4 ms·
That would be wealth redistribution, which a critical mass of Americans are pathologically opposed to.
by shadowgovt 6y ago
That would be wealth redistribution, which a critical mass of Americans are pathologically opposed to.
- mtgx 6y agoIn that case, I guess these people have nothing against the government taking away all of their farm subsidies, too. Better safe than "socialist".
- neaden 6y agoThe federal government gives farmers a lot of different subsidies already. If we can pay someone to not grow corn, we can pay them for a cow that got killed by a wolf.
- smabie 6y agoThings like that have bad incentive structures and will be gamed
- aejnsn 6y agoYou have to understand farmers and farming. Do you think a true farmer is more dedicated to completing government paperwork or more dedicated to raising another head of livestock? For the gamers/hackers, this is why we fund judges, prosecutors, investigators, and the rest of the court system. You cannot make the case that 5% of those with bad intentions ruin it for the 95% of those with good intentions. Not saying the policy will ever be correct, but this is why you introduce thresholds, limitations, and requirements. For instance, using donkeys in the pasture to combat predators should be required. Promote smart farming, not just a pocketbook.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI've never heard of co-pasturing donkeys to combat predators before. How does that work? That's neat.
- aejnsn 6y agoMy grandparents did some (mostly subsistence) livestock farming when I was a tiny kid. Donkeys are extremely territorial, and snap into this fit of pissed off rage when an intruder threatens their territory or what they identify as 'their' herd. Usually a well-acclimated herd will understand the donkey as their protector. If being ran down by this raging anger-beast doesn't spook a predator enough, a donkey will stomp it bad enough to bring new meaning to the phrase 'ass-kicking'. I've never seen a pasture-mated donkey scared by much of anything other than loud noise, they're brave and loyal to a fault. Great Pyrenees dogs are amazing defenders as well. I've seen those put the brakes on some prowling coyotes and put a chase on them so hard that they defy physics to get over a fence. Exceptionally friendly to humans, and other dogs, outside their pastures. One of the good boys used to visit for pets and treats. :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pkulak 6y agoEveryone is fine when it's distributed to them; half the population will not tolerate it distributed elsewhere. Which means that the only kind of redistribution that's politically feasible is the kind that ends at about half the population. So this plan to pay farmers would likely have broad support.
- dboreham 6y ago> which a critical mass of Americans are pathologically opposed to Presumably this is a joke?
- shadowgovt 6y agoit is not. https://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/business/jobs_employment/february_2013/61_think_state_governments_should_give_out_jobs_not_welfare https://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/business/job...
- willturman 6y agoI'd take this with a massive grain of salt. Rasmussen has the highest right leaning bias of any major pollster accounted for in Five Thirty Eight's pollster ratings: https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/pollster-ratings/ https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/pollster-ratings/ Beyond their biased election polls the site seems tailor made to provide links presenting cheap talking points as majority percentages. I won't bother linking anything else on their website.
- StillBored 6y agoThat link isn't directly about wealth distribution, more about how its distributed. And given my own biases, I'm not surprised about the results. The Works Progress Administration built a lot of infrastructure we still depend on today with unemployed people. Until we get to the point where all our roads, bridges, airports, etc are looking as good as the ones you find in other parts of the world, underpaying healthy people to run asphalt machines for 20 hours a week (or whatever), or provide childcare, gives us a return on the basic societal need to keep people from starving.
- dboreham 6y agoObviously nuts. Almost all Americans are beneficiaries of some sort of wealth distribution. Heck wealth distribution is at the core of western civilization. Pretending that a majority is against it is surely delusional.
- StillBored 6y agoAnd weirdly enough, frequently ones that receive the largest proportion of it are the ones most against it. Both at the federal level, where generally the money is redistributed from the coasts to the "heartland", to at the local level where the cities heavily support the rural schools, roads, and general infrastructure. Even semi-private industries like telcom services are heavily funded through things like the universal service fund. In areas where there is less support, like healthcare, you see rural hospitals struggling to stay open and maintain staff. And this continues get worse, as noticed by the recent "trade war" where a large proportion of the returns from the increased tariffs were just given to farmers, while the main goal of increased domestic manufacturing were further collapsing.
- chmod600 6y agoLet's assume that everything has a price, including one's adherance to a political philosophy. Then isn't is obvious that people with a political philosophy of limited government would demand a higher payout to abandon the idea of limited government? And that people who favor government involvement would go along with government involvement even if they end up footing the bill?
- aww_dang 6y ago>And weirdly enough, frequently ones that receive the largest proportion of it are the ones most against it Why is it weird for someone to resent regulatory conditions that necessitate dependence on a handout?
- jolux 6y agoThis is actually not true, most Americans support higher taxes on corporations and people with high incomes, and a more even wealth distribution: https://news.gallup.com/poll/1714/taxes.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/1714/taxes.aspx
- rtkwe 6y agoExcept they're not really there's all sorts of subsidies in the US economy propping up various industries; oil, farms, manufacturing, etc. It's the specific phrase and label of wealth redistribution/socialism that the US is allergic to the policies are generally individually pretty popular if they're broad based.