17 ms·
[Copying from the other item on this where I was answering a comment about why this is more expensive than a Raspberry Pi] You have to understand why the Raspb
by rwmj 6y ago
[Copying from the other item on this where I was answering a comment about why this is more expensive than a Raspberry Pi]
You have to understand why the Raspberry Pi is priced the way it is: it's because it is a side effect of the massive production of Broadcom chips for tablets, phones, embedded, etc. Millions and millions are made. A relatively tiny number of these find their way into developer boards. The economies of scale mean they can be very cheap.
RISC-V doesn't have this ... yet ... but there are several Chinese manufacturers currently making millions of chips for consumer devices with those going through foundries right now. So sooner or later the economics will work out for a "RISC-V Pi". I'd be surprised if it doesn't exist by 2022.
For now this SiFive board is IMHO the best PC-like developer experience for RISC-V. [Disclaimer: Red Hat works with SiFive]
- _alex_ 6y agoI didn’t know riscv was making its way into consumer goods yet. Any examples you can share of places seeing riscv adoption?
- rwmj 6y agoAllWinner are one company that has publicly disclosed doing a large multi-million run of chips: http://www.semimedia.cc/?p=7803 http://www.semimedia.cc/?p=7803 It's not exactly clear from that announcement what they are going to use them for though. "industrial control, smart home, and consumer electronics" - that's everything :-)
- snvzz 6y agoThis is great news. If peripherals are the same or similar to those in their existing ARM SoC chips, we'd be close to full support on release thanks to the linux-sunxi project efforts[0] and similar efforts in netbsd. [0]: https://linux-sunxi.org/Linux_mainlining_effort https://linux-sunxi.org/Linux_mainlining_effort
- TomVDB 6y agoThey are in a lot of current Western Digital SSDs. Nvidia is known to have them in their GPUs in some form. I know of other consumer products where they are similarly used as embedded CPU, which is where RISC-V will be most prevalent in the coming years.
- rwmj 6y agoEven better, WD have open sourced their implementation (as SweRV core: https://github.com/chipsalliance/Cores-SweRV https://github.com/chipsalliance/Cores-SweRV)
- wtallis 6y agoWestern Digital is heavily involved in RISC-V, but I wasn't aware that they had confirmed any of their products are using RISC-V yet. Last I heard from them, their first generation of in-house NVMe SSD controllers were definitively not using RISC-V. And their second generation of NVMe SSD controllers is only just starting to ship.
- justincormack 6y agoThere are Risc-V chips in the Google Pixel phones in the image processing core, see notes here https://techroose.com/tech/riscvWorkshop.html https://techroose.com/tech/riscvWorkshop.html There are probably lots more, but lots are not documented.
- rasz 6y ago>it's because it is a side effect of the massive production of Broadcom chips for tablets, phones, embedded There was exactly one product using same BCM2835 chip found in first Pee, Roku2. VideoCore 4 architecture (but different silicon) was also used in few Samsung phones, and Nokia 808 as GPU only (no CPU cores). Broadcom had zero VideoCore design wins past ~2014. >A relatively tiny number of these find their way into developer boards VideoCore is pretty much strictly rasPee boards now.
- mlyle 6y agoI guess you don't like the Pi, and that's fine. But most of us stopped using silly derogatory language like that many years ago. If you've got a complaint, say it like a grownup, IMO.
- jwr 6y agoAs an embedded developer and system designer with many years of experience with Broadcom SOCs, I largely share @centimeter's sentiment, and would likely use similar wording in a private conversation.
- mlyle 6y agoWell, feel free to look down your nose at things and act immaturely. I've built things around all kinds of ARM SoCS big and small... And AVR... and 8051 and 6502... I find things about Pi and Raspbian annoying, and sure wish there was more I/O and better graphics support... But, how awesome is it that there's a ~$50 lego brick out there, with a ton of computation and long term support that a huge ecosystem of projects have sprouted from? And even better, we have all the boards around with less traction (Beagle*, oDroid, etc) to pick from. I don't see the draw in being elitist. There's all kinds of projects I'd have had to spin a challenging-to-lay-out and expensive-to-manufacture board for before.. and now I can make a little silly Pi hat and get prototypes done in hours. This is exciting!
- rasz 6y agoIs this all you got from my post? Homophone parody overshadowed factual correctness?
- m463 6y agoThe SiFive HiFive Unmatched comes in the mini-ITX standard form factor to make it easy to build a RISC-V PC. For the first time, standard industry connectors such as ATX power supplies, PCI-Express(r) expansion, Gigabit Ethernet, and USB ports are present on a single-board RISC-V development system. Cost aside, I think using the PC ecosystem has a lot of advantages over the pi ecosystem.
