4 ms·
$666 is an improvement over $1k. It's still a core without V or B extensions, and still prohibitively expensive for anyone that doesn't need them. Useful for
by snvzz 6y ago
$666 is an improvement over $1k.
It's still a core without V or B extensions, and still prohibitively expensive for anyone that doesn't need them.
Useful for those working on risc-v ports, and that's about it.
- ddevault 6y agoThe price really isn't that outrageous. Consider the use-case: this is a mini-ITX form-factor with a standard power supply, M.2 slots, a PCIe adapter, etc. This is designed for desktop workstations. It comes with the CPU, motherboard, and RAM, all in one package. When you sum up the costs of those in your typical desktop PC workstation build, it's not really that far off.
- wmf 6y agoIt's very far off since this is slower and has fewer features than the worst motherboard ($60) and the worst CPU ($50) on the market. Add $30 worth of RAM and you're up to $140.
- ddevault 6y agoIt's also the first usable workstation for a novel open-source architecture. It's not as fast but that's a feature which, in my opinion, makes the price parity reasonable. Progress is gradual.
- snvzz 6y ago>It comes with the CPU, motherboard, and RAM, all in one package. Unfortunately, the RAM not being socketed means you're limited to 8GB, which disqualifies this machine as workstation. Low CPU performance is tolerable, system chocking on low RAM isn't. I'm suffering on a laptop that "only" has 16GB RAM, and this is despite minimizing the load by alternating between Sway and i3 depending on mood on boot. Editor, Browser (unavoidably heavy, with a ton of tabs open as part of the workflow), PDF viewer, Music player and little else. Everything is bloated these days. I don't see how 8GB can be tolerable as a workstation. It really is a deal breaker.
- ddevault 6y agoHah! 8G of RAM is plenty for a workstation. My main laptop away from home is only on 4G and I seem to manage just fine. My home workstation is 32G but the only time I get even close to that is when I use /tmp to compile a large project.
- fomine3 6y agoIt looks like enough for you but I think commonly it's not enough. 16GB is minimum for "workstation".
- FullyFunctional 6y agoNeither V nor B are ratified, nor are they part of the Unix platform standard (and hopefully never will be). V is close, B is not. There are exactly 0 chips or even IP on the market with standard B (which is really a family of sub-standards), but there are chips with pre-standard V (alas, a few of them aren't compatible with the current draft - the perils of running ahead). Overall, yes you are right, this is most useful for people interested in seriously evaluating RV64GC and/or porting code. It's a one of the necessary steps on the path to more adoption, but not the last one.
- snvzz 6y ago>(and hopefully never will be) Do you have a rationale for this? I understand that: * The unix platform standard is a relatively fat selection of extensions already. * The nature of V's flexible width allows it to be implemented in very small scale to very large scale, so it would have little impact on the complexity of the minimum platform, while allowing great benefits as it scales up to larger platforms.
- FullyFunctional 6y ago1. Cores already exist or are coming that satisfy the existing platform. They would be obsoleted by a change in the requirements. 2. RV64GC is already quite big. Piling more requirements onto it will make it harder to introduce small cores. 3. V is pretty complex and I don't agree with your assertion. In contrast I'm aware of cores with vector where the vector part takes up 50% of the die and does exactly nothing for the scalar apps that don't use it. I'd much rather spend that silicon on more IPC or a 2nd core.
- MrMorden 6y agoI appear to not be the only person who (thinks they) spotted an Apple I callout.
- ncmncm 6y agoIt's tragic that all these chips are coming out with no POPCOUNT instruction, held hostage by the unfinished B extension. We really need to get POPCOUNT into the base (at least) 64-bit core set.
- brucehoult 6y agoA number of companies have asked for popcount to NOT be included in the base spec for B (certainly Zbb for embedded), because of the expense of implementing it vs the relatively small speedup it givesfor quite specialized use-cases. Of course popcount will have an opcode allocated and binutils and gcc will (already do) know how to use it if it is present, so anyone who wants/needs it can implement it.
- ncmncm 6y agoA "number of companies" have asked to have the instruction set degraded because they have code that fails to use it? Ignorance, or corruption?
- fulafel 6y agoWhy popcount?
- PeCaN 6y agopopcount is extremely useful in a lot of algorithms, from RSA to chess engines to sparse arrays and tries it's honestly pretty baffling that RISC-V doesnt have it (perils of design-by-academia)
- brucehoult 6y agoIt's not an improvement over $999, it's an improvement over ($999 + $1999) = $2998 because it has PICe and USB and so forth all on one SoC and board. That's a 4.5x price reduction (or 77.8% off if you prefer) in three years. The price/performance increase should be bigger than that because of the ~50% increase in IPC and also hopefully a ~33% increase in clock speed (they don't seem to have announced that but it should be around 2 GHz) Also it's a just a little unrealistic to expect something that will have taped out 6 to 9 months ago to have extensions that aren't even at draft 1.0 status yet, let alone ratified. Any chip with those is going to be 18 to 24 months away.
- snvzz 6y ago>Also it's a just a little unrealistic to expect something that will have taped out 6 to 9 months ago to have extensions that aren't even at draft 1.0 status yet, let alone ratified. Any chip with those is going to be 18 to 24 months away. This was based on SiFive's recent announcements. https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200914005108/en/SiFive-To-Introduce-New-RISC-V-Processor-Architecture-and-RISC-V-PC-at-Linley-Fall-Virtual-Processor-Conference https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200914005108/en/SiF... Together with claims earlier this year that there'd be some ratified V (a 1.0 draft?) by September and they'd have chips ready pretty much immediately. What I understand at this point is that this simply hasn't happened, but I do not know the specifics.
- brucehoult 6y agoI don't believe they've ever said they'd have chips available immediately. That would be some kind of time travel. What I believe they've said in the past is they'll have cores available for licencing immediately, and indeed the "VIU75" with "Vector Intelligence" was announced last week. Customers will be able to sign contracts now, and get preliminary near-1.0 RTL to use in FPGAs for testing and software development. By the time the customers are ready to tape-out in six or twelve months the final spec-compliant RTL would be available.
- justinclift 6y ago> ... it should be around 2 GHz Isn't this one supposed to be 4 (main) cores @ 1GHz?