3 ms·
> When in American history would all of the major book publishers refusing to print someone’s words mean the publishers should be made legally liable? I'd say
by whimsicalism 6y ago
> When in American history would all of the major book publishers refusing to print someone’s words mean the publishers should be made legally liable?
I'd say that tech companies a. have more power than book publishers, b. are more concentrated than book publishers historically have been, c. are covered by section 230 safe harbor, unlike book publishers
Moreover, why are we constrained by American history given that the challenges we face clearly are not?
- mattnewton 6y agoThat’s a great criticism; I look to history to try and understand the consequences of principles in practice. But of course changing the details can change everything. The question then is, does the increased power and concentration move the internet companies to the category of something like a utility that needs public oversight, w.r.t. moderating content under section 230? To me that seems strange, other people’s attention does not seem like a utility. There may be other things large tech companies do with their power that mean they need to be regulated like utilities, but moderating user generated content so that users don’t leave or so that ads can be better sold over it doesn’t seem like it fits the bill. It’s not clear to me what is broken on section 230 specifically; I can’t separate a legitimate social ill from the politically motivated attacks.
- closeparen 6y agoMeta: how do you square this position with your usage of HN? Use social media only as much as necessary to bring about its demise? Regret its loss but feel it's socially necessary? Believe YCombinator will actually accept liability for everything posted here and it'll be fine?
- whimsicalism 6y agoAccept that I am going to be complicit and have to engage in things that are structurally problematic. The same way I buy gasoline, knowing that I am indirectly complicit in resource dispossession just by participating in that market. > actually accept liability My end goal is not in making HN liable for comments here, but I do think platform regulation is needed and if 230 has to be used as the "stick" to incentivize compliance, that might be necessary.
- closeparen 6y agoWhat is the shape of that regulation?