- bipson 6y agoI know, this discussion is quite old (e.g. Mac vs. PC), but can you clarify how you define PC in your post? Particularly what makes this RISC-V board a PC, what an RPi does not have? Form factor, ATX power or PCI-Express?
- justaguy88 6y agoThis isn't a Mac vs PC comparison, its embedded form factor and vs standard form factor with standard connectors
- bipson 6y agoI didn't say it was. I was just wondering how you define PC. Form factor or "standard connectors" (whatever that is - which RPi connector is not "standard"?) are none of my criteria.
- brucehoult 6y ago"PC": ability to use any commodity Mini-ITX PC case, commodity power supply, standard PCie video card, standard M.2 SSD.
- bipson 6y agoI'm getting frustrated here. Could you guys stop for a second pretending that your "opponent" is dumb and try to look outside the box? Again, to me this are entirely arbitrary criteria. They are not "PC-Standards", they are some of many standardized connectors, form factors, etc. and in fact a matter of habit, not defining criteria. Let me put it differently: - So is a DTX-Board with an ARM-SoC a PC? - Is an ATX-Board with a PowerPC but without PCIe a PC? What if we add PCIe? - Is a SBC with an AMD APU powered by an USB power supply a PC? What if we add an M.2 port? See where I am going? These are terrible criteria. Define PC for me.
- throwaway4good 6y agoThe smallest development board for Huawei's HarmonyOS uses a RISC-V chip: https://device.harmonyos.com/en/docs/start/introduce/oem_wifi_start_des-0000001050168548 https://device.harmonyos.com/en/docs/start/introduce/oem_wif...
- Narishma 6y ago> You have to understand why the Raspberry Pi is priced the way it is: it's because it is a side effect of the massive production of Broadcom chips for tablets, phones, embedded, etc. Millions and millions are made. A relatively tiny number of these find their way into developer boards. The economies of scale mean they can be very cheap. That was the case for the very first version, but didn't the subsequent models use SoCs made specifically for them?
- CameronNemo 6y agoThey can still use designs, knowledge, and supply chains that have already been built and scaled.
- londons_explore 6y agoEven the first one was an SoC which didn't sell well so they got it almost for free.
- Accujack 6y agoAnswer here on Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/raspberry_pi/comments/egwo6z/was_the_broadcom_bcm2711_designed_specifically/ https://www.reddit.com/r/raspberry_pi/comments/egwo6z/was_th...
- samatman 6y agoI know this a losing battle, but I can't help but pipe up from time to time: that's a disclosure, not a disclaimer. I'm grateful to everyone putting in the work to make RISC-V happen, open hardware is the only way out of the increasingly grim world of 'secure boots' and the like, which seems hell-bent on making general purpose computing on a trusted platform a thing of the past.
- silasdavis 6y agoGets on my tits also. It's a disclosure.
- pkaye 6y agoIsn't RISC-V just an open standard ISA. The hardware implementation might be closed source. Its still possible to but secure boot features on to an implementation.
- samatman 6y agoSure. It makes the world I'd like to live in possible, it doesn't guarantee we'll get it. But foundries will burn whatever chip you have the money to pay for. Having a robust open standard ISA lowers the barriers enough that I'm confident we'll see free-as-in-freedom CPUs and GPUs come out of the project.
- marcan_42 6y ago"Secure boot" is a perfectly fine and desirable thing. It makes evil maid attacks more difficult and has many other benefits. The problem is that the current crop of "secure boot" implementations focuses squarely on the average consumer that wants to delegate trust to the manufacturer, and, at best, only pays lip service to users who want to control their own hardware (see: Pixel devices and the like with closed bootloaders/TrustZone but an escape hatch for the OS) or nothing at worst. Almost every "secure boot" CPU in modern smartphones and such is already user-control-friendly, it's just that they aren't being shipped that way. They get locked down at the factory. The CPU architecture has little to do with any of this. If you want an example of what an unlocked secure boot device is, look at the Nvidia Tegra devkits. Those come without the public key fuses blown. You can burn in your own public key and then they will only ever run firmware you signed, forever. ARM devices without secure boot, or with user-control-assertable secure boot exist. And RISC-V devices locked down at the factory will exist.
- noja 6y agoIs there a RISC-V PC I can buy now that will run Fedora?
- rwmj 6y agoNo. You can run Fedora out of the box on QEMU[1]. We have Fedora running on the Unleashed, but you can't buy those boards any more. SiFive have Fedora running on the Unmatched, which you can preorder now and will ship this quarter. [1] https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Architectures/RISC-V/Installing https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Architectures/RISC-V/Installi...
