5 ms·
I prefer torrents inside I2P [0], because otherwise my IP will be shown to everyone. I wonder why there are so few people there. It's of course slow, but it's w
by fsflover 6y ago
I prefer torrents inside I2P [0], because otherwise my IP will be shown to everyone. I wonder why there are so few people there. It's of course slow, but it's worth it. There are already quite a few torrent trackers.
[0] https://geti2p.net https://geti2p.net
- knaik94 6y agoWhat kind of speeds do you get? Because last time I tried it getting above a few megabits per second was a struggle. When we're talking about even an Ubuntu ISO, it's a couple gigs. It's too slow to want me to keep using it.
- fsflover 6y agoIndeed, few Mbps is typical for the current number of users. It can take days to download relatively large files. Still, is speed more important than anonymity? Definitely not always, perhaps never. I hope it gets better with more users, as it happened with Tor.
- Eli_P 6y ago> I wonder why there are so few people Maybe because people understand that it's security model is flawed: the peers in the mesh treat all the other peers as not trusted, that's okay; but the network design doesn't seem to take into account potential hostility of the physical medium itself. Say, your ISP can tarpit packets or shape traffic, or shut down the power or cell tower in your block temporarily, and then measure how the mesh congestion changed. At the same time the mesh relies on building hop chains with TTL of 10 minutes iirc, which I think makes a peer a sitting duck. It is (was) all documented/leaked.
- fsflover 6y agoAFAIK garlic routing is still harder to crack than Tor: https://geti2p.net/en/comparison/tor https://geti2p.net/en/comparison/tor. The main advantage of Tor is the number of users.
- Eli_P 6y agoI doubt the number of nodes is important when you can split a large group of them into a few subgroups and analyze them or alter how they interact with each other, then repeat subdivision; because again, them overlay networks are like smaller sandboxes inside the big one.
- fsflover 6y agoDon’t forget that you have to do all this within 10 minutes, because after that time the network configuration will be totally different.
- Eli_P 6y agoYes, overlay network's configuration will be somewhat different, but physically it will be the same. It's like you're rearranging apple bits in a pie to save them; the pie will be sliced and eaten anyways.
- fsflover 6y ago> the pie will be sliced and eaten anyways. The difference is how long it takes and how much resources. There is no perfect security. Security is not a "yes/no" thing.
- Eli_P 6y agoAll correct. It's just important to remember who's the attacker: Alice -- ISP1 -- 1000 hops -- ISP2 -- Bob Alice and Bob's identities are protected from each other, but not from the govt because ISPs collect metadata.
- fsflover 6y ago> because ISPs collect metadata Which metadata? ISPs only know your next hop. Check out how garlic routing works.