5 ms·
Back in the Palm days I wrote a letter-tile game with letters falling from the top of the screen, you dragged them around to make words. In the 'search terms' o
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
Back in the Palm days I wrote a letter-tile game with letters falling from the top of the screen, you dragged them around to make words. In the 'search terms' on the sales site I used, I included 'scrabble'.
Got a cease-and-desist letter from hasbro(?) demanding I remove the trademarked name 'scrabble' from my 'marketing literature'.
Now, it wasn't in my 'marketing literature'. It wasn't in anything user-visible at all. The search terms were invisible. Unless either Hasbro got the website to release them (in which case they would simply have asked the website to remove them), OR they noticed when they searched for 'Scrabble' that my game came up first. Before the licensed game. Which was a lame app.
I felt annoyed they would stoop to this, and was going to hang fast. But my partner buckled, and removed the search term. Sigh.
Anyway, haven't played Scrabble since.
- BostonFern 6y agoHasbro in NA, Mattel internationally.
- rstupek 6y agoOur game in the app store could not include scrabble in the keywords because its copyrighted
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoBut you're not publishing it! Copyright doesn't apply. That's what galled me.
- dragonwriter 6y ago(1) Copyright applies even if you aren't publishing; it's called copyright and not publishright for a reason. (2) Providing an app on an app store is publishing, anyway. (3) The issue here was almost certainly trademark, not copyright.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoAgain, the word doesn't appear to any user, nor is it in the app nor transmitted to the user. It appears in a database, one time. Probably was already there, because the Scrabble app was already there! The app in the app store is irrelevant. The trademark is irrelevant (not marking this product, not infringing). Does that hold water?
- hansvm 6y agoMy layman's understanding of trademarks is that the salient detail is whether your use of the trademark would likely cause confusion about the source of the material. The question then is if your app showing up for search results (or whatever other side effects might happen from your use of the trademark) about scrabble would be likely to convince people that the app _might be_ officially endorsed. I believe current US case law is trending toward keyword stuffing not generally being a trademark violation, even when explicitly targeting a trademarked competitor, but people are getting dragged to court over it from time to time, so that might be more than you'd like to take on.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Our game in the app store could not include scrabble in the keywords because its copyrighted More likely, because it is a trademark.
- rstupek 6y agoLikely, but the error message indicated copyright. It seems like fair use to me but certainly not worth it to litigate.
- dspillett 6y ago> it wasn't in my 'marketing literature'. It was in your sales site. Your sales site could most validly be referred to as marketing literature. > It wasn't in anything user-visible at all. It was visible though, to the search engine at least. And back to the "not marketing literature" point - SEO very much is marketing. Now they might be being a bag of dicks, in this case and more generally, but I don't think those two points you are arguing with are valid at all.
- stephenhuey 6y agoExactly. A friend went through a bad lawsuit because his business partner did this very thing on their website (my friend didn’t know the business partner was playing that game with a competitor and unfortunately this incident led to their business shutting down).
- klyrs 6y agoFast forward to today, where Google entertains auctions for first-page listings and happily evicts trademark owners if they don't pay up.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoHey it was a walled-garden sales site, not my own. The same one Hasbro used to market their lame Scrabble game. And SEO is absolutely not 'marketing literature' which is defined as something the customer sees and reads. The word 'Scrabble' did not appear in that. No I think its a contortion to make those arguments.
- dspillett 6y agoYou could argue that SEO isn't marketing literature, but it is absolutely marketing process just like marketing literature is. > The same one Hasbro used to market their lame Scrabble game. > Unless either Hasbro got the website to release them Or the garden wasn't as walled as you had been lead to believe and the terms were included somewhere visible to search agents and Hasbro knew all about that from their own experience of the site. The association with your app and the mark was certainly visible as there was a direct mapping between the two via the search function. > (in which case they would simply have asked the website to remove them) Perhaps they did but the site said "copyright/trademarking isn't our problem, perhaps have your guys talk to their guys."?
- specialist 6y agoBut buying those search terms on an ad network is okay? Today's calvinball economy confuses me.