- brucehoult 6y agoI don't have my board yet, but I would expect Fedora (and Debian) for the HiFive Unleashed should run on the $499 Icicle (600 MHz quad U54 plus S51). That's the same as the Unleashed but clocked slower. Like the new HiFive Unmatched it also has PICe.
- justinclift 6y agoInteresting. Somehow hadn't noticed the Icicle before: https://www.hackster.io/news/microchip-s-risc-v-powered-polarfire-soc-icicle-kit-launches-as-the-industry-embraces-risc-v-cf8378f37614 https://www.hackster.io/news/microchip-s-risc-v-powered-pola...
- brucehoult 6y agoIt comes out of the box with Linux in the eMMC and FPGA programming that connects the CPU cores to the peripherals, so if all you want to do is run RISC-V Linux then you don't need to muck about with FPGA programming. But you can, if you wish, rebuild the default FPGA programming from source code, enhance it, or replace it completely.
- rwmj 6y agoIt's a good FPGA development environment (I have one too), but it's not a good RISC-V environment because of the slow clock speed - 650 MHz, which is about half the speed achievable on the HiFive Unleashed, itself not exactly a fast platform. If you want to play with FPGAs with lots of IO, or even experiment with writing your own peripherals for RISC-V then it's fun.
- bipson 6y agoFurther, a RPi is not a development board. Development boards are typically more expensive, since they are produced in lower numbers, and have features a consumer is not interested in (debugging, etc.). Unless the manufacturer pushes development boards hard to e.g. pull developers in to the new eco-system quickly, then they might get sold at a bargain. But those are then usually not usable in place of the "real thing" (would cut into sales).
- rwmj 6y agoTo be fair the RPi 4 8 GB with a UAS disk is getting pretty good: https://rwmj.wordpress.com/2020/09/24/raspberry-pi-4-running-fedora-32/ https://rwmj.wordpress.com/2020/09/24/raspberry-pi-4-running... I use it for Arm development.
- bipson 6y agoOh, well I guess you can use it as a development board - granted. Never occurred to me. Although I would expect better debugging interfaces, less hacky hardware setup, a reasonable boot-loader, etc. Some things improved over the generations, true.
- rwmj 6y agoIt's a lot cheaper than getting everyone Cavium ThunderX2's :-)
- jimsmart 6y ago> Development boards are typically more expensive That's not what I've experienced: Arduino's are cheaper, Teensys are cheaper, Adafruit boards are cheaper, many others too. And that's just regular retail prices at e.g. Mouser, or even the official websites — without even getting into the super-cheap Chinese stuff on AliExpress/etc. — Why the downvotes? IDK, maybe you meant more powerful boards than those?
- detaro 6y agoYour examples all are for simpler chips, more microcontrollers rather than application processors (with the chip on the Teensy 4.x being the closest to the latter category, it's a bit of a hybrid). Those kind of boards also typically do not expose much that's specific to the capabilities of the chip, but rather mostly jut raw access to the IO pins + some helper circuitry. That's not to say you can't use those to develop things with the chips, but it's a somewhat different market. Whereas from a classic development board it's typically expected that it provides access to as many capabilities of the chip as possible, and more complex chips have a staggering amount of those. E.g. taking the chip on the teensy, since it's the one that's the most high-end one from your examples: It has Ethernet support - add an Ethernet port. It has CAN support - add external CAN circuitry. It has USB - add USB ports. It supports low-level debugging through JTAG and SWD - add that, either a basic debugger or at least a space to connect an external one. It has a display interface - add a dedicated header for that, or maybe even just add a display. I think it supports eMMC flash - add space for that. That makes these boards a lot bigger and expensive, but it means a developer can start with whatever combination of things they want to try, and if the alternative is them spending a day on figuring out and hooking up all the external bits they need on a simpler board the higher price doesn't matter anymore. (Especially coming from the days were there wasn't as big an ecosystem of breakout boards for lots of things available). The end result then looks more like something like this: https://www.embeddedartists.com/products/imx-rt1062-developers-kit/ https://www.embeddedartists.com/products/imx-rt1062-develope..., and appropriately costs a bunch more than the teensy Teensy.
