by wolves. They still really hate wolves. More sheep are taken by wolverines, lynx and bears yet the ranches are still keen on full extermination of the wolf population.
- Filligree 6y agoIt's not unreasonable. Wolves are among the few predators that can and will attack humans. That the wolves, themselves, now have a deep-set fear of humanity and would only dare to do so if they're desperate and starving... is a distant second to that same deep-set cultural fear of wolves. Unpopular Opinion Time: The ecosystem damage from not having apex predators is large enough that it might be worth a few human lives to avoid. Unpopular Opinion Time the Second: But there are other apex predators, such as the lynx, which can take much the same role without being nearly as dangerous to megafauna like humans. Though that's only a decent solution if you don't have problems with megafauna like elk.
- peterwwillis 6y ago"Solutions" like this are how we destroyed Yellowstone the first time, and why deer now run rampant all over the US, literally eroding forests from excessive grazing. A naive assumption about a complex system has knock-on effects that destroy the entire ecosystem.
- spiderfarmer 6y agoYou're making a naive assumption based on one popular Facebook video. The wolves didn't make any difference to the deer population.
- abfan1127 6y agodo you have information to back that claim up?
- spiderfarmer 6y ago"It's a really romantic story," Utah State University ecologist Dan McNulty said. "It's a story about a world that doesn't really exist." https://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-news/scientists-debunk-myth-that-yellowstone-wolves-changed-entire-ecosystem-flow-of-rivers/349988 https://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-news/scientists-debun...
- pvaldes 6y ago> "Is a really romantic history" It still amazes me how often people think that biologists are stupid Wolves return to Yellowstone has being ruminated, and I say ruminated, by scientists for 70 long years All the possible results were examinated, there were lots of reports evaluating the project and all the benefits and cons were studied for decades, by lots and lots of well trained people. The effect of wolf in environment and its role as key species is described in conferences monographs and books. Teams of scientists studied the populations of each single big mammal and bird in Yellowstone, before and after wolves. You can find their conclusions in the libraries of all universities specialized in ecology and animal management. The results were even better than expected, but this was a big success because it was based in a entire life of previous hard work. We talk about reviewed, easily verifiable and painfully verified facts, not about a pulp novel written on a weekend or somebody tossing a coin. Do you really think that somebody could just upload a fakebook video linking to a fake scientific article in this field without being detected and disclosed immediately?
- jjtheblunt 6y agoIs there a citation for a single attack on a human? I'd looked before, some years back, and was unable to find any.
- yaypolitics 6y agoNo. A wolf has never attacked a human. They’re our friends. :)
- eloff 6y agoThere were a couple attacks here in Canada just this year. It's very rare but it happens. One guy was dragged out of his tent by a wolf while camping with his two kids and wife. That's extremely rare. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/wolf-attack-rampart-creek-banff-1.5245105 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/wolf-attack-rampart-c... There are also hunters that go missing in areas where there aren't known to be other predators. Some of those cases might be wolves. There are also cases where we find the remains of a hunter surrounded by dead wolves that he'd shot in a savage fight to the death that he lost. Again, it's rare. The most dangerous large mammal apart from us in North America is deer, because of people killed hitting them in cars or swerving to avoid them. More wolves might improve that.
- dev_tty01 6y agoIt happens. They are predators and we are relatively defenseless. Given enough motivation and circumstances, it will happen. Not an argument to destroy them, but we should base discussions on reality. "The first fatal attack in the 21st century occurred on November 8, 2005, when a young man was killed by wolves that had been habituated to people in Points North Landing, Saskatchewan, Canada[46] while on March 8, 2010, a young woman was killed while jogging near Chignik, Alaska." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolf_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolf_attack
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- torpfactory 6y agoWolves by and large do not attack humans: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wolf_attacks_in_North_America https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wolf_attacks_in_Nort... We might be afraid of them but that fear isn’t grounded in reality.
