3 ms·
> Precisely because they are expensive and difficult to get automatically, they can be a an extra protection against phishing. And the requirement for an EV ce
by jcranmer 6y ago
> Precisely because they are expensive and difficult to get automatically, they can be a an extra protection against phishing.
And the requirement for an EV certificate is that it has to be registered specifically in the corporate name, which isn't necessarily the well-known trade name. Furthermore, anyone could choose to register their company as, say, "Microsoft" if it's not in the same jurisdiction as the actual Microsoft, and you get this lovely verified checkmark saying that the phishing site is, indeed, Microsoft. (Just not the Microsoft they were expecting).
- bleepblorp 6y agoThe concept of TLS certs validating the identity of a business entity--rather than just ownership of a domain name--has merit even though the implementation of EVs was poorly considered. A system that presented the end user with a business card of relevant information regarding a given website could be very effective if done properly. Presenting a list of industries and trademarks that the site does business under in the user's current jurisdiction would be a good start.
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago"specifically in the corporate name, which isn't necessarily the well-known trade name" If you 'verifying' without knowing the legal identity, what on earth have you verified? Perhaps we could include trademarks somehow, but at the end of the day having weired names is down to the firm. The example with google blogs was particularly apt - all URLs are legit, but only one belongs to Google. I want to know which one.