2 ms·
Of course it is. Count every time the human has to take over as a crash for the computer, and then see what your statistics look like. The computer is much wors
by amanaplanacanal 6y ago
Of course it is. Count every time the human has to take over as a crash for the computer, and then see what your statistics look like. The computer is much worse.
- Retric 6y agoEvery time the computer is handing off control that’s a multi second process where it could have come to a complete stop instead. Essentially that’s the same thing as the vehicle stability assistance kicking in, which very much favors the machines. Instead you need to count the number of times someone has actively taken control to avoid a collision, which is rare enough it’s hard to find examples.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoYou seem to be claiming that the computer really is good enough today for fully autonomous driving, and that the need for the driver to pay attention and keep hands in the wheel is really unnecessary. Is that right?
- Retric 6y agoI don’t think fully autonomous driving is ready, fully autonomous human equivalent accident avoidance is a much simpler problem that seems to be largely solved. Having an alert driver paying attention is a net benefit, but in practice people don’t continuously pay full attention for long stretches with autonomous driving. If you assume people are paying attention say 90% of the time in practice then their only catching less than 90% of the potential accidents they could avoid. Further, assuming identical rates of accidents to the average person the other car is at fault 1/2 the increase is further reduced. As such, I think the regulation is a good idea for now as the net benefit to fully autonomous driving is to the individual while the risks include other drivers.