- dboreham 6y ago> Wolves are among the few predators that can and will attack humans Well...I live in a place where we have (in my back yard, except for Bison) all the megafauna present since the ice age. In order of practical danger (most to least), they rank like this: Moose, Bear, Cougar, Snakes, ... Wolves. People are regularly attacked by Moose and fatalities have occurred in the past few decades. People are eaten by bears every few years and injured by bears annually. Cougars present a real danger but they're pretty wary of humans so attacks are more a theoretical risk we hear about from reports concerning mountain bikers in Los Angeles. I never heard of anyone being attacked by a wolf nor anyone being concerned about being attacked by a wolf. Same for Coyotes and Foxes. I don't hear people suggesting that Moose be killed on sight.
- bigbubba 6y ago> Snakes Virtually every adult killed by snakes in America was asking for it. Rattlesnakes sure as shit know they can't eat humans and would never attempt it. They are named for the mechanism they use to scare us away and bite when that fails. A huge number of rattlesnake bites are to the face or hands because it happens when some moron ignores the rattle and picks up the snake. Wolves, unlike rattlesnakes do sometimes deliberately attack humans with 'malicious' intent. Rattlesnakes never do.
- dropofwill 6y agoRattlesnakes actually don’t rattle that much, they rely a lot on camouflage. Also young ones won’t have fully developed rattles and older ones can lose them. They will often strike without warning. It’s important to pay attention where you put your hands and feet when you’re in rattlesnake country.
- bigbubba 6y agoThey hide first, but will rattle when they think that has failed. Sometimes they bite first without rattling, particularly when startled, but they are less likely to use venom in those circumstances and those bites will generally be to the ankles or legs. Snakes only have self-preservation in mind when it comes to humans, never predation. They hid because they're scared, and they bite because they're scared. Their venom is meant primarily for catching meals but they'll use it in self defence when pressed. In the past 20 years in America, 30 men have been killed by snakes, vs 6 women. Dudes trying to be macho by fucking with snakes explains most of this gap; many of them were bitten on the hands and the circumstances of many of the cases make it pretty clear the snake was being fucked with. Only a handful of incidents were likely genuine accidents.
- supercheetah 6y ago> Unpopular Opinion Time the Second: But there are other apex predators, such as the lynx, which can take much the same role without being nearly as dangerous to megafauna like humans. They're usually more specialized than wolves, especially in terms of prey, and so the populations of species they don't prey upon are left unchecked.
- pvaldes 6y agoThe wolf is the species of animal that has saved more human lifes also (excepting humans of course). Is also in a really select club of animals deliberately adopting and taking care of lost children. They had a strong desire to protect cubs.
- rthomas6 6y agoI wonder if it could be some instinctual thing. Maybe early humans had trouble with wolves for enough time that we selected for loathing them. I don't know how that would work with the existence of dogs though, so maybe not.
- pvaldes 6y agoYep, is a scapegoat species that always pays for all. Must be noted that the entire population of wolves in Norway comprises 68 animals or so. Spain has 2000.
- gcheong 6y agoThat it’s such a deeply cultural thing makes me think that if wolves go extinct they will just choose the next convenient species to focus their ire on. In other words having an enemy to fight against is more important to them than actually protecting their livestock.
- spiderfarmer 6y agoWow, 3 hyperbolic statements in just one comment. To be clear: -Wolves won't go extinct anytime soon. -There's no reason to think farmers would pick another "enemy" if they would. -Livestock is actually important to farmers. No hidden agenda.
- chrisco255 6y agoFrom my talks with Montanans, the main reason some of them don't like the wolves is because the Elk population went down after their reintroduction.
- thinking2smll0 6y agoSo a deeply held cultural point of pride to be leveraged for political points all the same
- HappySweeney 6y agoWasn't that the point? The elk were eating everything down to the nubs.
