3 ms·
I didn't say compression at a shock was isentropic. I was saying the claim that compression at the shock could not be the cause of (all) the heating, unless yo
by pfdietz 6y ago
I didn't say compression at a shock was isentropic. I was saying the claim that compression at the shock could not be the cause of (all) the heating, unless you simply define heating at a shock as being due to compression. Instead, I think you should separate out the heating there into two parts: one due to isentropic compression, and one due to injection of additional entropy by dissipation at the shock.
- bernulli 6y agoYes you do, you keep repeating that 'proper' compression is isentropic. That's simply not the case, certainly not across a shock. The second part of your argument is well defined and makes sense, and no-one argued that. But explain to me again how this is now 'like friction'?
- pfdietz 6y agoRequiring compression to be isentropic is just requiring "compression" to be a well-defined term with a specific quantitative result. Otherwise, it's a vague term that offers no quantitative prediction for how much heating it produces for a given change in density. That's not science.