3 ms·
Agreeing with the rest of your comment, but: >> geoengineering > You mean the thing that's already gotten us into this mess? What got us into this mess is ge
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
Agreeing with the rest of your comment, but:
>> geoengineering
> You mean the thing that's already gotten us into this mess?
What got us into this mess is geo-moving-fast-and-breaking-things. Everyone chasing short-term profits and dumping externalities on everyone else.
I don't get the hate for geoengineering - i.e. planned, large-scale interventions. Sure, it would be better to not need it, but the way things are heading, we very well might.
- _-___________-_ 6y agoGiven the huge uncertainty in all models of the climate, how can we be sure our large scale interventions don’t have large scale unintended consequences?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWe can't, but at some point in the near future, the consequences of our current course of action will be bad enough to risk it. Think of geoengineering as chemo for the planet - a very blunt treatment with bad, large-scale consequences, that we apply anyway, because the disease it fights is even worse.
- triceratops 6y ago> planned, large-scale interventions. Unintended consequences. Unless it's direct carbon capture, there is no guarantee we won't create worse problems.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoDoesn't explain the hate any mention of geoengineering seems to be getting. "Unintended consequences" shouldn't be used as a generic counterargument/thought-terminating cliché. What particular consequences are we talking about, and how they stake against the problem we're sure to have?
- triceratops 6y ago> "Unintended consequences" shouldn't be used as a generic counterargument/thought-terminating cliché. "Geoengineering" is itself a very generic term. > What particular consequences are we talking about, They would depend on the particular geoengineering technique we're talking about. The whole point of unintended consequences is they are not or could not be anticipated before the fact. Other than direct carbon capture i.e. geoengineering that's a direct inverse of the problem we have right now, I'm not confident we can predict everything that can go wrong with any given geoengineering solution. Even direct carbon capture is likely to have some serious downsides at scale we haven't yet considered.