5 ms·
I actually think this is a fair question, because I feel like there are 2 issues that get conflated: 1. First, you are correct, the Earth was much hotter in th
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I actually think this is a fair question, because I feel like there are 2 issues that get conflated:
1. First, you are correct, the Earth was much hotter in the past, and I haven't seen anything convincing that global warming will lead to a fundamental "runaway greenhouse" effect a la Venus that makes life as we know it on Earth unsustainable.
2. That said, a huge climate change in a relatively short amount of time could easily lead the the deaths of billions of people, with a B. One third of the human population lives within 60 miles of the coast. Rising temperatures will lead to huge portions of the planet that are currently densely populated that will no longer support humans. The resulting migrations, "resource wars", and overall increase in extreme weather events (more hurricanes, more droughts, more floods) will lead to death and misery to a huge portion of humanity.
- yters 6y agobut if this change happens on the order of 100 years, that seems enough time to respond
- ALittleLight 6y agoYes, and we should start responding.
- core-questions 6y agoSea level has to actually start rising enough that the rich folks who live waterfront are affected and then we will see some geoengineering efforts or at the very least some solid seawalls. I'm waiting for someone to figure out how to use solar + hotter temperatures + seawater to give us desalinated water
- peterashford 6y agoYou say that, but its effecting Florida now and they're still just denying AGW
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoBut it doesn't and won't. E.g. the sea level may creep up slowly, and then all of a sudden you get a giant flood or hurricane that makes a huge portion of the coast unlivable. And regardless, if you think moving a third of humanity to vastly different lands will be hunky dory smooth sailing, you should study history.
- InitialLastName 6y agoNot just that, but the places we currently grow our food have been primed to fertility over thousands of years of relatively stable climates. If many of those areas become substantially less useful for growing crops (because of storms, temperature changes, drought, whatever have you), it's foolish to assume that we will see just as many places that haven't had millennia of vegetation growing on them become fertile.
- ldargin 6y agoThat depends. Migrations and wars are the responses we can expect if its not handled in an organized way.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoWe've known about it for over 50 years and have done basically nothing. Why would you expect another 100 to matter?
- catawbasam 6y agoUS CO2 per capita is down 1/3 from peak. Europe is way down. China is peaking out. It's a start.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoMuch of this decrease in CO2 per capita in 1st world countries is just because we have outsourced much of our CO2 production to 3rd world countries
- adrianN 6y agoThis is the graph that counts, and there is no discernible improvement in the curve: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Mauna_Loa_CO2_monthly_mean_concentration_DE.svg#/media/Datei:Mauna_Loa_CO2_monthly_mean_concentration.svg https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Mauna_Loa_CO2_monthly_me...
- nullsense 6y agoHundreds of years starting in 1800s gives us until about 2100. 80 years will be within our childrens lifetimes for us millennials.
- rtx 6y agoYou need to look at arable land distribution, most of them are far from seas.
- peterashford 6y agoNZ is the worlds largest dairy exporter. ALL of NZ is close to the sea. Many islands are the world's food basket for bananas, coffee, coconut, palm oil (which is MASSIVE) and those are just the ones I can think of off the top of my head.
- kanox 6y ago> Rising temperatures will lead to huge portions of the planet that are currently densely populated that will no longer support humans. This does not seem likely, the bar for a region being "unable to support humans" is very high. People already live in cities that need to support themselves with food from elsewhere, and worldwide calorie production per capita is increasing.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoLand that is underwater would count as unable to support humans, I think.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoA few areas of the world that are unusually low-lying and situated over permeable rock like limestone will be flooded. For the rest of the world, dikes are a well-understood technology, and quite cheap compared to sacrificing large land areas or moving cities. Even worst-case shortest-timeline estimates of sea level rise are not an existential crisis.
- peterashford 6y agoThere are pacific islands losing land to water rise NOW. This is an existential crisis for them. What do you say to them? Sorry, we couldn't be bothered to fix the problem? (That we created and you are suffering the consequences of)
- dodobirdlord 6y agoThey should move. Perhaps it would soften the blow if they were also told platitudes about fault and blame, but realistically (a) the problem is not going to be solved in time, and (b) the plight of a small number of people is not going to move the needle in regards to the willingness of the world to address the issue. People who still think that the damage can be averted entirely are just as deluded as people who think that sea level rise is an existential threat to human civilization.