4 ms·

It does -- and if Youtube Music lets you upload music files like GPM did (not sure if they've added this feature yet or not, I know they claimed they would), th

It does -- and if Youtube Music lets you upload music files like GPM did (not sure if they've added this feature yet or not, I know they claimed they would), that's one avenue. However, I've noticed that the one album I've ever purchased through GPM is not available on YTM and even though I purchased it, it is still greyed out in my transferred playlists. Lesson learned -- I'm just glad I only ever made that mistake once and didn't lose a library (or would have to painstakingly download each album manually and reupload) EDIT: To be clear, not only did the "ownership" of the music not transfer, but (presumably) because of a change in licensing agreements the music has become entirely unavailable in any form. At least, it will once GPM goes offline.

whereistimbo 6y ago
Can't you download your purchased album using Google Takeout?
- whereistimbo 6y ago
  Today I've discovered that vajroli mudra while focusing on bindu can indeed relieve some tension on area around bindu. I've also discovered that tension on the back of the neck and bindu could lead to tics, relaxing these part helps reduce the tics. I remembered that my mom had said that tension on the brain will cause muscular tics.
gitweb 6y ago
You just admitted you were able to download the album. If you want to own the music then you download it. You don't buy a movie and then keep it at the store and say whenever I want to watch this to you have to keep it here for me indefinitely until I decide to watch it and then when I do you gotta keep holding onto it until next time.
- spijdar 6y ago
  You and the other comments are right -- this isn't the same as Amazon or other digital stores where you have no ability to download the content. However, I wouldn't compare this to a movie store, or a music store. At least while I used it, GPM wasn't positioned as a store where you buy music and take it home, it's an app/ecosystem where you listen to music. So I'd argue a more apt comparison is it's like buying a movie at a store with sofas and televisions for watching the movies, where you can purchase content and ask for it to be displayed, and can optionally take the disk home. Stretching the analogy too far probably, but GPM didn't exactly encourage downloading FWIW -- can only download a song twice ever through the web interface, or all at once through takeout, or through a chrome extension/app, otherwise it's all on the GPM app, where you're "supposed" to listen to it. You do have the right to download DRM-free music though, so at least GPM had that. ... youtube music on the other hand ...
  - gambiting 6y ago
    >>this isn't the same as Amazon or other digital stores where you have no ability to download the content. Admittedly I haven't done this for a year or two, but last time I bought an album on amazon it came with a digital download which was just DRM-free MP3 files. Maybe that's not the case anymore, I don't know.
  - Mindwipe 6y ago
    > You and the other comments are right -- this isn't the same as Amazon or other digital stores where you have no ability to download the content. You do have the ability to download films on Amazon. (They're DRMed, and you can't transfer them to another device, but they don't expire).
411111111111111 6y ago
that rings hollow considering youre able to download them at the moment as mp3. just because you paid money in an online service once doesn't mean you can expect to be able to redownload it forever going forward. they might've given you that service, but thats a very different complaint then what this article is about - which is that people that bought it cannot download it and its amazon's choice to revoke their access at their will.
hanklazard 6y ago
Well put, I’ve had to learn the same lesson. Now I use Bandcamp where I can properly purchase/own/download archival DRM-free music. It’s a great service.

whereistimbo 6y ago

Can't you download your purchased album using Google Takeout?

whereistimbo 6y ago
Today I've discovered that vajroli mudra while focusing on bindu can indeed relieve some tension on area around bindu. I've also discovered that tension on the back of the neck and bindu could lead to tics, relaxing these part helps reduce the tics. I remembered that my mom had said that tension on the brain will cause muscular tics.

gitweb 6y ago

You just admitted you were able to download the album. If you want to own the music then you download it. You don't buy a movie and then keep it at the store and say whenever I want to watch this to you have to keep it here for me indefinitely until I decide to watch it and then when I do you gotta keep holding onto it until next time.

spijdar 6y ago
You and the other comments are right -- this isn't the same as Amazon or other digital stores where you have no ability to download the content. However, I wouldn't compare this to a movie store, or a music store. At least while I used it, GPM wasn't positioned as a store where you buy music and take it home, it's an app/ecosystem where you listen to music. So I'd argue a more apt comparison is it's like buying a movie at a store with sofas and televisions for watching the movies, where you can purchase content and ask for it to be displayed, and can optionally take the disk home. Stretching the analogy too far probably, but GPM didn't exactly encourage downloading FWIW -- can only download a song twice ever through the web interface, or all at once through takeout, or through a chrome extension/app, otherwise it's all on the GPM app, where you're "supposed" to listen to it. You do have the right to download DRM-free music though, so at least GPM had that. ... youtube music on the other hand ...
- gambiting 6y ago
  >>this isn't the same as Amazon or other digital stores where you have no ability to download the content. Admittedly I haven't done this for a year or two, but last time I bought an album on amazon it came with a digital download which was just DRM-free MP3 files. Maybe that's not the case anymore, I don't know.
- Mindwipe 6y ago
  > You and the other comments are right -- this isn't the same as Amazon or other digital stores where you have no ability to download the content. You do have the ability to download films on Amazon. (They're DRMed, and you can't transfer them to another device, but they don't expire).

411111111111111 6y ago

that rings hollow considering youre able to download them at the moment as mp3. just because you paid money in an online service once doesn't mean you can expect to be able to redownload it forever going forward. they might've given you that service, but thats a very different complaint then what this article is about - which is that people that bought it cannot download it and its amazon's choice to revoke their access at their will.

hanklazard 6y ago

Well put, I’ve had to learn the same lesson. Now I use Bandcamp where I can properly purchase/own/download archival DRM-free music. It’s a great service.