- hiimtroymclure 6y agoYou could also open up more elk tags. Plenty of hunters more than happy to take down a bull and have a packed freezer. Lottery systems to pull tags are not easy, especially for out of state folks.
- gcheong 6y agoThe difference is that wolves tend to take the weaker members of the herds which strengthens the herd overall, but hunters tend to focus on the stronger members.
- hiimtroymclure 6y agoWhat??? Sure I look for a big bull but I have no idea if the one I took was a "stronger" or "weaker" one. Half the time im just happy to find one. Im sure wolves also go for young bulls or even cows. I also think you are grossly over estimating between the difference between the stronger and weaker bulls in a herd.
- chrisco255 6y agoWolves tend to go for the young elk, which are easier prey, because yes, they are slower and weaker. Not sure it strengthens the herd to take out the young that haven't reached maturity yet.
- BurningFrog 6y agoIf someone was killing my pets, while paying me reasonable compensation, I would also be pissed off at the arrangement. Some things money can't buy.
- thinking2smll0 6y agoIf I chose to live in BFE, I’d accept the wilderness is a harsh reality and be less brittle over what is ultimately a personal life choice Not up to everyone else to let the ecosystem go cause they want to LARP John Wayne movies
- jefftk 6y agoCattle, not pets
- devwastaken 6y agoMany people have animals they have as pets or otherwise are not selling as meat. If you think farms are simply cows you are incorrect.
- BurningFrog 6y agoMy point is the same if it's my car that gets trashed or my internet domains taken. Even if I get good money as compensation, I'd resent it, and much prefer to have my possessions left in peace.
- ReptileMan 6y agoIn the rural parts where I was going when I was growing up the meat animals were not that far from pets. Weird thing to play with a bunny and eat it couple of months later. First lessons in the circle of life.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- peterwwillis 6y agoWhich is like pissed off that an alligator ate your dog when you took your dog to swim in alligator-infested waters. How dare nature be.... natural! Let's kill all the alligators!
- spiderfarmer 6y agoHere in the Netherlands we also pay farmers for killed livestock. And nobody is happy with the situation we're in now. Not the farmers, not the public, not the sheep and not even the environmentalists. Public support for wolves is growing, but only among people who don't know about the problems they cause. One of the main reason farmers hate wolves is because it's madness. A wolf kills 14 sheep in one night and only eats one, partly. That doesn't make it a very sympathetic animal. The Netherlands is very densely populated. Everyone was doing fine without the wolf. Now a couple of environmentalists use public money to try to reintroduce wolves in habitat that isn't able to support them. They got subsidies based on reports that promised no livestock would be harmed. Wolves would just limit themselves automagically to wildlife when there is enough wildlife to support them. This claim is demonstrably false. It's fraud. On top of that, the environmentalist arrogantly call everyone who doesn't love the wolf stupid, uninformed bigots. Like that helps.
- pvaldes 6y ago> the environmentalist arrogantly call everyone who doesn't love the wolf stupid Taking in mind how well we are doing in the last years, maybe would be wise to stop making fun of the environmentalists for a while. I'm still expecting the other part proposing a single valid solution that is not based in 'pay me because I'm unable to understand how to use a shepherd dog'.
- spiderfarmer 6y ago> a single valid solution Shoot the wolves is a single valid solution. But you don't want to hear it. And I think you don't know how shepherd dogs work. Otherwise you would have dismissed that as a valid solution too.
- pvaldes 6y agoThey are more valuable alive than dead. > You don't know how shepherd dogs work Sorry but the facts speak loudly. Last month I had personally visited the area of Europe with a biggest density of wolves (excepting maybe Chernobyl). We tried, and failed, to see a single wolf. There were cows munching all around. There was deer scattered all around the valley. I walked the oak forest alone without any problem. In this area a single human with a few dogs manages routinely 300 sheep without losing a single one by wolves. Not a single attack reported in the entire year. Humanity has being doing the same for 4000 years. Is perfectly possible.