- ArcticCelt 6y ago>So sooner or later the economics will work out for a "RISC-V Pi". There is already pretty cool stuff. Look at this developer board, you get a RISC-V Dual Core 64bit + an ESP32 (a full MCU for wifi + Bluetooth) on the same board and a camera for $24. That Risc-V chip is optimized for processing neural networks. https://www.seeedstudio.com/Sipeed-Maixduino-Kit-for-RISC-V-AI-IoT-p-4047.html https://www.seeedstudio.com/Sipeed-Maixduino-Kit-for-RISC-V-... (warning site very slow)
- nl 6y agoI have one of these and can confirm it's pretty good. Don't expect a smooth out-of-the-box experience (things like the pin numbers don't match in different versions) but the hardware works and the software works enough to be able to use it.
- centimeter 6y agoThe broadcom SoC used on the raspi is also a horrendously designed unstable piece of shit. I can't wait for open source SoCs to come eat its lunch.
- qwerty456127 6y ago> So sooner or later the economics will work out for a "RISC-V Pi" This is cooler than Raspberry Pi because it has PCIe x8 (which I couldn't find on the picture but the specs say its there) and M.2 slots.
- derpthethrowaw 6y agoThe Raspberry Pi is not pervasive and popular because of the architecture. There are millions of single board computer knock off versions of the Pi, new ones coming out every day with different features. None of them catch on. Why would a random new SBC, even at the exact same price or lower, have any chance of replacing the Pi with no identifiably better user facing features other than “it isn’t Arm and it does the exact same thing or less things!!! And it is vastly incompatible with all the software ecosystem and uses you actually care about!” This is like me handing you a RISC-V iPhone (same price) and 30% of the apps work. Would you ever, ever, ever switch? No. Sorry, Arm architecture skyrocketed to popularity because of an ultra long term strategy and a few rocket ship design wins like Android and the iPhone. I am afraid the door is shut. Tizen might have been a good idea, but without a rocket ship to subsidize the improvements of the OS, it died. RISC-V boards are not different. I am looking for a rocket ship, which is a new high volume use case which is not properly covered by the current set of solutions. Self driving cars? AI cameras? Robots? Nothing looks like it needs RISC-V in particular, none of it seems likely to produce iPhone scale novel designs that will eat the rest of the market out from Under arm.
- monoideism 6y ago> I am afraid the door is shut. The door is never fully shut. Arm itself is proof of that.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoChina adopting RISC-V to achieve IP independence will likely be that killer app. ARM popularity is going to significantly reduce the porting challenge. The gap between supporting 1 and 2 platforms is an order of magnitude harder to cross than 2 and 3.
- spirobel 6y agosbcs are not the next big thing. But still there are other sbc platforms besides the pi. Do you think that all these iot devices with linux in there are developed from scratch everytime? Also regarding the last part: Ai cameras in iot devices will need riscv look at this: https://www.sipeed.com/solution.html# https://www.sipeed.com/solution.html#
- fomine3 6y agoJust curious, could you show any other product that uses BCM2711? I don't know whether exact same chip is used other than RPi. Even exact same chip isn't used for other than RPI, its design should be shared to other SoCs, so it can be cheap.
- nextaccountic 6y agoI don't know, but this thread has some info https://www.reddit.com/r/raspberry_pi/comments/egwo6z/was_the_broadcom_bcm2711_designed_specifically/ https://www.reddit.com/r/raspberry_pi/comments/egwo6z/was_th... > > Hi all – I'm curious about the origin of the chip used in the Pi 4, the Broadcom BCM2711. Was it designed specifically for the Pi? I can't find any reference to it on the Broadcom website, which is strange, nor any record of its use in any other device, e.g. a smartphone. > Sort of. The BCM2835 (Pi 1) was originally designed as a set top box SoC and was used in devices like the 1st gen Roku boxes. The BCM2836 (Pi 2), BCM2837 (Pi 3) and BCM2837B0 (Pi 3+) were designed for and only used by Pi boards. The BCM2711 was designed for and only used by the Pi 4 but it is closely related to a new BCM7211 which is for set top box usage.
- oso2k 6y agoI agree. I think the original assumption about "leftover volume/stock" only really applies to the RPi 1. However, if you talk more in terms of ARM ISA, then it certainly applies to every generation of the RPi in that the chosen ISAs are "leftover/last gen licenses" and are presumably less expensive to procure and produce chips from on older design processes. The ARM11/ARMv6 was new in 2001 while the ARMv6Z core in the RPi 1 was new in 2003 with the RPi 1 coming out in 2013. The ARMv8 ISA came out in 2011, with A72 coming out in 2015, while the RPi 4 came out in 2019. [0][1][2][3] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raspberry_Pi#Specifications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raspberry_Pi#Specifications [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM11#Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM11#Overview [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM11 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM11 [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_ARMv8-A_cores https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_ARMv8-A_cores
- unwiredben 6y ago